That Burning Question: “Is This a Real Thing?” – Why We Ask and How to Know
We’ve all been there. Scrolling through social media, half-listening to a friend’s wild story, or reading a headline that seems too bizarre to be true. A little voice pipes up in the back of our minds: “Wait… is this a real thing?”
It’s one of the most fundamental human questions, a direct line to our innate curiosity and our constant, often subconscious, process of trying to figure out the world. But why do we ask it so much now, and how can we actually find a reliable answer? Let’s unpack the journey from skepticism to understanding.
The Roots of Our Skepticism: A Built-In Survival Feature
Think about it. Early humans who unquestioningly believed every rustle in the bushes was just the wind probably didn’t last long. Doubt – that little “Is this real?” nudge – is an evolutionary advantage. It makes us pause, assess, and seek more information before committing to an action or belief. It protects us from danger, deception, and wasted effort.
In the modern world, this instinct manifests constantly:
1. The Wild Claim: “I heard drinking celery juice cures all known diseases!” Is this a real thing? (Spoiler: No, but it is hydrating!)
2. The Viral Trend: People are taping spoons to their faces overnight? Is this a real thing? (Yes, people do it, but it doesn’t do what they think it does).
3. The Dubious Product: This magnetic bracelet claims to balance your energy and relieve pain. Is this a real thing? (Scientific evidence? Largely lacking).
4. The Historical Tidbit: Did pirates really make people walk the plank? Is this a real thing? (Rarely; mostly a Hollywood invention).
5. The Urban Legend: Alligators living in the New York City sewers? Is this a real thing? (Persistent myth, but biologically implausible).
Why It Feels Harder Than Ever to Know What’s Real
Our “Is this real?” radar is pinging constantly these days, and for good reason:
The Information Avalanche: We are bombarded with more information daily than our ancestors encountered in a lifetime. Quantity ≠ quality. Sorting signal from noise is exhausting.
The Rise of the Deepfake & Sophisticated AI: Seeing isn’t always believing anymore. Convincing fake videos, audio, and images are becoming increasingly accessible, making visual evidence less reliable.
Echo Chambers & Algorithmic Bias: Social media feeds and search engines often show us content confirming our existing beliefs, shielding us from contradictory evidence that might answer the “is it real?” question more objectively.
Disinformation Campaigns: Deliberate efforts to mislead for political, financial, or ideological reasons muddy the waters significantly. They exploit our emotions and biases.
Blurring Lines: Satire sites can look real, parody accounts can seem genuine, and marketing often masquerades as news. Context is easily lost.
So, How DO We Figure Out If It’s Real? (A Skeptic’s Toolkit)
Moving beyond gut feeling requires developing some critical habits. Here’s a practical approach the next time you wonder “Is this a real thing?”:
1. Pause & Question the Source: Who is telling you this? What’s their expertise? What’s their agenda? Are they known for accuracy or sensationalism? A random meme account ≠ a peer-reviewed scientific journal.
2. Check the Evidence: Does the claim provide verifiable evidence? Links to reliable sources? Data? Or is it all vague assertions and emotional appeals? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
3. Seek Corroboration: Don’t rely on a single source, especially if it’s unfamiliar. Use search engines to see what other reputable sources (mainstream news, academic institutions, established fact-checking sites like Snopes, PolitiFact, Reuters Fact Check) say about the claim. Do experts agree?
4. Consider the Plausibility: Does this align with established scientific principles? Does it defy basic logic? While science evolves, claims that contradict well-understood laws of physics or biology require incredibly strong evidence to be considered real. A perpetual motion machine? Likely not real. A new species of insect discovered? Entirely plausible.
5. Look for the Original: Especially online, claims get distorted as they spread. Can you find the original study, video, or statement? What did it actually say? Reverse image search can help trace photos.
6. Watch for Emotional Manipulation: Does the information make you feel outrage, fear, or an intense sense of belonging? These powerful emotions can override our critical thinking. Be extra skeptical of content designed purely to provoke.
7. Embrace “I Don’t Know (Yet)”: It’s okay not to have an immediate answer. Saying “I need to check that” is a sign of intellectual honesty, not weakness. The “Is this real?” question is the start of the journey, not the end.
Beyond Facts: The “Realness” of Experience
Sometimes, “Is this a real thing?” goes beyond verifiable facts. We might ask it about:
Subjective Experiences: “Is synesthesia a real thing?” (Yes, neurologically verified). “Is the feeling of ‘awe’ a real thing?” (Yes, a documented psychological state). Their reality lies in consistent subjective reports and measurable neurological correlates.
Social Constructs: “Is ‘brand loyalty’ a real thing?” While it’s not a physical object, its effects on consumer behavior and marketing strategies are demonstrably real within human culture.
Personal Meaning: “Is this career path the real thing for me?” This requires introspection and self-knowledge, not just external verification.
The Power of Asking
Asking “Is this a real thing?” isn’t cynicism; it’s the engine of curiosity and critical thinking. It’s how we learn, how we avoid scams, how we make better decisions, and how we build a more accurate understanding of the complex world we live in. It’s a vital skill in an age overflowing with information and disinformation.
So, the next time that question pops into your head, don’t dismiss it. Lean into it. See it as an opportunity to dig a little deeper, verify a little more thoroughly, and sharpen your ability to discern what’s truly real from the noise. Because in a world constantly trying to capture our attention (and sometimes, deceive us), that simple question might just be one of the most important tools we have. Keep asking it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » That Burning Question: “Is This a Real Thing