The Kamehameha Schools: Preserving Heritage Under Legal Siege
For over 135 years, the Kamehameha Schools have stood as a beacon of hope and cultural preservation in Hawaiʻi. Founded by the visionary will of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, the last direct descendant of King Kamehameha I, these schools represent a unique promise: to educate children of Native Hawaiian ancestry using the vast lands and resources Pauahi entrusted for that very purpose. They are, quite literally, the only private K-12 school system in the entire world dedicated exclusively to serving students with Native Hawaiian lineage. It’s a legacy built on cultural restoration, academic excellence, and fulfilling a sacred kuleana (responsibility) to uplift a people who faced devastating cultural and demographic decline. Yet, today, this vital institution finds itself facing an unprecedented legal challenge that threatens its very core mission.
Princess Pauahi witnessed firsthand the catastrophic impact of Western contact and disease on her people. Determined to create a better future, she directed that her vast estate be used solely to create and maintain schools for Native Hawaiian children. This wasn’t born out of exclusionary intent against others, but from a deep, urgent need to provide educational opportunities specifically designed to nurture Hawaiian identity, language, and values – opportunities systematically denied to Hawaiians for generations. The Kamehameha Schools became the physical manifestation of this profound aloha (love) for her lāhui (nation).
The impact of Kamehameha is undeniable. Campuses on Oʻahu, Maui, and Hawaiʻi Island serve thousands of students, offering a rigorous education steeped in Hawaiian culture. Students learn ʻŌlelo Hawaiʻi (Hawaiian language), practice traditional arts like hula and chant, study Hawaiian history from an indigenous perspective, and develop a deep connection to the ʻāina (land). Beyond academics, Kamehameha fosters a powerful sense of belonging and pride, empowering generations of Native Hawaiian leaders, scholars, artists, and community stewards. It’s a place where “E ola mau ka ʻōlelo Hawaiʻi” (May the Hawaiian language live forever) is more than a motto; it’s a lived reality.
This unique, ancestry-based admissions policy is central to fulfilling Pauahi’s will and addressing the specific historical and educational needs of Native Hawaiians. It operates under federal law recognizing the special trust relationship between the U.S. government and Native peoples. Kamehameha’s policy is fundamentally different from race-conscious affirmative action programs in public universities, which aim for diversity within a broader population. Kamehameha exists because of a private trust, established with specific assets, for a specific beneficiary group defined by indigenous ancestry, not simply race.
However, this very policy is now under direct legal attack. The organization at the forefront is Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA), the same non-profit group that successfully argued before the U.S. Supreme Court to dismantle affirmative action in college admissions (the Harvard and UNC cases). SFFA has filed a federal lawsuit against Kamehameha Schools, arguing that its admissions preference for Native Hawaiians constitutes unlawful racial discrimination under federal civil rights law.
SFFA’s argument hinges on the claim that Native Hawaiian ancestry is essentially a racial classification, not a political or indigenous status deserving unique legal recognition in this context. They view Kamehameha’s policy through the same lens as the affirmative action programs they successfully challenged, ignoring the deep historical context, the unique trust relationship, and the explicit terms of Princess Pauahi’s bequest.
For the Native Hawaiian community, this lawsuit feels like a profound betrayal and a direct assault on their right to self-determination and cultural survival. They see Kamehameha Schools not as discriminatory, but as reparative – a crucial mechanism to counteract centuries of dispossession, suppression of language and culture, and socioeconomic disadvantage. The schools are viewed as a “living amends,” a tangible way to honor Princess Pauahi’s directive and rebuild what was nearly lost.
“This isn’t about exclusion; it’s about fulfilling a sacred trust and addressing generations of neglect,” explains a Kamehameha graduate and educator. “Our keiki (children) deserve a place where their identity is the foundation, not an afterthought. SFFA doesn’t understand our history or our unique relationship with the U.S. government.” The legal battle strikes at the heart of Hawaiian sovereignty and the right to maintain institutions dedicated to indigenous resurgence.
The implications are vast. If SFFA prevails, it wouldn’t just change Kamehameha’s admissions; it could dismantle the core principle upon which the entire institution was built, potentially forcing it to abandon its mission to prioritize Native Hawaiian students. Such a ruling could also send shockwaves through other Native Hawaiian trusts and programs, and potentially impact similar institutions serving other Indigenous groups across the nation, eroding hard-won rights to self-governance and cultural preservation.
Kamehameha Schools, backed by the overwhelming support of the Native Hawaiian community, is mounting a vigorous defense. They argue passionately that their admissions policy is legally sound, rooted in federal recognition of Native Hawaiian rights and the specific terms of a private charitable trust. They emphasize that the schools represent educational opportunity specifically designed to remedy past injustices against Native Hawaiians, a distinction SFFA deliberately ignores.
As the legal process unfolds, the future of this unique Hawaiian institution hangs in the balance. The fight for Kamehameha Schools transcends a single admissions policy; it’s a fight to honor the vision of a princess, to preserve a culture, and to affirm the right of Indigenous peoples to create spaces where their children can thrive with their heritage intact. As one trustee recently stated, “We will fight with every fiber of our being to protect Princess Pauahi’s gift to her people.” The world watches as this Hawaiian treasure defends its legacy against an all-too-familiar legal storm.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Kamehameha Schools: Preserving Heritage Under Legal Siege