The College Admissions Grind: Why Today’s Students Feel Cheated
Let’s cut to the chase: If you’ve ever compared your chances of getting into an Ivy League school to your parents’ or grandparents’ generation, you’ve probably wanted to scream into a pillow. Older relatives love to reminisce about how they “just applied on a whim” to Harvard and got in with a B+ average and a part-time job at a gas station. Meanwhile, today’s students are expected to juggle AP classes, Olympic-level extracurriculars, and a side hustle curing diseases—all while maintaining the personality of a TED Talk host. What happened?
The Golden Age of Low Stakes
Rewind to the 1970s or 1980s, and college admissions looked almost unrecognizable. Elite schools like Stanford accepted nearly 30% of applicants, compared to today’s grim 4-5% acceptance rates. Back then, a strong GPA and decent SAT scores were often enough to secure a spot. Essays? A two-page reflection on “your favorite hobby” would suffice. Extracurriculars? Being captain of the debate team or playing in the school orchestra was considered impressive. There were no LinkedIn profiles at age 16, no pressure to monetize your hobbies, and certainly no viral TikTok campaigns to “demonstrate leadership.”
The simplicity wasn’t just about effort—it was about volume. Fewer students globally were competing for the same slots. College wasn’t yet synonymous with guaranteed career success, so many talented people skipped higher education altogether for trade jobs or immediate work. For those who did apply, the process felt human. Admissions officers had time to read applications holistically, rather than scanning for keywords in a 10-minute frenzy.
The Perfect Storm of Modern Competition
So why does getting into a top college now feel like running a marathon blindfolded? Let’s break it down:
1. Globalization and Population Growth
The applicant pool isn’t just bigger—it’s smarter. Students from around the world now vie for the same elite institutions, armed with perfect grades and fluency in three languages. In 1980, about 26% of U.S. high school graduates enrolled in college; today, that number is nearly 70%, with international applicants adding another layer of competition.
2. The Rise of the Super-Applicant
Colleges have unintentionally created a monster by prioritizing “well-rounded” students. To stand out, kids now need a “spike”—an exceptional talent in one area—plus a laundry list of other achievements. Want to study biology? Better have a research internship, a nonprofit fighting climate change, and a patent pending. The result? Burnout culture, where teenagers treat their childhoods like a LinkedIn optimization project.
3. The Rankings Game
Universities themselves are trapped in a cycle of one-upmanship. To climb U.S. News & World Report rankings, schools prioritize metrics like low acceptance rates and high SAT averages. This incentivizes them to attract more applicants (to reject more people) and favor students who’ll boost their stats. It’s no longer about finding the best fit—it’s about gaming the system.
4. The Cost of Failure (Literally)
With tuition skyrocketing—up 169% since 1980, adjusted for inflation—families see top colleges as a ROI calculation. Graduates from elite schools earn higher salaries, on average, creating a desperation to “buy” that pedigree. But when everyone’s chasing the same golden ticket, the ticket loses value.
“But We Had Challenges Too!”
Before older generations dismiss this as whining, let’s acknowledge their point: Yes, college was cheaper but less accessible to marginalized groups. Yes, standardized testing was arguably more biased decades ago. And yes, today’s students have resources like online courses and mentorship programs that past generations couldn’t dream of.
But here’s the difference: The intensity of the competition has warped the entire journey. High school isn’t about learning anymore—it’s about resume-building. Students are pressured to strategize their friendships (“Will starting a podcast with you look good to Yale?”), sacrifice sleep for yet another internship, and treat hobbies as transactional stepping stones. The mental health toll is staggering, with anxiety and depression rates soaring among teens.
Is There a Way Out?
Fixing this mess requires a shift in mindset—from students and institutions:
– Colleges need to stop rewarding overachievement porn. Why not cap the number of extracurriculars listed on applications? Or emphasize quality over quantity in essays? Some schools, like MIT, now ask for fewer recommendation letters to reduce applicant stress.
– Parents and students must redefine success. Attending a top college doesn’t guarantee happiness or financial stability. Many thriving professionals graduated from state schools or community colleges. The obsession with brand names overlooks the value of fit, mentorship, and opportunities at less-selective institutions.
– Push back against the grind. Normalize gap years, vocational programs, and non-traditional paths. The more we diversify our definition of achievement, the less power elite admissions hold over students’ self-worth.
The Bittersweet Truth
Past generations did have it easier in some ways, but they also lacked today’s opportunities. Want to take a course on AI ethics from Stanford at age 15? You can. Build a global nonprofit from your laptop? Go for it. The same world that created cutthroat competition also empowers students to innovate beyond traditional paths.
So yeah, the system’s broken. But instead of resenting the past, today’s students are finding workarounds—embracing internships over generic volunteer hours, prioritizing mental health, and leveraging technology to stand out authentically. The goal shouldn’t be to replicate the “easy” admissions of the past but to reinvent the future. After all, if there’s one skill this generation has mastered, it’s adapting to unreasonable expectations—and maybe, just maybe, that resilience will matter more than any college acceptance letter.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The College Admissions Grind: Why Today’s Students Feel Cheated