The Day My Teacher Followed Me: Rethinking Small Rules and Big Reactions
Okay, picture this. The final bell rings, a wave of relief crashes over you. Freedom! You grab your backpack, weave through the buzzing crowd in the hallway, maybe laughing with a friend about something dumb. You push open the heavy school doors, sunlight hits your face, you’re practically tasting the weekend… and then you hear it.
“Hey! Wait up!”
You turn. Your teacher is striding purposefully across the quad, eyes locked on you. Your heart sinks. What now? They catch up as you near the school gate, slightly out of breath.
“About earlier,” they say, their tone serious. “You were running in the hallway. We have a strict ‘walk only’ rule for safety, remember? I saw you and called out, but you didn’t stop. I need you to understand how important this is.”
Cue the internal monologue: Seriously? They chased me all the way out here… for running? The embarrassment is instant. Fellow students are glancing over. The sense of freedom evaporates, replaced by annoyance and a weird feeling of being… hunted? Over this?
Yeah, it happened. And it left me, and probably everyone who witnessed it, with a lot more than just a reminder about hallway etiquette.
Why Does This Feel So… Extreme?
Let’s break down why this kind of reaction feels disproportionate and counterproductive:
1. The Scale Mismatch: Running in the hallway is, objectively, a minor infraction. It’s a rule designed for safety and order, absolutely. But chasing a student across campus to the very edge of school property elevates it to a level that feels utterly mismatched. It transforms a quick “Hey, walk please!” moment into a significant, confrontational event.
2. The Public Factor: Being followed, especially outside the building where the “crime” occurred, is inherently public and humiliating. It broadcasts a message to peers: “This student messed up badly.” Except they didn’t. The public shaming vastly outweighs the severity of the original action.
3. The “Pursuit” Psychology: Being physically followed triggers primal feelings. It feels invasive, aggressive, and signals that the authority figure sees your action as warranting immediate and forceful intervention. For a student already leaving the premises, it feels unnecessary and intimidating. It erodes trust instantly.
4. Timing is Everything: The incident was over. The student was exiting the school. Addressing it at that moment, especially in that way, served no immediate safety purpose. It felt punitive and obsessive, not corrective. Couldn’t it wait until the next class? A quick, quiet word later?
5. The “Didn’t Hear You” Factor: Hallways are noisy chaos when the bell rings. Claiming a student deliberately ignored a call is often pure assumption. Maybe they genuinely didn’t hear over the din. The pursuit assumed guilt and defiance without confirmation.
Beyond the Embarrassment: What’s the Real Cost?
Reactions like this, even over small things, have ripple effects:
Damaged Teacher-Student Rapport: Trust is fragile. An overreaction over something trivial makes students wary. Will this teacher blow up over anything? Will they chase me again? It creates distance, not respect. Respect is earned through fairness and proportionality.
Focus Shifts from Learning to Rules: Instead of associating the teacher with knowledge or support, the student (and witnesses) remember the time they got chased over running. It makes the school environment feel more about policing minutiae than fostering growth.
Undermining Legitimate Authority: When adults use significant power for very minor offenses, it cheapens their authority when genuinely needed. Students are less likely to take serious rules or consequences seriously if they see the same heavy hand applied to everything.
Student Perspective Gets Lost: The immediate reaction focuses solely on the rule breach and the teacher’s feelings about being “ignored.” It rarely considers the student’s perspective: the rush to leave, the noisy environment, the natural forgetfulness, or the sheer mortification of being pursued.
So, What Should Happen Instead? (A Few Thoughts)
Addressing minor missteps is part of school life. But how matters immensely. Here are alternatives to the campus chase:
1. Address it Proximally and Promptly: A clear, firm “Walk, please!” in the hallway is appropriate. If they genuinely didn’t hear, maybe a slightly louder “Excuse me, [Name], walking!” catches their attention without escalating. A gentle tap on the shoulder as you pass works too.
2. Choose Your Battles (Wisely): Teachers have immense discretion. Is pursuing a student outside over a hallway run worth the relational damage and lost time? Often, the answer is no. Letting the truly minor stuff go in the moment preserves energy for what truly matters.
3. Follow Up Later, Calmly: If it needs addressing beyond the initial reminder, do it privately later. “Hey, I noticed you running in the hall after class. Everything okay? Just remember we need everyone walking for safety.” This is respectful and effective.
4. Assume Good Faith (Initially): Instead of jumping to “They ignored me!”, consider “Maybe they didn’t hear.” Start the interaction with that assumption. “Hey, not sure if you heard me back in the hall…” changes the tone completely.
5. Focus on the ‘Why’, Not Just the ‘What’: A quick explanation in the moment helps. “Walk, please! It gets too crowded and someone could get hurt,” connects the rule to a real purpose beyond just “because I said so.”
The Takeaway: Rules Matter, Reactions Matter More
That day at the school gate wasn’t about learning the importance of walking. It was a lesson in disproportionate responses, public embarrassment, and how quickly a small rule can create a big, negative memory. It strained a relationship over something incredibly minor.
Rules exist for good reasons – safety, order, respect. But enforcing them effectively requires wisdom, restraint, and an understanding of the student experience. Chasing someone across campus to the gate over a hallway sprint? That’s not enforcing a rule; that’s making the rule, and the enforcer, seem unreasonable. It confuses control with genuine authority.
The best teachers understand that their power is most potent when used judiciously and kindly. They know that preserving a student’s dignity, even when correcting them, isn’t weakness – it’s the foundation of a classroom, and a school, where students actually feel safe enough to learn and grow. Let’s save the pursuit for things that truly warrant it. Walking in the hallway just isn’t one of them.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Day My Teacher Followed Me: Rethinking Small Rules and Big Reactions