How to Respond When a Classmate Constantly Puts Themselves Down
We’ve all been there: You’re working on a group project, chatting during lunch, or studying together when a classmate casually says something like, “I’m so bad at this—why do I even bother?” or “No one would miss me if I dropped out.” These self-deprecating comments can feel awkward, even unsettling. You want to support them, but you’re unsure how to respond without making things worse.
This scenario is more common than you might think. Many people use self-deprecation as a coping mechanism, a misguided attempt to deflect criticism or seek reassurance. But when these remarks become frequent, they can strain relationships and create an uncomfortable atmosphere. Let’s explore why this happens and how to navigate these conversations with empathy and clarity.
—
Understanding the “Why” Behind Self-Deprecation
Before reacting, it’s helpful to consider why your classmate might default to negative self-talk. Often, self-deprecation stems from:
– Fear of judgment: They might criticize themselves preemptively to avoid others doing it first.
– Low self-esteem: Persistent self-doubt can manifest as humor or sarcasm to mask deeper insecurities.
– Cultural or social conditioning: Some communities normalize self-deprecating humor as a way to bond or appear humble.
– Mental health challenges: Chronic self-criticism can be a sign of anxiety, depression, or perfectionism.
Recognizing these root causes doesn’t excuse hurtful behavior, but it can help you respond thoughtfully instead of reacting impulsively.
—
Responding in the Moment: Dos and Don’ts
When faced with a self-deprecating comment, your instinct might be to say, “Stop being so hard on yourself!” or “You’re amazing—don’t say that!” While well-intentioned, these responses often miss the mark. Here’s how to balance kindness with effectiveness:
Do:
1. Acknowledge their feelings
Instead of dismissing their words, validate their emotions. Try:
“It sounds like you’re feeling really discouraged right now. Want to talk about it?”
This approach invites openness without pressuring them to “cheer up.”
2. Offer specific encouragement
Generic praise (“You’re great!”) can feel insincere. Highlight their actual strengths:
“I noticed how prepared you were for today’s presentation. Your research made our group stand out.”
3. Redirect the focus
If the comment feels attention-seeking, gently shift the conversation:
“Let’s focus on what we did accomplish today. We’ve got this!”
Don’t:
– Laugh it off
Even if they frame it as a joke, avoid reinforcing the habit with laughter.
– Argue or over-comfort
Saying “That’s not true!” might lead them to double down to “prove” their point.
– Make it about you
Responses like “I feel bad when you talk like that” could guilt them into silence.
—
Setting Boundaries Without Alienation
What if the comments persist despite your efforts? It’s okay to set gentle boundaries. For example:
“Hey, I care about you, but it’s tough to hear you talk about yourself that way. Can we find a different way to work through this?”
This communicates care while discouraging harmful patterns. If they resist, don’t push—some people aren’t ready to confront these habits yet.
—
The Power of Modeling Self-Compassion
Sometimes, the best way to support others is to lead by example. If you openly practice self-compassion, it can inspire them to reframe their own mindset. For instance:
– Instead of saying “I totally bombed that test,” try: “That exam was tougher than I expected. I’ll review my mistakes and ask for help.”
– Celebrate small wins aloud: “I’m proud of myself for sticking with that problem until I solved it.”
Over time, this creates a classroom culture where growth—not self-criticism—becomes the norm.
—
When to Seek Outside Help
While peer support is valuable, some situations require professional intervention. If your classmate’s comments escalate to themes of hopelessness, self-harm, or suicide, don’t handle it alone. Privately encourage them to speak with a counselor or trusted adult. You might say:
“I’m not qualified to give advice on this, but I really think talking to [teacher/counselor] could help. Can I walk with you to their office?”
Remember: You’re not responsible for “fixing” someone else’s mental health. Your role is to be a compassionate friend, not a therapist.
—
Final Thoughts: Patience Is Key
Changing deeply ingrained thought patterns takes time. Your classmate might not stop self-deprecating overnight, and that’s okay. Consistency matters more than grand gestures. Keep showing up, listening without judgment, and reflecting their strengths back to them.
In the end, your willingness to engage thoughtfully—even when it’s uncomfortable—might be the lifeline they didn’t know they needed. And who knows? Your empathy could spark a positive ripple effect far beyond the classroom.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Respond When a Classmate Constantly Puts Themselves Down