It’s Always Them: Navigating the Tricky Terrain of Teacher’s Pets
We’ve all been there. Sitting in class, maybe struggling with a tricky algebra problem or trying to form a coherent sentence in a foreign language. You raise your hand tentatively, hoping for a lifeline… only to see that one student already basking in the teacher’s beaming approval for the third time that hour. The thought echoes, sometimes whispered, sometimes screamed internally: “Ugh, it’s always them.”
The “teacher’s pet” – a label loaded with a complex cocktail of admiration, resentment, envy, and curiosity. But what exactly makes someone earn this title? And more importantly, what does this dynamic mean for the classroom, the teacher, the favored student, and everyone else watching? Let’s unpack this near-universal school experience.
Beyond Just Raising Their Hand: What Defines a “Teacher’s Pet”?
It’s rarely just about getting good grades. While high achievers might naturally get more positive attention, the “teacher’s pet” phenomenon is more nuanced. True teacher’s pets often display a specific combination:
1. Conspicuous Enthusiasm: They aren’t just answering questions; they seem genuinely excited by the subject matter (or at least, adept at projecting that). They ask extra questions, delve deeper, sometimes even anticipating the teacher’s next point.
2. Effortless Alignment: They intuitively understand the teacher’s expectations, preferences, and even sense of humor. Their contributions consistently align with what the teacher values most.
3. The “Go-To” Status: Teachers naturally gravitate towards them for answers, help with tasks (passing out papers, erasing the board), or as examples. They become a reliable anchor point in the classroom flow.
4. Perceived Privilege: This is key to the label. Peers perceive them as receiving preferential treatment – maybe getting the benefit of the doubt on late work, slightly more lenient grading, or simply more frequent and warmer interactions. It feels like they operate under different rules.
So, Do We Like Them? The Student Perspective is Muddled
The short answer? It’s complicated, and often depends on who you ask and how the dynamic plays out.
The Resentment Factor: This is the most common negative reaction. Seeing one student consistently singled out for praise and opportunity can breed feelings of unfairness and exclusion. “Why does their opinion matter more?” “Why do they always get chosen?” It can make other students feel invisible, undervalued, or like the game is rigged. This is where the exasperated “It’s always them!” truly takes root.
The Annoyance Factor: Sometimes, it’s not deep resentment, just plain irritation. The constant hand-raising, the eagerness that borders on sycophancy (“Brown-nosing,” anyone?), the way they dominate discussion – it can simply grate on nerves. It can feel performative or interrupt the natural rhythm of the class.
The Respect (Sometimes) Factor: Occasionally, grudging respect exists. If the “pet” is genuinely brilliant, incredibly kind, or helps others without arrogance, peers might acknowledge their abilities even if the favoritism stings. They might be seen as a valuable resource (“Ask Sarah, she’ll know”).
The Indifference Factor: Not everyone cares deeply. Some students are focused on their own work, their friends, or just getting through the day. The teacher’s pet might register as a background character in their school experience.
Behind the Desk: Why Does This Happen? (It’s Not Always Simple)
Teachers are human. While professionalism demands fairness, unconscious biases creep in. Why might a teacher gravitate towards certain students?
1. Validation and Confirmation: Teaching is tough. A student who is consistently engaged, understands the material quickly, and responds positively is incredibly rewarding. They confirm the teacher’s efforts are working, providing much-needed encouragement.
2. Ease and Flow: Relying on a reliable, quick-thinking student helps the lesson run smoothly. Calling on them avoids awkward silences or wrong answers that derail momentum, especially when time is tight.
3. Shared Passion: Sometimes, it’s genuine intellectual connection. A student who shares the teacher’s deep fascination with chemistry equations or Victorian literature creates a unique bond that’s hard to replicate with 30 others.
4. Unconscious Bias: Teachers, like everyone, have preferences shaped by their own experiences. They might unconsciously favor students who remind them of themselves, who share their background, or whose learning styles mirror their teaching style. Effortless communicators often have an edge.
5. Misplaced Helpfulness: A teacher might think they’re helping a shy or struggling student by not calling on them as often, inadvertently focusing more attention on the confident volunteers.
The Hidden Cost: It’s Not Just About the “Others”
While resentment from peers is the most visible fallout, the dynamic can harm the “pet” too:
Social Isolation: Being labeled can be alienating. Peers might exclude them, mock them, or assume they’re “stuck up,” making genuine friendships harder.
Performance Pressure: Constant expectation to be perfect, to always have the answer, can create intense anxiety. What happens when they don’t know?
Stunted Growth: Over-reliance on teacher approval can hinder the development of independent thinking or the resilience to handle criticism or failure. They might learn to perform for the teacher rather than truly explore and question.
Unprepared for Reality: The “real world” rarely offers consistent, unconditional positive reinforcement. The sudden lack of constant praise in college or a job can be jarring.
Beyond “It’s Always Them”: Fostering a Fairer Classroom
Acknowledging the phenomenon is the first step. How can we move towards healthier dynamics?
Teachers: Mindful Awareness & Strategy: Actively monitor participation patterns. Use random calling techniques (names on popsicle sticks, digital randomizers). Make “wait time” mandatory after asking a question to allow more students to formulate answers. Verbally appreciate different types of contributions (thoughtful questions, creative approaches, perseverance). Build relationships with all students, finding entry points beyond academics (shared interests, checking in on well-being).
Students: Finding Your Voice & Perspective: If you feel overlooked, try participating in different ways – ask a thoughtful question in class, contribute to online forums, or visit during office hours. Understand that the teacher’s interaction with the “pet” isn’t necessarily a judgment on your worth. Focus on your own learning journey. If favoritism feels truly egregious and harmful, consider respectfully talking to the teacher or a guidance counselor.
The “Pet”: Self-Awareness & Humility: Recognize the label might exist. Make an effort to connect with peers genuinely. Step back sometimes – let others have the spotlight. Use your position to help others if possible. Don’t define your self-worth solely by teacher approval.
The Takeaway: It’s Complicated, Human, and Manageable
The “teacher’s pet” dynamic is woven into the fabric of education because it stems from fundamental human tendencies – the desire for connection, affirmation, efficiency, and the perception of fairness (or lack thereof). The sting of “it’s always them” is real for those who feel sidelined, but the reality for the “them” is often more complex and less enviable than it appears.
The goal isn’t to eliminate natural connections or enthusiasm. It’s about striving for classrooms where multiple students feel seen, valued, and empowered to contribute. Where teachers consciously cultivate an environment where diverse strengths are recognized, and where every student feels they have a fair shot at being noticed – not just the one whose hand is perpetually in the air. It moves us beyond the resigned sigh of “it’s always them” towards a more inclusive “there’s space for all of us.”
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » It’s Always Them: Navigating the Tricky Terrain of Teacher’s Pets