The Kamehameha Schools: A Hawaiian Legacy Under Threat
Imagine a school born from a royal vision, fueled by profound loss, and dedicated to lifting an entire people. A school where the chants of ancestors echo in modern hallways, where children learn not just math and science, but the deep meaning of aloha ‘āina (love for the land) and their unique kuleana (responsibility). This is Kamehameha Schools, a beacon of hope and identity for Native Hawaiians. Unique on the global stage, it stands as the only private K-12 institution in the world exclusively dedicated to educating those of Native Hawaiian ancestry. But this vital institution is facing a serious legal challenge that strikes at the very heart of its mission, spearheaded by the same non-profit organization that recently dismantled affirmative action in higher education across the United States.
The story begins with Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop, the last direct descendant of King Kamehameha I, the unifier of the Hawaiian Islands. Witnessing the devastating decline of her people following Western contact – their population ravaged by disease, their lands increasingly lost, their culture suppressed – she made an extraordinary decision. Upon her death in 1884, her immense estate was transformed into a perpetual trust dedicated solely to the education and upliftment of children with Native Hawaiian ancestry. Her will was explicit: the schools built and supported by her trust were for “the children of Hawaii,” understood then and legally interpreted since as Native Hawaiian children. This wasn’t exclusion born of prejudice, but a targeted remedy for profound historical injustice and cultural erosion.
For nearly 140 years, Kamehameha Schools has fulfilled Pauahi’s vision. Its campuses – stretching from preschool to high school – provide a world-class education steeped in Hawaiian values, language, history, and culture. Students learn ‘ōlelo Hawai‘i (Hawaiian language), participate in traditional hula and chant, study Hawaiian navigation and sustainable agriculture, while simultaneously mastering rigorous academic curricula. The impact is undeniable. Kamehameha graduates become leaders, innovators, and cultural practitioners, forming the backbone of efforts to revitalize Hawaiian language and traditions across the islands and beyond. It’s a powerful engine for reversing historical wrongs by empowering the descendants of those who suffered them.
However, this very mission, this targeted remedy, is now under direct legal assault. The non-profit group “Students for Fair Admissions” (SFFA), led by Edward Blum, has set its sights on Kamehameha Schools. This is the same organization that successfully argued before the Supreme Court that race-conscious admissions programs at Harvard and the University of North Carolina violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment, effectively ending affirmative action as practiced by many universities.
SFFA’s argument against Kamehameha hinges on applying similar logic to a fundamentally different context. They allege that the school’s admissions policy, giving preference to applicants of Native Hawaiian ancestry, constitutes illegal racial discrimination under federal civil rights laws, specifically Section 1981 of the Civil Rights Act of 1866. They argue that it unfairly excludes non-Native Hawaiians solely based on race.
For Kamehameha Schools and the vast majority of the Native Hawaiian community, this lawsuit represents a profound misunderstanding and misrepresentation of their unique status and history. Their defense rests on several critical pillars:
1. A Private Trust, Not a Public Institution: Unlike the universities involved in the affirmative action cases, Kamehameha is a privately funded institution, operating under the terms of a specific charitable trust established over a century ago. It does not receive federal funding contingent on non-discrimination compliance in the same way public entities do.
2. Political Classification, Not Strictly Racial: Kamehameha argues that Native Hawaiians are recognized as an indigenous people with a distinct political status, similar to Native American tribes, rather than simply a racial group. The admissions policy is based on this political/ancestral classification tied to the trust’s purpose, not solely on race.
3. The Remedial Purpose: The core justification remains Princess Pauahi’s intent: to remedy the specific, documented disadvantages suffered by Native Hawaiians due to colonization, dispossession, and cultural suppression. The school’s existence is intrinsically linked to addressing this historical trauma.
4. Legal Precedent: While challenged before, Kamehameha’s admissions policy has generally been upheld. A key precedent is the 2003 settlement of the Doe v. Kamehameha Schools lawsuit. While not a Supreme Court ruling, the settlement preserved the school’s ability to maintain its preference while also acknowledging its private trust status and unique mission. Courts have often recognized the distinct legal relationship between the U.S. government and Native peoples.
The stakes couldn’t be higher. If SFFA prevails, it wouldn’t just change an admissions policy; it would dismantle the central pillar of Princess Pauahi Bishop’s legacy. It could force Kamehameha Schools to admit students without regard to Hawaiian ancestry, fundamentally altering its character and diluting its core mission of cultural revitalization and empowerment specifically for Native Hawaiians.
The implications extend far beyond the school gates. A loss for Kamehameha would send shockwaves through other institutions serving Native communities, potentially undermining programs designed to support Native Hawaiians in areas like health, housing, and economic development. It would be seen as another blow to the self-determination and cultural survival of Native Hawaiians, echoing the painful history of loss they have endured.
Supporters of the school view SFFA’s lawsuit as a cynical attempt to weaponize civil rights law against the very people those laws were partly intended to protect. They see it as an attack not just on an educational policy, but on the right of an indigenous people to preserve their identity and uplift their own community through self-directed institutions.
Kamehameha Schools represents more than just classrooms and textbooks. It embodies resilience. It stands as a testament to the foresight of a princess who sought to save her people through knowledge and cultural strength. It’s a vibrant community where Hawaiian identity isn’t just studied; it’s lived, celebrated, and passed on to the next generation. The legal battle ahead is fierce, pitting a powerful national organization against a unique Hawaiian institution built on a sacred trust. The outcome will determine whether Princess Pauahi Bishop’s profound vision for her people can endure, or whether it will become another chapter in the long story of Native Hawaiian dispossession. The world watches as this singular school, born of aloha and purpose, fights to preserve its essential role in shaping the future of Hawai‘i.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Kamehameha Schools: A Hawaiian Legacy Under Threat