Preschool Expulsion: Why It Happens and How We Can Do Better
Imagine a four-year-old child being told they can’t return to their preschool classroom. It sounds shocking, but preschool expulsion—the formal removal of a child from an early education program—is more common than most people realize. Recent studies have uncovered troubling trends about who gets expelled, why it happens, and what it means for children’s futures. Let’s dig into the research and explore solutions to this complex issue.
The Shocking Reality of Preschool Expulsion
Preschool is often seen as a safe space for play, learning, and social growth. Yet data reveals a different story. In the U.S., children are expelled from preschool at rates three times higher than those in K–12 schools. A landmark study by Yale researcher Walter Gilliam found that over 250 preschoolers are expelled daily nationwide. Even more concerning? Racial and gender disparities are stark. Black children, particularly boys, are expelled at twice the rate of their white peers, despite no evidence of higher rates of disruptive behavior.
Why does this happen? Preschool staff often face high-stress environments with limited resources. Teachers may lack training in managing challenging behaviors or addressing underlying issues like trauma or developmental delays. When overwhelmed, expulsion becomes a “quick fix”—even though it solves nothing long-term.
Why Are Young Children Being Removed?
Preschool expulsion rarely stems from a single incident. Instead, it’s typically the result of multiple factors:
1. Adult Stress, Not Child Behavior
Gilliam’s research highlights a counterintuitive truth: Expulsion rates often reflect adult stress levels more than a child’s actions. In classrooms where teachers report burnout or lack support, expulsion rates soar. Large class sizes, low pay, and inadequate access to mental health professionals exacerbate the problem. A teacher scrambling to manage 20 preschoolers alone is more likely to see expulsion as their only option.
2. The “Invisible” Causes
Many expelled children struggle with unrecognized challenges. Speech delays, autism spectrum traits, or trauma responses (like aggression or withdrawal) are frequently misunderstood as “bad behavior.” Without proper screening or specialists, teachers may misinterpret these signs, leading to punitive measures instead of support.
3. Bias in Decision-Making
Implicit bias plays a role. Studies show educators often perceive Black children as older, less innocent, and more intentional in their actions than white peers. This skewed perception increases the likelihood of harsh discipline. Similarly, boys are more frequently expelled than girls for similar behaviors, reflecting gendered expectations about “appropriate” conduct.
The Lifelong Impact of Early Exclusion
Expelling a preschooler isn’t just a temporary setback—it can alter the trajectory of their life. Children who experience expulsion are:
– More likely to drop out of school later. Early exclusion fosters disengagement from education.
– At higher risk for mental health issues. Labeled as “problematic” early on, kids internalize this identity, leading to anxiety or defiance.
– Less prepared socially. Missing preschool limits opportunities to build critical skills like sharing, empathy, and conflict resolution.
Families also suffer. Parents may struggle to find new programs, lose work hours, or face stigma. For marginalized communities, this reinforces cycles of inequality.
Turning the Tide: What Works
The good news? Research points to actionable solutions that reduce expulsion rates and create inclusive classrooms.
1. Support Teachers, Support Kids
Providing teachers with training in trauma-informed care, behavioral intervention, and cultural competency can transform classroom dynamics. For example, the Pyramid Model—a framework focused on social-emotional development—has been shown to lower expulsion rates by helping educators address root causes of behavior. Mentorship programs and access to on-site counselors also alleviate teacher stress.
2. Smaller Classes, Better Ratios
States like Illinois and Colorado have lowered preschool expulsion rates by capping class sizes and improving teacher-to-child ratios. Smaller groups allow teachers to build stronger relationships and address issues before they escalate.
3. Mental Health Partnerships
Collaboration with child psychologists and early intervention specialists helps identify and support children with hidden challenges. In Arkansas, a statewide initiative connecting preschools to mental health consultants reduced expulsions by 42% in two years.
4. Policy Changes
Some states, including California and Massachusetts, now ban expulsion in state-funded preschools. Instead, programs must create individualized plans for children with behavioral needs. Federal policies like the 2016 Head Start expulsion ban set a precedent for prioritizing support over punishment.
5. Family Engagement
Involving parents as partners—not adversaries—is key. Regular communication, parenting workshops, and home visits build trust. When families and teachers collaborate, children thrive.
Success Stories: Proof That Change Is Possible
Consider Chicago’s Child-Parent Centers, which serve low-income communities. By integrating social workers, offering small classes, and emphasizing teacher coaching, these centers have maintained near-zero expulsion rates for decades. Similarly, Connecticut’s statewide training initiative for preschool staff reduced disparities in expulsion rates by 50% within five years.
A Call to Rethink “Problem” Kids
Preschool expulsion isn’t about “bad” children or “failing” teachers—it’s a systemic issue. Addressing it requires shifting our mindset: Behaviors are a form of communication. A child who throws toys might be expressing frustration from an undiagnosed language delay. A child who refuses to sit still may need sensory accommodations.
By investing in teacher support, equitable policies, and early intervention, we can ensure preschool is a launchpad—not a barrier—for every child’s potential. Let’s replace exclusion with empathy, and judgment with curiosity. After all, the goal of early education isn’t to filter out “difficult” kids, but to help all children grow into resilient, confident learners.
The lesson is clear: When we give educators the tools to succeed and children the support they deserve, everyone wins.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Preschool Expulsion: Why It Happens and How We Can Do Better