The Eternal Question: Did I Make the Right Decision?
We’ve all been there. Standing at life’s crossroads, weighing options, and finally choosing a path—only to spend days, months, or even years wondering: Did I make the right decision? Whether it’s changing careers, ending a relationship, moving to a new city, or even something as simple as buying a car, the haunting doubt can linger like an uninvited guest. But why do we torture ourselves with this question, and how can we find peace in our choices? Let’s unpack the psychology behind decision regret and explore practical ways to navigate it.
The Paradox of Choice: Why Doubt Creeps In
Modern life offers endless possibilities, but freedom of choice often comes with a side of anxiety. Psychologist Barry Schwartz coined the term “paradox of choice” to describe how more options lead to greater dissatisfaction. When we make a decision, we’re not just choosing for something—we’re also choosing against alternatives. This creates a mental tally of “what-ifs” that fuels regret.
For example, imagine accepting a high-paying job in a field you’re not passionate about. Even if the role meets your financial goals, you might fixate on the creative career you didn’t pursue. The brain tends to magnify the appeal of unchosen paths while downplaying their potential downsides. This cognitive bias, known as “grass-is-greener syndrome,” tricks us into believing our alternate realities would’ve been perfect—even though they likely wouldn’t.
Redefining “Right” and “Wrong” Decisions
To ease decision-related stress, we need to rethink what makes a choice “right” or “wrong.” Many people assume a “good” decision guarantees happiness, success, or smooth sailing. But life rarely works that way.
Consider this: A decision isn’t inherently right or wrong—it’s context-dependent. What feels like a mistake today might reveal its value years later. Take the story of Steve Jobs, who dropped out of college but later credited a calligraphy class he audited for inspiring Apple’s typography. At the time, quitting school seemed like a failure. Decades later, it became part of his success narrative.
Instead of judging choices as absolute wins or losses, view them as experiments. Every decision teaches us something—about our priorities, resilience, or adaptability. As author Paulo Coelho wrote, “You have to take risks. We will only understand the miracle of life fully when we allow the unexpected to happen.”
The Role of Regret: Friend or Foe?
Regret often gets a bad rap, but it’s not inherently destructive. Psychologists classify regret into two types: action regret (wishing you hadn’t done something) and inaction regret (wishing you had done something). Studies show inaction regrets—like not pursuing a dream or avoiding tough conversations—tend to linger longer.
However, regret can also be a teacher. It highlights misalignments between our values and actions. For instance, if you regret snapping at a loved one during an argument, that discomfort reinforces the importance of patience. The key is to acknowledge regret without letting it paralyze you. Ask: “What can I learn here?” instead of “Why did I mess up?”
Strategies to Quiet the “What-If” Monster
1. Reframe Your Narrative
When doubt arises, challenge catastrophic thinking. Instead of ruminating on worst-case scenarios, ask: “What’s the best possible outcome of this decision?” For example, if you’re regretting a breakup, focus on how it might create space for healthier relationships rather than fixating on loneliness.
2. Practice “Satisficing”
Coined by economist Herbert Simon, satisficing means choosing an option that’s “good enough” rather than obsessing over perfection. Set clear criteria for your decisions upfront (e.g., salary range, location, work-life balance) and stop searching once those boxes are checked.
3. Embrace the “No Undo Button” Rule
Life doesn’t have a rewind button—and that’s okay. Once a decision is made, commit fully to it. As entrepreneur Sara Blakely’s father taught her, celebrate failures as proof you’re trying. The same applies to “questionable” choices: They’re proof you’re actively shaping your life.
4. Talk to Your Future Self
Write a letter to yourself five years from now. Describe why you made this decision and what you hope it leads to. This exercise adds perspective and reduces present-moment anxiety.
When to Revisit a Decision (and When to Let Go)
Not all decisions are set in stone. If a choice consistently causes misery—say, a job that drains your energy or a relationship that feels toxic—it’s okay to pivot. However, don’t confuse temporary discomfort with failure. Growth often requires discomfort.
Before backtracking, ask:
– Is this situation harmful, or just challenging?
– Am I avoiding effort, or is this truly misaligned?
– What would I gain by changing course now?
If your gut says “stay,” give it time. Adaptability is a muscle; sticking with a decision can build resilience.
The Hidden Gifts of “Wrong” Decisions
Some of life’s greatest lessons come from choices we initially regret. A failed business venture teaches financial literacy. A friendship fallout strengthens boundaries. Even seemingly “bad” decisions contribute to our growth.
Author J.K. Rowling once said her early career failures gave her “a stripping away of the inessential”—pushing her to focus on writing. Similarly, what feels like a detour might be redirecting you toward something better suited to your evolving self.
Final Thoughts: Trust the Process
The question “Did I make the right decision?” may never fully disappear—and that’s human. But instead of seeking certainty, seek clarity. Clarify your values, learn from missteps, and trust that every choice is a step forward, even if the path isn’t linear.
As you navigate life’s uncertainties, remember: The goal isn’t to avoid “wrong” decisions. It’s to make decisions with intention, own them courageously, and remain open to wherever they lead. After all, a life without a few questionable choices is a life half-lived.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Eternal Question: Did I Make the Right Decision