SoTL: Transforming Teaching from Intuition to Impact
“Anyone here familiar with the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) field?” That question, tossed into a faculty meeting, conference session, or online forum, often gets a mix of responses. Some faces light up with recognition, others look intrigued but puzzled, and a few might simply shrug. If you’re in the latter groups, or even if you’ve heard the term but aren’t quite sure what it entails, you’re not alone. SoTL represents a powerful, often underappreciated, movement reshaping how we understand and improve education itself.
Beyond the Lecture: What Exactly Is SoTL?
At its heart, SoTL is about treating teaching and student learning as subjects worthy of serious, systematic scholarly investigation. Think of it as the research arm of pedagogy. It moves teaching beyond relying solely on tradition, personal experience, or anecdotal evidence. Instead, SoTL practitioners – usually faculty members like you – ask critical questions about what works, why it works, for whom it works, and under what conditions.
Imagine you try a new active learning technique in your history seminar. Some students seem more engaged, but others struggle. Your gut says it’s helpful, but how do you know? SoTL provides the framework and methods to systematically explore that:
1. Question: Does this specific active learning technique improve conceptual understanding compared to traditional lecture for students in this course?
2. Investigation: You design a study – perhaps comparing pre/post-test results between sections using different methods, analyzing student reflections, or tracking participation patterns.
3. Analysis: You rigorously examine the data you collect.
4. Sharing: You share your findings – successes, failures, and insights – with colleagues through conferences, publications, or department presentations.
This cycle transforms a personal teaching experiment into scholarly work that contributes to our collective knowledge about effective education.
A Bit of Backstory: Where Did SoTL Come From?
The term gained significant traction thanks to Ernest Boyer’s seminal 1990 report, Scholarship Reconsidered: Priorities of the Professoriate. Boyer argued that scholarship shouldn’t be limited to traditional discovery research (Scholarship of Discovery). He proposed broadening it to include:
Scholarship of Integration: Synthesizing knowledge across disciplines.
Scholarship of Application: Applying knowledge to solve real-world problems.
Scholarship of Teaching: Systematically studying teaching and learning to advance pedagogical knowledge.
Boyer’s idea of the “Scholarship of Teaching” laid the groundwork. Later scholars, like Lee Shulman, refined it, emphasizing the need for work that was public, peer-reviewed, and open to critique and use by others – hallmarks of any scholarly field. Thus, the “Scholarship of Teaching and Learning” (SoTL) emerged as a distinct field focused explicitly on evidence-based inquiry into educational practices and outcomes.
The Core DNA of SoTL Work
SoTL isn’t just any reflection on teaching; it’s scholarly inquiry. Key characteristics include:
Focus on Student Learning: The ultimate goal is understanding and improving how students learn. It’s not just about what the instructor does, but how students experience and integrate knowledge.
Question-Driven: It starts with a clear, answerable question about teaching/learning phenomena within a specific context.
Methodologically Rigorous: It employs appropriate research methods (qualitative, quantitative, mixed-methods) ethically and systematically to gather evidence. This could involve analyzing assignments, surveys, interviews, observations, learning analytics, etc.
Contextual: SoTL recognizes that teaching and learning are deeply influenced by discipline, institutional culture, student demographics, and specific classroom settings. Findings are often nuanced.
Public and Peer-Reviewed: SoTL work is shared with the wider educational community through journals, conferences, workshops, and institutional repositories. This allows for critique, replication, and building upon each other’s work.
Reflective and Iterative: Findings inform future teaching practice, leading to new questions and investigations. It’s a continuous cycle of improvement.
Why Bother? The Powerful Impact of SoTL
Engaging in SoTL isn’t just an academic exercise; it offers tangible benefits:
Improved Student Learning & Success: This is the big one. By systematically investigating what works, instructors can make data-informed decisions that directly enhance student engagement, understanding, retention, and achievement.
Enhanced Teaching Practice: SoTL moves teaching beyond trial-and-error. It provides evidence to refine methods, develop new approaches, and justify pedagogical choices. It makes you a more intentional and effective educator.
Professional Development & Growth: Engaging in SoTL is intellectually stimulating. It connects faculty to a larger community of educators, fosters collaboration across disciplines, and deepens understanding of the learning process.
Recognition of Teaching: In institutions where research traditionally dominates, SoTL provides a pathway for faculty to gain scholarly recognition for their teaching innovations and expertise. It elevates the status of teaching as intellectual work.
Informing Institutional Decisions: SoTL findings can inform curriculum development, assessment strategies, faculty development programs, and educational policy at the department or institutional level. It grounds decisions in evidence.
Building a Knowledge Base: Collectively, SoTL work builds a rich, evolving body of knowledge about effective teaching practices across diverse contexts, moving the entire field of education forward.
Getting Your Feet Wet: How Can You Engage with SoTL?
You don’t need to be a full-time education researcher to participate. Start small and build:
1. Identify a Question: Reflect on your teaching. What puzzles you? Where do students consistently struggle? What new technique do you wonder about? Frame a specific, manageable question. (e.g., “Does providing structured peer review guidelines improve the quality of feedback students give on each other’s drafts?”).
2. Explore Existing Literature: See what others have already discovered about your question or similar topics. Journals like Teaching & Learning Inquiry or The International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning are great resources. Your campus teaching center is another.
3. Design a Mini-Investigation: Choose simple, feasible methods. Maybe compare two assignment versions, analyze a set of student reflections, or use a quick classroom assessment technique (CAT).
4. Gather & Analyze Evidence: Collect your data ethically and analyze it thoughtfully. What patterns emerge?
5. Reflect and Share: What did you learn? How will it change your teaching? Share your insights informally with a colleague, at a department meeting, or through a campus teaching blog. Even small-scale findings can be valuable.
Challenges and Considerations
SoTL isn’t without hurdles. Finding time amidst other responsibilities is a major one. Navigating Institutional Review Board (IRB) processes for human subjects research can feel daunting, though many small classroom inquiries qualify for exemption. Some disciplines or institutions may still undervalue SoTL compared to disciplinary research. The key is often starting small, seeking support (from teaching centers or SoTL mentors), and focusing on questions that genuinely matter to you and your students.
So, Anyone Familiar? Becoming Part of the Conversation
The next time you hear someone ask, “Anyone here familiar with the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) field?” – you can confidently say you are. More importantly, you understand that SoTL offers a powerful pathway. It transforms teaching from a private act into a scholarly, evidence-based practice focused squarely on enhancing student learning. It empowers educators to become not just knowledge conveyors, but educational researchers within their own classrooms and disciplines. Whether you start by reading a SoTL article, attending a workshop, or designing your own small inquiry, engaging with SoTL is an investment in your students’ success and your own growth as an educator. The field thrives on diverse perspectives and shared discoveries – your unique insights and questions are a valuable part of the journey towards better teaching and deeper learning for all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » SoTL: Transforming Teaching from Intuition to Impact