The Art of the “Now”: What Would You Teach in This Situation?
Every educator, trainer, or mentor faces that pivotal moment: standing before a group, an individual, or even just staring at a lesson plan, confronted by the immediate reality. The carefully crafted agenda meets the live energy of the room, the unexpected question, the visible confusion, or the sudden shift in context. The core question echoes silently: “What would you teach in this situation?”
It’s the essence of responsive, effective teaching. It’s not just about knowing your subject inside-out (though that’s crucial!), but about reading the room, understanding the moment, and making a conscious, often split-second, decision about the most valuable knowledge or skill to impart right now. Let’s explore the factors that shape this critical choice and how you can hone this situational awareness.
Beyond the Syllabus: The Variables in the Equation
Choosing what to teach “in this situation” requires assessing a dynamic interplay of factors:
1. The Learners Themselves: Who are you teaching?
Prior Knowledge & Skill Level: Are they beginners drowning in jargon? Are they advanced and need deeper nuance? Did yesterday’s foundational lesson actually stick? Misjudging this leads to frustration or boredom.
Current State: Are they tired? Energized? Anxious? Distracted by external events? A group buzzing with excitement after a break needs a different approach than one slumped after lunch.
Visible Confusion or Insight: Are heads nodding in understanding, or are brows furrowed? Is someone bravely raising a hand with a question that reveals a fundamental gap?
Specific Needs: Are there learning differences, language barriers, or cultural considerations demanding adaptation now?
2. The Immediate Context:
Time Constraints: Do you have 5 minutes left or 50? This drastically changes what’s feasible. Can you cover the planned complex concept, or is it better to solidify a smaller piece?
The Physical (or Virtual) Environment: Is the tech working? Is the room too hot/cold/noisy? Is it a formal lecture hall or a collaborative workshop space? An unexpected fire drill changes everything!
The “Mood” of the Session: Is it a tense Q&A after a difficult topic? A celebratory wrap-up? A critical troubleshooting session? The emotional tenor dictates the appropriateness of content.
3. The Overarching Goals: Never lose sight of the forest.
The Core Objective: What is the ultimate skill or understanding they need from this course, module, or session? Does the immediate situation require reinforcing that core, or tackling a prerequisite?
The “Why”: Is the purpose primarily knowledge transfer, skill development, attitude change, problem-solving, or team building? Your immediate teaching choice must serve this purpose.
Long-Term Development: What will serve them best not just today, but tomorrow and next week? Sometimes teaching how to find the answer (a resource, a strategy) is more valuable than the answer itself in a tight spot.
Scenarios: Decoding the “Situation”
Let’s see how this plays out in real moments:
Scenario 1: The Critical Gap Revealed
Situation: You’re midway through explaining a complex statistical analysis technique. You ask a check-in question, and the majority of the class clearly doesn’t grasp the foundational concept you assumed they knew cold from the previous module.
What Would You Teach? The immediate need isn’t pushing forward with the technique. It’s diagnosing where the gap is (was it the concept itself? The prerequisite math?) and teaching that foundational piece again, perhaps using a completely different analogy or simpler example. You sacrifice planned content to ensure future content can be built.
Scenario 2: The Unexpected Detour
Situation: During a leadership workshop, a heated debate erupts among participants about a recent company policy change, derailing the planned activity.
What Would You Teach? The content about the planned leadership model might be lost. But the situation offers a golden opportunity to teach crucial skills: facilitating difficult conversations, active listening in conflict, or finding common ground. You pivot to use the live debate as a case study for applying those very leadership principles.
Scenario 3: The “Tech Fail” Moment
Situation: Your entire interactive presentation with embedded videos crashes minutes before your session starts. No time to fix it.
What Would You Teach? Panic is tempting! But the core information remains. You teach adaptability – yours and theirs. You might quickly outline key points on a whiteboard, shift to a facilitated discussion using prepared questions (“Here’s the core question the video addressed…”), or break them into small groups to brainstorm based on the topic. You teach the material despite the obstacle, modeling resilience.
Scenario 4: The Spark of Curiosity
Situation: While teaching basic botany to kids, one child excitedly asks, “But why do some plants eat insects?!” This wasn’t part of the plan.
What Would You Teach? Do you brush it off (“We’ll cover that later”) or seize the moment? Capitalize on the genuine interest! Briefly explain carnivorous plants in simple terms, maybe showing a quick picture on your phone. You teach responsiveness and show that their curiosity drives learning. You might ignite a passion.
Scenario 5: The High-Stakes Corporate Training
Situation: Training customer service reps on a new software system. Half the group are tech-savvy millennials breezing through; the other half are experienced but less tech-comfortable reps struggling visibly.
What Would You Teach? Pushing the whole group at the same pace fails both. You might briefly teach the core navigation again for the strugglers while offering the advanced group a “challenge task” exploring a nuanced feature. Or, pair them up strategically for peer coaching. You teach differentiated instruction on the fly.
Developing Your Situational Teaching Compass
Becoming adept at answering “What would you teach in this situation?” isn’t luck; it’s a skill cultivated through:
Deep Content Knowledge: You can’t adapt what you don’t know well. Mastery frees you to be flexible.
Keen Observation: Constantly scan the room. Listen actively. Notice body language, participation levels, and the quality of questions.
Preparedness with Flexibility: Have clear goals and a plan (Plan A!), but also have Plan B, C, and D in your mental toolkit. Know where you can trim, expand, or divert.
Embracing the Pivot: Don’t be a slave to the slides. It’s okay to abandon a section if the situation demands it. Explain your reasoning briefly (“I see we need to revisit X before moving on”).
Reflective Practice: After each session, ask yourself: What situations arose? What did I choose to teach? Why? Did it work? What could I have done differently? This builds your internal database of responses.
Building Rapport: When learners trust you and feel safe, they’re more likely to show their confusion or ask questions, giving you better situational data.
Prioritizing Core Over Coverage: It’s almost always better to teach a few things well that learners truly understand and can use, than to rush through everything superficially just to “cover” it. The situation often highlights what the core truly is at that moment.
The Heart of Responsive Education
Asking “What would you teach in this situation?” moves teaching from a monologue to a dialogue, even if the dialogue is often unspoken. It transforms instruction from a rigid delivery of content into a dynamic interaction shaped by the human beings in the room and the realities of the moment.
It requires courage to deviate from the plan, humility to recognize when an assumption was wrong, and creativity to find the best path forward. But when you successfully read the situation and choose wisely, you’re not just teaching content; you’re teaching learners that their needs matter, that learning is alive, and that adaptability is key – perhaps the most valuable lesson of all. So, the next time you stand before your learners, pause, observe, and ask yourself that powerful question: What truly needs to be taught, right here, right now? Your answer defines the art of teaching in the moment.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Art of the “Now”: What Would You Teach in This Situation