The Smartest Thing You’ll Do Before Building Your LMS: Ask!
Imagine this: You’ve spent months researching, comparing features, and getting excited about building your shiny new Learning Management System (LMS). It launches with fanfare… only to be met with confusion, low adoption, and grumbles about missing features. That critical course? Turns out instructors need a workflow it doesn’t support. That mobile access everyone wanted? It’s clunky on half the devices used by your learners. The investment feels wasted, the promise unfulfilled.
This scenario is tragically common, and the culprit is often simple: Building in a vacuum. Jumping straight into development or procurement without deeply understanding the needs of the people who will actually use the system is a recipe for disappointment, wasted resources, and frustration. The most powerful weapon against this failure? Asking for feedback upfront.
Here’s why actively seeking input before you commit to building or buying an LMS isn’t just a good idea – it’s absolutely essential:
1. You Uncover Real Needs, Not Assumptions: We all have assumptions about what users want. Maybe you think instructors desperately need complex gamification, but what they really crave is a simpler way to grade essays or track attendance seamlessly. Feedback exposes the gap between your perception and their daily reality. It shifts the focus from “cool features” to “essential workflows.”
2. You Identify Hidden Pain Points & Workarounds: People are incredibly resourceful. They develop intricate workarounds using spreadsheets, shared drives, email chains, or even paper to manage learning tasks your current system (or lack thereof) doesn’t support. Asking “What frustrates you most about how we manage learning now?” or “What clumsy workarounds do you use?” reveals inefficiencies you can solve and critical requirements your new LMS must address.
3. You Build Buy-in and Ownership From Day One: When people feel heard, they become invested. Soliciting feedback isn’t just about gathering data; it’s about building relationships. It signals, “Your experience matters. This system is being built for you.” This early engagement fosters champions who will advocate for the LMS during rollout and beyond, significantly boosting adoption rates.
4. You Avoid Costly Mistakes and Re-Work: Discovering a fundamental mismatch after development has started or a contract is signed is incredibly expensive. Feedback upfront helps you prioritize core functionalities correctly. It might reveal that a seemingly “nice-to-have” feature is actually mission-critical for a key department, or that a feature you prioritized isn’t needed at all. This clarity prevents budget blowouts and painful mid-project pivots.
5. You Gain Insights into Technical Constraints & Opportunities: Don’t just ask about features; ask about context. What devices are learners using? What’s the typical internet bandwidth? Are there existing systems (HRIS, CRM, content libraries) the LMS needs to integrate with? Feedback from IT and users uncovers technical realities that will heavily influence your platform choice or development specifications.
Okay, I’m Convinced! How Do I Actually Ask?
Asking for feedback effectively requires strategy. Don’t just blast a vague survey. Be intentional:
1. Identify Your Key Stakeholders (and Their Unique Perspectives):
Learners (Employees, Students, Members): What makes learning engaging/easy/frustrating? How do they prefer to access content? What devices do they use? What reporting would be helpful? What support do they need?
Instructors/Facilitators/Trainers: What are their biggest administrative headaches? What pedagogical tools do they need (discussions, quizzes, assignment workflows)? How do they want to track progress? What integrations would save them time (e.g., gradebooks)?
Content Developers: How do they create and update materials? What formats are essential? What metadata do they need? How important are version control and collaboration tools?
Administrators & Managers: What reporting is crucial (completion rates, time spent, skill gaps)? What user management features are needed? What compliance tracking is essential? How should enrolments be handled?
IT Department: What are security, scalability, and integration requirements? What deployment model is preferred (cloud, on-premise)? What existing systems must it connect with? What are bandwidth limitations?
2. Choose the Right Feedback Methods (Mix and Match!):
Structured Surveys: Great for quantitative data (ranking priorities) and reaching a large audience. Keep them focused and concise. Use scales (e.g., 1-5 importance) and specific questions (“How often do you…?”).
