The Bedsharing Question: When Can Parents Who Said “Never” Reconsider?
For many parents committed to safe sleep practices, bedsharing felt like an absolute “no.” Fueled by understandable fear of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) and suffocation risks highlighted by organizations like the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), they set up separate sleep spaces from day one – cribs, bassinets, following the ABCs (Alone, on their Back, in a Crib). But as their baby grows into a wriggly, opinionated toddler, a question might whisper: “When does it become safe? Is there a point where those initial worries fade?”
If you’re an “anti-bedsharing” parent starting to wonder this, you’re not alone or inconsistent. Your initial stance prioritized overwhelming evidence for infant safety. Revisiting the topic now reflects not a weakening of resolve, but a natural evolution as your child develops. So, when can the risk calculus change?
Understanding the Shift in Risk
The core safety concerns driving the recommendations against bedsharing with infants are:
1. Immaturity: Newborns and young infants lack the motor skills and strength to reliably free themselves if their breathing is obstructed (by bedding, a parent’s body, or even getting wedged).
2. SIDS Vulnerability: The peak age for SIDS is between 1-4 months, significantly decreasing after 6 months. While the exact causes are complex, factors like immature arousal responses play a role.
3. Environmental Hazards: Soft bedding, pillows, adult mattresses not designed for infants, and the presence of other sleepers all pose significant risks to a very young baby.
The Developmental Milestones That Matter
As your child grows, several key developmental changes significantly reduce the risks associated with bedsharing:
1. Age (Especially 6 Months and Beyond): This is a crucial turning point. The risk of SIDS drops dramatically after 6 months. By their first birthday, the risk is extremely low. Their bodies are stronger and more resilient.
2. Motor Skill Mastery: Can your child roll over easily both ways (front-to-back and back-to-front)? Can they reliably push up on their hands and knees, or even crawl? These skills mean they can move themselves away from potential obstructions or reposition their heads if needed. They have much greater control over their body position.
3. Head and Neck Strength: A toddler has vastly superior head and neck control compared to a floppy newborn. They can lift and turn their head with ease.
4. Communication & Awareness: An older baby or toddler will often vocalize, push, or kick if they are uncomfortable or in distress during sleep. They are more aware of their surroundings.
So, When Might It Be “Safe Enough” for the Cautious Parent?
There’s no single, magic age stamped on a calendar that declares bedsharing universally “safe.” Safety is always about risk reduction, not elimination. However, based on the reduced SIDS risk and increased physical capabilities:
Many pediatricians and safe sleep experts suggest that the earliest point to even consider bedsharing with dramatically lower risk is after 6 months of age. This aligns with the significant drop in SIDS risk and improved motor skills.
The period between 12-18 months is often cited as a point where the remaining risks (primarily suffocation/entrapment, not SIDS) become comparable to other toddler sleep risks if the environment is meticulously controlled. By this age, toddlers are strong, mobile, and the SIDS risk is negligible.
Crucial Caveats: Safety First, Always
Even if your child is well past infancy, if you choose to explore bedsharing, the environment must be made as safe as possible. The principles that protected them as infants still matter, adapted for their size and mobility:
1. Firm Mattress: No memory foam toppers or overly soft surfaces. The mattress must be firm and fit the bed frame snugly (no gaps).
2. Minimal Bedding: Avoid heavy comforters, duvets, quilts, and excessive pillows. A light blanket placed no higher than the child’s waist is better than a thick duvet near their face. Consider warm sleep clothing instead.
3. No Gaps or Hazards: Ensure the child cannot get trapped between the mattress and wall, headboard, footboard, or furniture. Use bed rails designed for toddlers if needed, ensuring no dangerous gaps.
4. Safe Sleep Surface: The bed should be low to the ground. Consider placing the mattress directly on the floor if feasible to eliminate fall risk.
5. No Other Children or Pets: Only one caregiver (if any) should share the bed with the toddler. Other children or pets add unpredictability and risk.
6. Sober & Alert: The adult(s) in the bed must never be under the influence of alcohol, drugs (including some prescription medications), or be excessively sleep-deprived to the point of impaired awareness.
7. No Smoking: Absolutely no smoking in the home, especially not in the bedroom.
8. Health Status: Be extra cautious if your child has any respiratory issues or is unwell.
Is It Necessary? Or Even Desirable?
This is the other vital question. Just because the risk might be acceptable to you after 12-18 months doesn’t mean you have to bedshare, or that it will solve sleep problems. Many families successfully maintain independent sleep throughout the toddler years and beyond.
Toddler Sleep is Complex: Bedsharing might solve one issue (e.g., frequent night wakings needing comfort) but create others (kicking, less parental sleep quality, difficulty transitioning later).
Habits: Introducing bedsharing at this stage can become a long-term habit that’s challenging to change. Be intentional.
Parental Comfort: Your comfort matters too! If bedsharing means no one sleeps well, it might not be the right solution, regardless of physical safety.
Making the Decision: It’s Personal
For parents who started as firmly “anti-bedsharing,” revisiting the question reflects their child’s growth. The intense risks that warranted an absolute stance in infancy diminish significantly as babies become robust toddlers. While safety must always be paramount (following the guidelines above), the period after 12 months often represents a point where the nature of the risk changes, and parental choice based on family needs becomes more prominent.
The “safe enough” point is deeply personal. It depends on your individual child’s development, your tolerance for risk (even reduced risk), the safety of your sleep environment, and your family’s specific needs and rhythms. There’s no obligation to start bedsharing later if independent sleep is working. But if you find yourself wondering, know that your initial caution served its vital purpose, and reassessing as your child grows is a natural, responsible part of the parenting journey. Trust your instincts, prioritize safety measures, and choose what brings the most peace and rest to your family.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Bedsharing Question: When Can Parents Who Said “Never” Reconsider