Navigating the Dilemma: Should Parents Use Their Child’s Social Media Earnings?
The rise of child social media stars has created a modern parenting dilemma. Kids as young as five are building massive followings, earning money through brand deals, sponsorships, and ad revenue. While this can be exciting, it also raises tough questions: Who “owns” this income? Is it ethical for parents to use their child’s earnings for family expenses? What’s the best way to balance immediate needs with long-term responsibility? Let’s unpack these issues and explore practical approaches for families navigating this uncharted territory.
The Legal Gray Area
First, it’s important to understand the legal framework. In most countries, minors cannot legally enter into contracts or manage their own finances. Parents or guardians typically control earnings until the child turns 18. However, laws vary:
– In the U.S., states like California require a portion of a minor’s entertainment income to be set aside in a trust (Coogan Law), protecting it from misuse.
– Other regions have fewer safeguards, leaving decisions largely to parental discretion.
While parents can legally access these funds in many cases, the bigger question is whether they should. This decision hinges on ethics, family values, and the child’s well-being.
The Family Dynamic: Needs vs. Responsibilities
Many families view a child’s social media income as a collective resource. For example:
– Covering production costs: Camera gear, editing software, or hiring a manager often come out of the child’s earnings.
– Supporting household needs: Some parents use the money for bills, groceries, or saving for college.
– Rewarding the child: Trips, toys, or experiences tied to their “job.”
However, problems arise when earnings are spent without transparency. A 12-year-old influencer might not grasp why their $10,000 brand deal is going toward a new family car. Open conversations are crucial to avoid resentment or feelings of exploitation.
Case in point: Emma, a 14-year-old YouTuber, told me her parents used her savings to renovate their kitchen. While she initially agreed, she later felt her contributions were undervalued. “It’s my face in all those videos,” she said. “I wish I’d kept some for myself.”
Teaching Financial Literacy
Child influencers are essentially young entrepreneurs. Using their earnings as a teaching tool can set them up for lifelong success:
1. Involve them in budgeting: Show how income is allocated for taxes, business expenses, and savings.
2. Discuss percentages: Agree on a split (e.g., 50% for long-term savings, 30% for family needs, 20% for personal spending).
3. Introduce investing: Apps like Greenlight or custodial accounts let teens learn about stocks or interest.
By treating them as partners, parents foster responsibility rather than entitlement.
When Using the Money Crosses a Line
Red flags emerge when earnings are used impulsively or without the child’s buy-in:
– Lifestyle inflation: Upgrading to a luxury home or car funded solely by a child’s work.
– Parental dependency: Relying on a minor’s income to cover essential expenses long-term.
– Ignoring the child’s future: Failing to save for their education or protect against career uncertainty (most child stars don’t stay famous).
Psychologists warn that blurring financial boundaries can strain relationships. Dr. Lisa Miller, a family therapist, notes, “Kids need to trust that their efforts are respected. Sudden ‘loans’ from their savings without discussion can break that trust.”
A Balanced Approach: 4 Steps for Families
1. Separate accounts
Open three accounts:
– Trust account (long-term savings, legally protected).
– Business account (content expenses, taxes).
– Family contribution (agreed-upon percentage for shared goals).
2. Document everything
Track income and expenses meticulously. Apps like Mint or QuickBooks Self-Employed simplify this.
3. Compensate their labor
If the child spends hours filming, allocate a “salary” for discretionary spending. This mirrors real-world work structures.
4. Plan for the future
Social media fame is fleeting. Prioritize saving for education, skills development, or a backup career.
Real Stories: How Families Are Making It Work
– The Thompsons
Their 10-year-old daughter’s baking channel earns $3,000/month. They save 60% in a trust, spend 25% on ingredients/equipment, and use 15% for family vacations. “She picks the destinations,” says mom Jenna. “It feels fair because she’s part of the decision.”
– The Garcias
After their son’s gaming channel took off, they hired a financial advisor. Earnings fund his college fund and a Roth IRA, while 10% goes to charity. “We want him to understand wealth isn’t just for spending,” says dad Carlos.
The Bottom Line
Using a child’s social media income isn’t inherently wrong—it’s about how and why it’s done. The key is transparency, shared goals, and prioritizing the child’s future. As influencer lawyer Sarah Adams advises, “Ask yourself: If this money disappeared tomorrow, would my child feel their time was valued? Would they still trust me?”
By framing earnings as a collaborative effort rather than a parental entitlement, families can turn viral success into a foundation for financial wisdom and mutual respect. After all, the greatest gift isn’t the money itself—it’s teaching kids to navigate wealth with integrity.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Navigating the Dilemma: Should Parents Use Their Child’s Social Media Earnings