Focus Groups: Invaluable for qualitative depth. Bring together small groups of similar stakeholders (e.g., all instructors, a mix of learners) for guided discussions. Probe deeper on survey responses and uncover the “why” behind needs.
One-on-One Interviews: Essential for busy experts or those with highly specific needs (e.g., key department heads, lead instructors). Allows for deep dives into complex workflows.
Observation: If possible, watch people perform current learning-related tasks. Where do they pause, sigh, or switch to another tool? This reveals friction points they might not articulate.
Document Analysis: Review existing training materials, process docs, and support tickets related to current learning challenges. What recurring issues appear?
3. Ask the Right Questions:
Focus on Goals & Problems: “What are the top 3 things you need to achieve with our learning programs?” “What’s the single biggest challenge you face managing/delivering training currently?”
Explore Current State & Pain Points: “Walk me through how you currently [run a course/complete training].” “What parts of this process are most time-consuming or frustrating?” “What tools do you use outside the current system (if any) to get things done?”
Envision the Future State: “If you could wave a magic wand, what would this new system do to make your life easier or learning better?” “Describe your ideal learner/instructor experience.”
Be Specific About Features (Gently): Instead of “Do you want quizzes?”, ask “How important is the ability to create different question types (multiple choice, essay, matching)?” or “What kind of feedback do learners need after assessments?”
Ask for Examples: “Can you give me an example of a time when [current system] didn’t meet your need?”
Turning Feedback into Action: The Bridge to a Better LMS
Collecting feedback is only half the battle. The magic happens when you synthesize and act:
1. Organize Ruthlessly: Categorize feedback by stakeholder group, theme (e.g., “Assessment Needs,” “Reporting Requirements,” “User Management”), and priority (Critical, Important, Nice-to-Have).
2. Identify Patterns & Conflicts: Look for recurring requests and pain points across different groups. Also note where stakeholder needs might conflict (e.g., instructors wanting complex features vs. learners wanting simplicity) – these require careful resolution.
3. Define Clear Requirements: Translate the feedback into concrete, actionable requirements for your LMS. Instead of “Instructors want easier grading,” specify: “The LMS must allow bulk downloading of assignment submissions in common formats (DOCX, PDF) and provide a streamlined interface for leaving inline comments and entering grades.”
4. Share Back & Validate: Don’t disappear after gathering feedback! Summarize what you heard (themes, key priorities) and share it with participants. Ask: “Did we capture your input accurately?” “Did we miss anything major?” This closes the loop and builds further trust.
5. Use It to Evaluate & Guide: This feedback becomes your North Star. Use it to:
Evaluate Vendors: Does this LMS solution genuinely address our validated top priorities?
Guide Development: If building custom, these requirements are your development roadmap.
Set Realistic Expectations: Manage stakeholder expectations about what features will be included in the initial launch (Phase 1) based on priority and resources.
Beyond the Build: Feedback as an Ongoing Superpower
The power of asking doesn’t end once the LMS is live. The feedback skills you cultivate now should become part of your continuous improvement cycle. Regularly check in with users:
Post-Launch: “How is the new system working for you? What’s better? What’s still frustrating or missing?”
Ongoing: Use surveys, feedback buttons within the LMS, and open forums to gather input for future enhancements.
Before Major Updates: Re-engage stakeholders before adding significant new features or changing workflows.
The Bottom Line:
Building or selecting an LMS is a significant commitment. Skipping the crucial step of gathering comprehensive, structured feedback from all key stakeholders is like setting sail without a map. You might eventually get somewhere, but the journey will be rough, expensive, and you might not reach the destination you intended.
Taking the time to genuinely ask, listen, understand, and incorporate the needs of your learners, instructors, admins, and IT team before you build is the single most effective way to ensure your LMS investment delivers real value. It transforms your project from a technical implementation into a solution co-created with its users – paving the way for higher adoption, greater satisfaction, and ultimately, more successful learning outcomes. Don’t build your LMS in the dark. Turn on the lights by asking first.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Smartest Thing You’ll Do Before Building Your LMS: Ask