The Gift Card Dilemma: Should You Ever Cash It In Without Telling Your Grown-Up Kid?
That gift card you thoughtfully chose for your adult child’s birthday last year? The one tucked away in their wallet, seemingly forgotten? Or maybe it’s still sitting in the birthday card envelope on their desk, months later. You notice it every time you visit. A little voice whispers: “It’s just gathering dust… that’s money going to waste… I could really use it for groceries this week…” The temptation to quietly redeem it yourself – without ever mentioning it – feels surprisingly potent. But should you? Let’s unpack this surprisingly common parental quandary.
The Siren Song of the Unused Gift Card
First, let’s acknowledge why the idea feels tempting. It’s rarely about greed. More often, it’s driven by:
1. Perceived Waste: You see value sitting idle. That card represents money not being used, potentially expiring, or worse, getting lost forever. It feels like watching cash slowly dissolve.
2. Practical Need: Times can be tight. Seeing that unused $50 or $100 while facing a real expense can make it feel like a harmless, victimless solution. “They clearly don’t want it,” you reason.
3. Frustration: You put effort into choosing it! Maybe it was for their favorite store or restaurant. Seeing it ignored can feel like a rejection of your gesture, fueling a subtle resentment.
4. Convenience: It’s right there! The justification builds quickly: They don’t know I’m taking it, they weren’t using it anyway, what’s the harm?
The Unseen Costs of Cashing In (Without Consent)
Here’s where it gets tricky. While the act of redeeming the card might seem harmless, the secrecy and the violation of ownership carry significant weight:
1. Breach of Trust (Even If They Never Find Out): Trust is the bedrock of healthy adult relationships with your children. Secretly taking something you gave them, regardless of its perceived use, erodes that foundation. It introduces a subtle, unspoken dishonesty into the dynamic. Would you secretly take cash out of their wallet if you saw it sitting there unused? A gift card functions the same way – it’s their property once given.
2. Undermining Their Autonomy: Your adult child is, well, an adult. They have the right to manage their possessions (even poorly!). Maybe they are saving it for something special. Maybe they forgot but would be delighted to rediscover it later. Perhaps they simply haven’t gotten around to it yet. Taking away their agency to decide its fate treats them like a child who can’t manage their things.
3. The Risk of Discovery: Imagine the fallout if they do find out. “Mom, Dad, did you take that gift card?” That conversation is incredibly awkward and damaging. It instantly frames you as untrustworthy over something seemingly small. The hurt and confusion would likely far outweigh the card’s monetary value.
4. Devaluing the Gift: The essence of a gift is the transfer of ownership without strings attached. Secretly redeeming it retroactively turns the gift into a conditional loan. It sends the subconscious message: “My gifts aren’t really yours; I retain control.”
5. A Slippery Slope: If it’s okay to take back an unused gift card, where does it stop? Is it okay to “borrow” clothes they haven’t worn in a while without asking? To reclaim a tool you gave them because they aren’t using it right now? Respecting boundaries is paramount.
Better Paths: What To Do Instead
Resisting the cash-in urge doesn’t mean you have to silently watch the card expire. Try these respectful alternatives:
1. The Gentle Reminder: Casually mention it during a chat. “Hey, I was just thinking, whatever happened to that gift card for [Store] I gave you for your birthday? Hope you found something fun to get with it!” This prompts them to remember and use it without pressure.
2. The Curious Inquiry: Frame it as concern, not criticism. “I noticed that gift card on your desk the other day. Just curious, haven’t found anything you like there lately?” This opens a dialogue about their preferences (maybe the store isn’t appealing anymore, useful intel for future gifts!).
3. The Expiration Date Alert: If it’s nearing expiry, tell them! “Hey, just a heads-up, I think that card for [Store] might expire next month. Wouldn’t want you to lose it!” This shows you care about their potential loss.
4. The Direct Ask (If Truly Necessary): If you genuinely need financial help and feel the relationship is strong enough, be honest. “This is awkward to ask, but things are really tight right now. I noticed the gift card I gave you hasn’t been used. Would you consider letting me have it back? Totally understand if not!” This respects their autonomy and avoids deception. Be prepared for any answer.
5. Let It Go (Literally and Figuratively): Sometimes, the healthiest thing is simply to accept that the gift card belongs to them, and its fate is their decision. Part of loving an adult child is releasing control over the things we give them, even when we perceive them as “wasted.” It’s a practice in respect.
The Core Principle: It’s Theirs, Not Yours
Ultimately, the question boils down to a fundamental principle of respect and ownership. Once a gift is given, it unequivocally belongs to the recipient. Your feelings about how they use it, or don’t use it, are secondary to that fact.
Redeeming a gift card you gave your adult child without their knowledge isn’t a harmless act of recycling. It’s a small but potent act of boundary-crossing and dishonesty that can chip away at the trust and mutual respect vital to your relationship. The convenience or perceived practicality simply doesn’t outweigh the potential cost to the connection you value most.
So, the next time you spot that forgotten card, take a deep breath. Remember the spirit in which it was given. Choose the path of respect and open communication, or simply choose to let it go. Your relationship with your grown-up kid is worth infinitely more than the balance on any gift card.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Gift Card Dilemma: Should You Ever Cash It In Without Telling Your Grown-Up Kid