R/Education, What’s Your Hot Take About Teaching? Mine? Let Teachers Be Human
Scrolling through r/education feels like walking into the world’s largest, most passionate, and occasionally exhausted teacher’s lounge. Debates rage about curriculum, funding, tech tools, and pedagogy. But when someone drops the classic, “What’s your hot take about teaching?”, the responses get spicy. We’ve heard the big ones: abolish homework, grades are meaningless, standardized tests are the root of all evil.
Here’s mine, simmering on the back burner for years: We demand superhuman perfection from teachers, yet their greatest strength often lies in embracing their human fallibility.
Hear me out. The archetype of the “perfect” teacher is deeply ingrained: always patient, endlessly energetic, flawlessly prepared, knowing every answer instantly, radiating calm authority 24/7. This mythical figure never gets flustered, never admits doubt, and certainly never makes a mistake in front of the students. Admins subtly (or not so subtly) reinforce this. Parents expect it. Society idolizes it. And teachers? Many internalize it, leading to crushing guilt and burnout when they inevitably fall short.
This relentless pursuit of infallibility isn’t just unrealistic; it’s actively harmful to authentic learning.
Why? Because real learning happens in the messy, vulnerable spaces where humanity connects. When a teacher pretends to know everything, it creates an artificial distance. It subtly tells students, “You must achieve this impossible standard too.” It stifles the beautiful, essential process of inquiry and discovery together.
My Hot Take? Let Teachers Be Human, Openly.
What does this look like in practice? It’s not about being unprofessional or unprepared. It’s about authenticity:
1. “I Don’t Know, Let’s Find Out” is a Powerful Phrase: Imagine a student asks a brilliant, unexpected question that stumps you. The old model demands a deflection or a quick, possibly inaccurate, answer to preserve the facade. The human approach? “Wow, that’s a fantastic question! I actually don’t know the answer off the top of my head. Let’s figure this out together – how could we research this?” This models intellectual humility, critical thinking, problem-solving, and genuine curiosity. It shows learning is a journey, not a destination dictated solely by the teacher. Suddenly, the classroom becomes a collaborative exploration hub.
2. Owning Mistakes (Gracefully): Accidentally spell a word wrong on the board? Mispronounce a name? Botch a calculation? Instead of pretending it didn’t happen or getting defensive, a simple, “Whoops, my mistake! Thanks for catching that, [Student Name]. Let me fix that…” goes a long way. It normalizes error as part of the process. It shows students it’s safe to take risks and make mistakes themselves. It builds trust through honesty. It demonstrates that correction isn’t personal, it’s about accuracy.
3. Sharing the Struggle (Appropriately): You don’t need to dump personal baggage, but showing that learning complex things is sometimes hard, even for the teacher, is valuable. “You know, when I was first learning calculus, this concept really tripped me up too. What helped me was…” or “I spent a long time figuring out the best way to explain this – let’s see if this approach works.” This builds empathy and shows perseverance. It dismantles the idea that understanding should be instantaneous.
4. Vulnerability in Connection: Sometimes, sharing a tiny, relevant sliver of your own journey (struggles, passions, how you came to love the subject) creates powerful connections. It bridges the gap between “authority figure” and “fellow human being.” Students are far more likely to engage with someone they perceive as real.
5. “I Need a Minute” is Okay: Feeling overwhelmed? Frustrated by tech failing again? Instead of snapping or pushing through visibly stressed, it’s okay (and healthy!) to model self-regulation. “Class, I need to take one quick deep breath to reset, because this projector is testing my patience!” (Said with a slight smile). Or, if a discussion gets unexpectedly heated, “Okay, let’s pause for 30 seconds. I want everyone to take a breath and think calmly about the points being made.” This shows emotional intelligence and coping strategies.
The Objections & Why They Miss the Point
“But won’t students lose respect?” Actually, research (like that related to John Hattie’s work on Visible Learning) often points to teacher credibility – built on trust, competence, and authenticity – as crucial. Owning a small mistake or admitting you don’t know something, then competently navigating to the answer, builds far more respect than bluffing. Students have finely tuned BS detectors.
“It’s unprofessional!” Professionalism isn’t synonymous with robotic perfection. It’s about preparedness, ethical conduct, commitment to student learning, and creating a safe environment. Authenticity enhances this by fostering genuine connection and trust, which are foundational to a productive learning environment.
“There’s no time!” Modeling “I don’t know, let’s find out” might take 5 minutes now, but it teaches students how to find answers independently later, saving time in the long run. Showing emotional regulation prevents bigger meltdowns (teacher or student) down the line.
The Payoff: Deeper Learning & Resilience
When teachers safely embrace their humanity:
Classrooms become psychologically safer: Students feel permission to ask questions, admit confusion, and take intellectual risks without fear of looking stupid. They see that struggle is part of the deal.
Critical thinking thrives: The focus shifts from “What’s the right answer for the test?” to “How do we figure this out? What evidence supports this?” Inquiry becomes central.
Relationships deepen: Authenticity fosters genuine connection. Students engage more with teachers they perceive as real people who care.
Resilience is modeled: Students witness adults navigating imperfection, setbacks, and frustration constructively. This is life skills education in action.
Teacher well-being improves: Dropping the exhausting pretense of constant perfection reduces stress and burnout. It allows teachers to bring their whole, best selves to the work.
So, r/education, that’s my hot take. The path to truly transformative teaching isn’t through constructing an image of infallible expertise. It’s through the courage to be authentically, professionally human – doubts, mistakes, curiosity, and all. It’s about showing students that learning is a shared, sometimes messy, always worthwhile human endeavor. What’s yours? Let’s get that discussion going. What human moment in the classroom made a real difference for you or your students?
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » R/Education, What’s Your Hot Take About Teaching