The Art of Getting Great Suggestions: How to Ask So People Can Actually Help
“Hi, can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?”
We’ve all typed something similar, haven’t we? Maybe in a group chat, a forum, a comment section, or even an email to a colleague. You’re stuck, unsure, facing a problem, and you just need a little nudge in the right direction. It seems straightforward: ask a question, get an answer. Yet, so often, that simple plea floats into the digital void, met with silence, confusion, or responses that miss the mark entirely. Why does this happen? And crucially, how can you ask for suggestions in a way that actually gets you the useful help you need?
The truth is, that innocent “abt this” is often the core of the problem. It’s vague. It lacks context. It puts the entire burden of understanding on the person you’re asking. Getting helpful suggestions isn’t just about asking; it’s about framing your request effectively. Let’s break down how to transform that generic ask into a magnet for genuinely useful advice.
Why “Abt This” Doesn’t Cut It: The Vague Request Trap
Imagine walking up to a librarian and saying, “Hi, can you give me a suggestion about a book?” While well-intentioned, the librarian is left scrambling. Do you want fiction or non-fiction? A thrilling mystery or a heartwarming romance? Something easy to read or deeply challenging? Your request lacks the necessary details for them to provide a relevant suggestion.
The same principle applies online and offline:
1. The Burden of Mind-Reading: When you say “abt this,” you’re expecting the responder to magically know what “this” refers to, the background, your specific goals, and your limitations. That’s a big ask!
2. Attracting the Wrong Help: Vagueness often attracts broad, generic advice that might not apply to your situation at all (“Just work harder!” or “Have you tried Googling it?”), or worse, attracts unhelpful or irrelevant comments.
3. Wasted Time (Yours and Theirs): People might ask clarifying questions, leading to a lengthy back-and-forth before any real suggestion is offered. Others might skip your question entirely because deciphering it feels like too much effort.
4. Missing the Expertise: The person best equipped to help you with your specific coding bug, knitting pattern dilemma, or career crossroads might scroll right past your vague post because they don’t recognize it as something within their niche.
From Fuzzy to Focused: Crafting a Suggestion-Worthy Request
Turning “can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?” into a request that gets traction involves providing context and clarity. Think of it as giving potential helpers a roadmap. Here’s how:
1. Clearly Define “This”: What exactly are you seeking suggestions on?
Bad: “Need suggestions for my project.”
Good: “I’m designing a mobile app for local gardeners to trade seeds. I’m stuck on how to structure the user profile section – any suggestions for essential info to include beyond basic name/contact?”
Why it works: Instantly tells people the project type (mobile app), its purpose (seed trading for gardeners), and the specific area needing input (user profile structure).
2. Provide Essential Background Context: Helpers need to understand your starting point.
Bad: “Suggestions for learning guitar?”
Good: “I’ve been playing acoustic guitar for about 3 months, can play basic chords and strum patterns. I want to focus on fingerpicking folk styles. Any suggestions for good online courses or specific exercises to build that skill?”
Why it works: Clarifies current skill level, the instrument type, the specific musical style goal, and the type of resource sought (courses/exercises).
3. State Your Goal or Desired Outcome: What does success look like for you? What are you trying to achieve?
Bad: “Suggestions for this essay?”
Good: “I’m writing a persuasive essay arguing that public libraries need more funding. My goal is to convince local council members. I’m worried my second argument about community impact feels weak – any suggestions for stronger evidence or a more compelling angle?”
Why it works: States the essay type (persuasive), the topic (library funding), the target audience (council members), the specific problem area (weak second argument), and the type of suggestion needed (evidence/angle).
4. Mention Constraints (If Applicable): Are there limitations helpers should know about? Time? Budget? Tools?
Bad: “Need a suggestion for a birthday gift.”
Good: “Looking for a unique birthday gift suggestion for my sister who loves gardening. She has a small balcony, so needs to be compact. Ideally under $50.”
Why it works: Identifies the recipient (sister), their interest (gardening), a key constraint (small balcony/compact), and a budget limit. This immediately filters out irrelevant suggestions.
5. Ask a Specific Question: Instead of a broad “suggestions?”, guide the type of response you want.
Examples:
“What’s one feature you think is crucial for a [your specific thing]?”
“Based on your experience with [similar situation], what pitfalls should I avoid?”
“Can you recommend a specific resource/tool for achieving [specific goal]?”
“What alternative approach would you consider for [specific problem]?”
Instead of: “Can anyone give me a suggestion abt this code error?”
Try: “I’m getting a ‘Null Reference Exception’ on line 42 when trying to load user data in my C app. I’ve verified the data file exists. Any suggestions on where to look next for the cause?”
Putting it into Practice: Before and After
Vague Ask: “Hi, planning a trip. Can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?”
Focused Ask: “Hi! Planning a 7-day trip to Portugal for two adults next May. We love history, hiking, and local food, and want to avoid super crowded spots. Thinking Lisbon, Sintra, and maybe Porto? Any suggestions for must-see historical sites off the beaten path, or a great day hike near Sintra? Budget is mid-range.” (This tells us destination, duration, travelers, interests, dislikes, rough itinerary, specific suggestion areas, and budget).
Vague Ask: “Need help with this school assignment.”
Focused Ask: “I’m a high school junior working on a biology research paper about the impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems. I’ve gathered sources but am struggling to develop a strong, focused thesis statement. Any suggestions for crafting a thesis that’s specific and arguable based on this topic?”
Where You Ask Matters Too
Specialized Forums/Communities: (Reddit subgroups, niche forums, professional networks) These are goldmines for expert advice. Always search first to see if your question has been answered! Be detailed and respect the community’s specific rules. Tag appropriately if the platform allows (e.g., beginner, webdesign).
Social Media (Broad/Friend Groups): Great for personal recommendations (gifts, travel, restaurants) or brainstorming. Provide clear context as you would above. Tag specific friends if you know they have relevant expertise (“Hey Sam, knowing you’re a photography whiz, any suggestions for…?”).
Email/Professional Settings: Formality increases slightly, but clarity remains paramount. State your request clearly in the subject line (“Suggestion Request: Improving Client Onboarding Process”) and provide necessary context concisely in the body. Acknowledge their time and expertise.
The Magic of the Well-Framed Question
When you move beyond “can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?” and invest effort in framing your request clearly, something powerful happens:
1. You Attract Relevant Experts: People who genuinely know about your specific issue can instantly recognize it and are more likely to engage.
2. You Get Higher Quality Responses: Clear context allows people to provide targeted, actionable advice instead of generic platitudes.
3. You Show Respect: Demonstrating that you’ve thought about your problem and value others’ time makes them much more willing to invest their effort in helping you.
4. You Learn to Clarify Your Own Thinking: The process of articulating your problem clearly often helps you understand it better, sometimes even leading to your own solution!
5. You Build Better Connections: Thoughtful questions foster more meaningful interactions and can lead to ongoing helpful relationships.
So, the next time you feel stuck and ready to type “hi can anyone give me a suggestion abt this?”, pause. Take a deep breath. Ask yourself: What exactly do I need help with? What background would someone need to know? What’s my goal? What constraints exist? Frame that context clearly, ask a specific question, and watch how much more effectively the suggestions – the right kind of suggestions – start to flow in. It transforms the ask from a shot in the dark into an invitation for genuinely helpful collaboration. Go ahead, give it a try on your next challenge!
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Art of Getting Great Suggestions: How to Ask So People Can Actually Help