The Parenting Habit I Swore to Break: Why Silence Isn’t Golden
We carry our childhoods with us, especially when we become parents. Patterns echo, lessons linger, and sometimes, habits we experienced firsthand become the very ones we vow never to replicate. For me, the habit I consciously refuse to pass down is one cloaked in silence: the withdrawal of emotional connection as punishment – often known as the “silent treatment” or shutting down emotionally.
Growing up, this manifested subtly but potently. After a disagreement, a perceived transgression, or simply a moment of parental frustration, the atmosphere would shift. Conversations ceased. Eye contact vanished. A palpable chill replaced warmth. It wasn’t a shouted consequence; it was a suffocating void. The message, intended or not, was clear: “You are not worthy of my presence, my voice, my connection right now because of what you did or who you are in this moment.”
Why This Habit Haunts:
The impact was profound and lasting. Instead of learning about the behaviour that caused the issue, I learned to associate conflict and parental displeasure with deep-seated fear and insecurity:
1. Fear of Abandonment: That silent withdrawal felt like the precursor to being utterly alone, unloved, and abandoned. It triggered a primal panic.
2. Emotional Confusion: Without explanation or discussion, I was left scrambling to interpret the silence. What exactly was wrong? How bad was it? Was it me, fundamentally?
3. Inability to Process Conflict: It modeled avoidance, not resolution. It taught me that conflict meant shutting down and retreating, not communicating and repairing.
4. Internalized Shame: The silence felt like a judgment on my entire being, not just my actions. It bred a sense of being intrinsically “bad” or unlovable when I made mistakes.
5. Damaged Trust: The security of unconditional connection felt fragile and conditional, easily revoked.
Breaking the Cycle: Choosing Connection Over Withdrawal
Becoming a parent myself brought this habit into sharp, uncomfortable focus. I knew, viscerally, that I could not use this tool. The cost was too high. So, how do I navigate those inevitable moments of frustration, anger, or disappointment with my own child without falling into that familiar, destructive pattern?
1. Name the Feeling (Mine and Theirs): Instead of shutting down, I strive to articulate my own emotional state in an age-appropriate way: “I’m feeling really frustrated right now,” or “I need a minute because I’m upset.” Equally important is helping my child name theirs: “You look really angry. Is that how you feel?”
2. Take a Conscious Pause (Not a Shutdown): Recognizing when I’m overwhelmed and might want to withdraw, I explicitly state my need for a short break: “I’m feeling too upset to talk calmly. I’m going to sit quietly for five minutes in the next room to calm down, and then we will talk about this.” This is radically different from storming off in icy silence. It communicates intent to return and resolve.
3. Separate the Behaviour from the Child: This is crucial. “I don’t like it when you throw your toys; it’s not safe,” is fundamentally different from silence that implies, “I don’t like you right now.” Emphasizing that the action is the problem, not their core self.
4. Prioritize Repair: After conflicts cool down, making the effort to reconnect is vital. A hug, a calm conversation, an apology if I lost my temper (“I’m sorry I yelled, that wasn’t the best way for me to handle my frustration”). This teaches that relationships can withstand disagreements and be mended.
5. Model Healthy Conflict Resolution: Showing my child that disagreements happen, feelings get big, but we can talk through them respectfully. It’s okay to disagree with someone you love. We demonstrate how to listen, validate feelings (“I see why that made you mad”), and find solutions together.
6. Acknowledge Imperfection: I don’t always get it right. Sometimes, in the heat of the moment, I might withdraw more than I intend. The key difference? Recognizing it quickly, naming it (“Wow, I just got really quiet. I was feeling overwhelmed, not mad at you”), and repairing the connection.
The Science Behind the Shift:
This conscious effort to avoid emotional withdrawal isn’t just about feelings; it’s rooted in what we know about healthy child development. Psychologists like Dr. Dan Siegel emphasize the importance of “connection before correction.” When children feel emotionally safe and connected to their caregivers, they are far more receptive to learning boundaries and understanding consequences. Emotional withdrawal, conversely, activates stress responses in the brain, hindering learning and fostering insecurity. Secure attachment, built on consistent emotional availability (even during conflict), provides the foundation for resilience, empathy, and healthy relationships later in life.
The Legacy I Choose
The silence I experienced wasn’t malicious; it was likely a learned coping mechanism passed down through generations. But understanding its origin doesn’t diminish its impact. Choosing differently is an act of breaking that cycle. It’s choosing to teach my child that their worth is unconditional, that mistakes are opportunities for learning (not abandonment), and that love means showing up, especially when things are hard.
Refusing to repeat this habit is about replacing fear with security, shame with understanding, and silence with the powerful, connective language of emotion – spoken aloud, even when it’s difficult. It’s the hardest, most rewarding parenting commitment I’ve made: ensuring my child always knows that my love and presence are constants, not privileges revoked by imperfection. The silence ends with me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Parenting Habit I Swore to Break: Why Silence Isn’t Golden