The Ones Who Always Raise Their Hands: Unpacking the “Teacher’s Pet” Phenomenon (And Why It’s Always Them)
You know the type. The hand shoots up before the teacher finishes the question. They’re always the first to volunteer, the first to finish the extra credit, the one whose homework seems perpetually pristine. When praise gets handed out, their name seems to float to the top. A collective, sometimes silent, sigh ripples through the classroom: “Ugh… It’s always them.”
The “teacher’s pet.” It’s a label loaded with baggage, whispered in hallways, rolled eyes in the back row. But what’s really going on here? Why does this dynamic exist, and what does it mean for everyone involved? More importantly – how do we, as students, teachers, or even former students looking back, navigate this tricky territory without falling into resentment or unfairness?
Beyond the Label: Why “Them”?
Let’s be honest – it’s rarely just about sucking up (though that element definitely exists sometimes). Several factors often converge to create that “always them” feeling:
1. The Effort & Enthusiasm Factor: Often, the student labeled the “pet” is genuinely engaged, prepared, and enthusiastic. They participate because they want to. For a teacher managing 20+ students, this consistent, positive contribution is incredibly noticeable and, frankly, a relief. It creates momentum in the lesson.
2. The Reliability Anchor: Teachers need students they can count on. The “pet” often becomes that anchor – the one who will answer when no one else will, the one whose group work gets done, the one who remembers deadlines. This reliability builds trust, making the teacher more likely to rely on them, perpetuating the cycle. It’s less about favoritism and more about predictability in a sometimes chaotic environment.
3. The Feedback Loop: Positive reinforcement works. When a student participates well and gets praise or a good grade, they’re more likely to participate again. The teacher, seeing this student “gets it,” might call on them more to move the lesson forward, unintentionally sidelining others who need more encouragement to find their voice.
4. Alignment with Expectations: Some students naturally align with the teacher’s preferred learning or behavioral style. They might be naturally quiet and attentive, excel at the type of work assigned, or simply share the teacher’s passion for the subject. This natural fit can look like favoritism from the outside.
5. The “Polishing” Element (The Real Annoyance): This is where the negative perception truly festers – the student who goes beyond genuine enthusiasm into obvious flattery, constantly telling the teacher how wonderful they are, bringing small gifts, or overly reporting on other students’ minor missteps. This behavior feels manipulative and is understandably grating. It’s the core of the “suck-up” stereotype.
The Ripple Effect: Why It Bugs Us (And Why It Matters)
So, why does “It’s always them” trigger such a universal groan?
Perceived Unfairness: The core issue. When one student seems to consistently get praise, opportunities, or (students believe) easier grading, it feels fundamentally unjust. It undermines the idea of a level playing field.
Feeling Invisible: Other students, especially quieter ones or those who struggle, can feel their efforts go unnoticed. Why try if Suzie Always-Raises-Her-Hand is going to get the spotlight anyway?
Social Isolation: The “teacher’s pet” label is social poison. It can isolate that student from peers, painting them as untrustworthy or solely interested in adult approval. This is incredibly damaging, regardless of the student’s actual motives.
Distrust in the Teacher: If students perceive favoritism, it erodes their trust in the teacher’s fairness and judgment. This damages the entire classroom atmosphere and learning dynamic.
Discouragement: Seeing the same person constantly praised can make others feel their contributions are less valuable, discouraging participation and effort.
Teacher’s Pet: Like or Dislike? It’s Complicated.
Asking “do you guys like or not like teacher pets?” reveals the nuance. It’s rarely a simple binary.
Dislike (Mostly): The negativity stems from the perception of unfair advantage and the “polishing” behavior. Students dislike feeling like their own efforts are ignored in comparison. They dislike the social awkwardness the label creates. They dislike the feeling that the game is rigged.
Respect (Sometimes): If the “pet” is genuinely brilliant, hardworking, and kind (not a tattletale or flatterer), there can be underlying respect, even if accompanied by annoyance. Students might grudgingly admit, “Yeah, they do know the answers.”
Ambivalence: Often, it’s a mix. Annoyance at the dynamic, perhaps envy, maybe a dash of respect, and definitely a desire for the teacher to spread the attention more evenly.
Beyond “Them”: Creating a Fairer Classroom
The “It’s always them” phenomenon isn’t inevitable. It requires awareness and effort from both sides:
For Teachers:
Conscious Rotation: Make a deliberate effort to call on all students. Use random name generators, popsicle sticks, or seating charts to ensure broader participation. Don’t just rely on the eager hands.
Praise Wisely & Widely: Recognize effort, improvement, and unique contributions as much as (or more than) constant correctness. Find ways to authentically praise quieter students or those working hard behind the scenes.
Examine Biases: Are you unconsciously favoring students who are like you? Who learn like you? Who remind you of yourself at that age? Self-awareness is crucial.
Address “Polishing” Subtly: While you can’t punish enthusiasm, avoid rewarding obvious, excessive flattery. Redirect it gently (“Thanks, Sarah, but let’s focus on the topic”).
Build Relationships: Get to know all your students. Understand their strengths, challenges, and what motivates them. This makes it easier to value diverse contributions.
For Students:
Speak Up (Appropriately): If you feel overlooked, find a respectful way to ask for opportunities. “I’d like a chance to answer next time” or “Could I help with that task too?” can be effective.
Focus on Your Own Learning: Don’t let resentment derail your progress. Engage for yourself, not just for recognition. Your effort is valuable regardless of who the teacher calls on.
Understand the Teacher’s View: Teachers are human. Managing a classroom is complex. Genuine enthusiasm is helpful, even if it seems like it gets all the attention. Try not to assume the worst motives of the “pet” or the teacher without evidence.
Be Kind: Social isolation hurts. Avoid ganging up on the “teacher’s pet.” They might be just as uncomfortable with the label as you are annoyed by it.
The Takeaway: It Doesn’t Have to Be “Always Them”
The “teacher’s pet” dynamic is a complex dance of human nature, classroom management, perception, and sometimes, genuine enthusiasm or unfortunate flattery. While it’s easy to grumble “It’s always them,” recognizing the why behind it is the first step.
The goal isn’t to squash enthusiasm but to cultivate an environment where every student feels seen, valued, and capable of contributing. It requires teachers to be mindful distributors of attention and opportunities, and it requires students to communicate needs respectfully and focus on their own growth. When that happens, the phrase “It’s always them” loses its sting, replaced by a classroom where many hands feel welcome to rise.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Ones Who Always Raise Their Hands: Unpacking the “Teacher’s Pet” Phenomenon (And Why It’s Always Them)