The Heavy Little Question: “Do I Deserve an A+?” Unpacking the Weight of Perfection
That question, whispered internally or debated anxiously with friends, carries more weight than any single assignment ever could: “Do I deserve an A+?” It’s rarely just about the grade itself. It’s a tangled knot of effort, expectation, self-worth, and the often-unspoken pressure cooker of academic achievement. Let’s untangle it together.
The Burden of the Plus
First, acknowledge the sheer pressure. An A is excellent, recognized universally as top-tier work. But the “+”? That tiny symbol elevates it to something almost mythical – perfection, flawless execution, beyond reproach. It’s not just “did well”; it’s “couldn’t have done better.” That’s an incredibly high bar, and feeling the strain to reach it, or the doubt after achieving it, is completely understandable.
The question often arises in specific, pressure-filled moments:
After Submitting a Major Project: You poured your heart and soul into it. Was it truly perfect? Did you miss something crucial? Could you have researched one more source, polished one more sentence?
Facing a Challenging Exam: You studied relentlessly, but the test threw curveballs. You think you did well, maybe even very well, but was it A+ material? Did your performance match your preparation?
Comparing Yourself to Others: You see a classmate consistently getting top marks. You wonder: Is their work genuinely superior, or are they just better at playing the game? What does it take to reach their level?
Internal Pressure: Sometimes, the loudest critic is inside your own head. High personal standards can make even objectively excellent work feel insufficient. The drive for perfection can make an A feel like a failure if it wasn’t the elusive A+.
Decoding “Deserve” – Effort vs. Outcome
This is where the core tension lies. What does “deserve” actually mean in this context?
The Effort Argument: “I worked harder than anyone. I sacrificed sleep, social time, everything. Doesn’t that deserve the highest recognition?” This perspective links the grade directly to the sheer quantity of input – the hours logged, the pages written. And effort should be recognized! But…
The Outcome Argument: “…But does effort automatically equal flawless mastery of the subject and execution of the task?” This viewpoint prioritizes the final product’s quality, alignment with learning objectives, and demonstration of understanding, regardless of how many hours it took. Sometimes, brilliance appears effortless; other times, immense effort yields solid but not flawless results.
The truth is, deserving an A+ usually requires a potent combination:
1. Deep Understanding: Truly grasping the core concepts, theories, and nuances of the material, not just memorizing facts.
2. Exceptional Execution: Applying that understanding skillfully. This means clear, insightful analysis, persuasive argumentation (where required), meticulous attention to detail (grammar, formatting, citations), and often, a spark of originality or critical thinking that elevates the work.
3. Meeting & Exceeding Standards: Not just fulfilling the rubric, but demonstrating insights or skills that go demonstrably beyond the basic requirements. It shows you didn’t just do the assignment; you mastered its intent.
4. Consistent Excellence: While a single assignment might earn an A+, the feeling of deserving it often comes from sustained high-quality work throughout a course, proving it wasn’t a fluke.
Beyond the Report Card: The Emotional Toll
Asking “Do I deserve an A+?” isn’t always a purely academic inquiry. It’s frequently intertwined with:
Self-Worth: It’s dangerously easy to equate your value as a person with the letters on your transcript. An A+ can feel like validation; anything less can feel like rejection or proof of inadequacy. This is a dangerous trap.
Fear of Failure (or Success): The pressure to maintain perfection can be paralyzing. Fear of not getting the A+ next time can be as debilitating as the fear of failing outright. Conversely, achieving it consistently can create immense pressure to never slip.
External Validation: Seeking approval from parents, teachers, peers, or even future universities. The A+ becomes a currency for earning that validation.
Burnout: The relentless pursuit of the “+” can lead to exhaustion, anxiety, and a loss of genuine passion for learning. The process stops being about growth and becomes solely about the outcome.
Redefining Success: Shifting the Focus
So, how do we navigate this heavy question without letting it crush us?
1. Separate Worth from Work: Consciously remind yourself: Your grade is an assessment of a specific piece of work at a specific moment, NOT a judgment of your intelligence, character, or future potential. You are infinitely more valuable than any letter grade.
2. Focus on Mastery, Not Just Marks: Shift your primary goal from “getting the A+” to “truly understanding this deeply.” When mastery is the aim, high grades often follow naturally as a byproduct, and the anxiety lessens. Ask: “What did I learn? How did I grow?”
3. Understand the Rubric (and Talk to Your Teacher): What does an A+ actually look like for this specific assignment or class? Don’t guess – refer to the grading criteria. If unsure, ask the teacher for clarification before submission or after grading. Understanding the target makes hitting it (or understanding why you didn’t) much clearer.
4. Evaluate Holistically: Instead of obsessing over a single +, look at your overall progress. Did you significantly improve? Did you tackle a weakness? Did you contribute meaningfully to class discussions? These are profound successes.
5. Acknowledge Effort, Value Growth: Celebrate your hard work! Recognize the discipline and dedication it took. Also, value the learning that came from challenges, even if the outcome wasn’t perfect. A B+ earned through overcoming a significant hurdle might represent more genuine growth than an easy A.
6. Challenge Perfectionism: Understand that perfection is often an illusion and an unreasonable standard. Excellence is achievable; perfection rarely is, and striving for it can be counterproductive. Aim for outstanding, insightful, well-crafted work – that is worthy of high praise.
7. Embrace “Good Enough”: Sometimes, delivering very good work that meets requirements without draining your well-being is the smarter, healthier choice. It allows you to sustain effort across all your responsibilities.
The Liberating Answer
So, do you deserve an A+? The honest answer is complex. It depends on the quality and depth of that specific work measured against clear standards. It might mean acknowledging a truly exceptional performance. More often than not, however, the question stems from a deeper place of doubt or pressure.
The more important, liberating question isn’t about deserving a specific symbol, but: “Did I engage deeply, learn meaningfully, and produce work I can be genuinely proud of based on my effort and understanding?”
If the answer to that is yes, then you’ve achieved something significant, regardless of the final letter. You deserve respect – especially your own. Let go of the crushing weight of the “+” and focus on the real substance of learning and growth. That’s the success that truly lasts.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Heavy Little Question: “Do I Deserve an A+