Rant: Stop Blaming Admin for Lack of Funding. Seriously, Stop It.
Alright, let’s talk. Let’s really talk about something that grinds my gears more than a budget meeting in May: the constant, knee-jerk blaming of school administrators for funding shortages. It’s become the go-to complaint, the easy villain in the complex drama of public education. “Why can’t we have smaller classes?” “Why did they cut the art program?” “Why is my kid’s textbook older than me?” And the answer, shouted from the back of the PTA meeting or muttered in the teacher’s lounge, is always the same: “Admin!” “It’s those administrators wasting money!” “Look at their salaries!” “They just don’t care!”
Stop. Just stop.
I’m not here to paint every administrator as a flawless saint. Like any profession, there are good ones, great ones, and yeah, maybe a few who missed their calling elsewhere. But blaming them – the principals, the superintendents, the business managers – for the deep, systemic, nationwide crisis of underfunding public education? That’s like blaming the deckhand for the iceberg the Titanic hit. It’s wildly misdirected fury, and frankly, it lets the real culprits completely off the hook. Let’s get real about where the blame actually belongs.
Scapegoating 101: Why Admin is the Easy Target
Think about it. Who do parents, teachers, and the community interact with most directly when programs are cut, class sizes balloon, or supplies run short? It’s the principal. It’s the district office. They’re the visible faces delivering the bad news, implementing the painful cuts dictated by budgets they didn’t create in isolation. They’re the ones explaining why the leaky roof still isn’t fixed or why that crucial reading specialist position vanished. Naturally, frustration gets aimed at the messenger.
Administrators also manage complex budgets – budgets that look large on paper but are stretched thinner than a dollar-store rubber band over dozens of competing, essential needs. When people see a six or seven-figure budget, they don’t always grasp the sheer scale of costs: salaries for hundreds of staff, benefits, utilities for aging buildings, transportation fleets, curriculum materials, technology infrastructure, maintenance, special education services mandated by law, security… the list is immense. Seeing any perceived administrative “luxury” (often vastly exaggerated) becomes a lightning rod for anger that should be aimed much higher up.
The Real Villains Hiding in Plain Sight (Hint: It’s NOT the Principal)
So, if it’s not the local admin frittering away the cash on gold-plated staplers, who is responsible for schools perpetually scraping the bottom of the fiscal barrel? Let’s shine the spotlight where it belongs:
1. Broken State Funding Formulas: This is often Ground Zero. Many states rely heavily on local property taxes to fund schools. What does this mean? Wealthy communities with high property values can generate ample funding. Poorer communities? They’re screwed from the start. The result? Glaring, unjust disparities in resources, opportunities, and outcomes based purely on zip code. State legislatures hold the power to fix these formulas – to create equitable, adequate funding models. Many consistently fail to do so, or worse, actively cut state contributions.
2. Political Priorities (or Lack Thereof): Education funding is a political choice. When state legislatures and governors choose to prioritize massive corporate tax breaks, bloated prison budgets, or pet projects over investing in the future workforce and citizenry (i.e., children), that’s a conscious decision. They decide not to fully fund the mandates they impose on schools. They choose austerity for kids while finding cash elsewhere. The chronic underfunding is a direct result of political willpower being directed away from public schools.
3. The Tax Revolt Hangover: Decades of anti-tax sentiment, often fueled by misleading rhetoric, have deeply damaged the public’s willingness to invest in shared goods like schools. Initiatives like Prop 13 in California and similar measures nationwide have starved local governments and, by extension, schools, of vital revenue. The “starve the beast” mentality aimed at government often hits schools hardest, as they are among the largest public expenditures.
4. Unfunded Mandates: Federal and state governments love to pass laws requiring schools to do X, Y, and Z – implement new curriculum standards, provide specific services, meet stringent testing requirements, comply with complex regulations. Often, these mandates come with little to no additional funding to actually cover the costs. This forces districts to rob Peter (like art supplies or librarian hours) to pay Paul (the state-mandated program).
5. Societal Disinvestment: Let’s be brutally honest. As a society, we often pay lip service to valuing education while refusing to put our money where our mouths are. We expect schools to solve every social problem – poverty, hunger, mental health crises, inequality – without providing the resources necessary to tackle these immense challenges effectively. We criticize teachers and admin while simultaneously voting down school funding levies or opposing tax increases needed to support them.
What Happens When We Misplace the Blame?
Blaming admin isn’t just unfair; it’s actively harmful:
Burns Out Good Leaders: Talented, passionate administrators – the ones fighting tooth and nail for resources and for kids within the constraints they have – get demoralized and leave. Who wants to be the perpetual punching bag?
Diverts Energy from Real Solutions: All that anger aimed at the principal’s office is anger not being channeled towards the state capitol, the governor’s office, or the voting booth to demand systemic change.
Creates Toxic Environments: It fosters distrust and antagonism between parents, teachers, and the leadership trying to hold things together, making collaboration impossible.
Lets the Powerful Off the Hook: Politicians and policymakers breathe a sigh of relief when the heat is on local officials instead of them. They want you mad at the superintendent, not questioning why they passed another corporate tax cut instead of funding schools.
So, What Can We Do? (Hint: Look Up, Not Down)
It’s time to redirect that frustration. Channel that energy productively:
1. Get Politically Active: This is non-negotiable. Learn how your state funds schools. Who are your state legislators? What are their voting records on education funding? Hold them accountable. Attend town halls, write emails, make calls. Demand equitable funding formulas and adequate state investment. Vote based on education funding priorities.
2. Support Local Funding Measures (Wisely): Understand the specific needs behind local levies or bonds. Ask tough questions about how the money will be spent, but recognize that sometimes, local communities must step up because the state has failed. Support measures focused directly on student needs.
3. Advocate for Policy Change: Support organizations working at the state and national levels to reform school funding systems and push for policies that direct resources equitably to the students and schools that need them most.
4. Demand Transparency (Then Understand It): Yes, ask for budget transparency from your district. But then take the time to actually understand it. Attend budget workshops. Ask administrators to explain the constraints they face – the fixed costs, the mandated expenses, the funding gaps. See the bigger picture they are forced to operate within.
5. Focus on Systemic Issues: When you see a problem – large classes, outdated materials, crumbling infrastructure – ask the why behind it. Dig deeper than “admin is incompetent.” Ask, “Why does our state allow this funding disparity?” or “Why did our legislature cut funding for this program?”
The Bottom Line
The next time you feel that surge of anger about the lack of funding in your local school, take a breath before you blast the principal or superintendent. Yes, hold them accountable for managing resources wisely and transparently within the constraints they are given. Demand good leadership. But understand that the fundamental lack of resources isn’t their doing. It’s the result of deliberate political choices made far above their pay grade, compounded by societal neglect and deeply flawed systems.
The real fight isn’t in the principal’s office. It’s in the state legislature. It’s at the ballot box. It’s in demanding that our society finally, truly, invests in its future – in its kids. Stop blaming the deckhands for the iceberg. Aim your fury at the captains who steered us into this mess and refuse to change course. That’s where the real blame – and the real solution – lies.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Rant: Stop Blaming Admin for Lack of Funding