Enough Already: Why Pointing Fingers at Admin Won’t Fix School Funding Woes
Let’s get this off my chest: the constant, knee-jerk blaming of school administrators for every budget shortfall, every outdated textbook, every canceled field trip? It’s not just unfair, it’s actively harmful. It’s a convenient scapegoat that distracts from the real, systemic battles being fought and masks the complex reality of how public education is funded. It’s time we stopped shouting at the messenger and started demanding real solutions.
We see it everywhere. The frustrated parent Facebook post: “How can the principal afford a new office chair but my kid’s class has 35 students?!” The teacher lounge grumbling: “District office is bloated, that’s why there’s no money for classroom supplies.” The angry community meeting: “Cut the superintendent’s salary before cutting sports!”
Here’s the uncomfortable truth administrators often can’t shout back:
1. They Didn’t Create the Funding Formula: Principals and superintendents don’t wake up and decide how much money their district gets per student. That’s dictated by layers of state legislation, local tax policies (often voted on by the public!), and complex federal grant structures. They work within a system largely outside their direct control. Blaming them for the system’s output is like blaming a cashier for the price of milk.
2. Their “Fat” Salaries Are a Drop in the Ocean: Yes, superintendent salaries can be high, especially in large districts. But let’s talk scale. Cutting a $250,000 superintendent salary (a figure often exaggerated in perception) in a district with a $100 million budget solves approximately 0.25% of the problem. It’s symbolic, not substantive. Eliminating all central office admin salaries often wouldn’t even cover the cost of hiring a handful of desperately needed teachers or counselors. The vast majority of any education budget (often 80%+) goes to personnel costs in the schools – teachers, aides, custodians, bus drivers.
3. They Are Often Fighting Bigger Battles We Don’t See: That principal you’re mad at for the oversized class? They’ve likely spent months pleading with the district office for another teacher position, only to be told the money simply isn’t there because state funding didn’t increase or local tax revenue fell short. That superintendent you think is overpaid? They’re probably spending sleepless nights figuring out how to comply with unfunded state mandates, navigate declining enrollment (which directly hits funding), or lobby legislators for more resources. They are managers of scarcity, not creators of it.
4. Mandates vs. Flexibility: Much of the funding schools do receive comes with strings attached. “Categorical funding” dictates exactly how that money must be spent – maybe it’s only for remedial reading programs, or specific technology upgrades, or special education services. An administrator can’t legally divert that “reading program” money to hire another art teacher, no matter how badly the art program needs it. Blaming them for not fixing the art program with money they legally can’t use for it is nonsensical.
5. They Are Victims Too: Chronic underfunding creates impossible choices. Do you cut extracurriculars that keep kids engaged? Increase class sizes? Defer essential building maintenance? Delay technology upgrades? Reduce support staff? Each choice directly impacts students and staff. Administrators bear the emotional and professional brunt of making these lose-lose decisions, often while being vilified by the very communities they serve. Burnout is high, turnover is significant.
So, Who Should We Be Focusing On? Where Does the Blame Actually Belong?
State Legislatures: This is ground zero. State funding formulas are the primary engine for K-12 education. When states fail to adequately fund the formulas they create, or when formulas are inherently inequitable, the funding crisis starts here. Underfunding pension obligations also creates massive budget holes years down the line.
Local Tax Policies: Reliance on local property taxes creates vast inequities between wealthy and poor communities. Districts in low-property-value areas simply cannot raise comparable funds locally, no matter how high their tax rates. This systemic inequity needs structural reform at the state level.
Federal Government: While not the primary funder, federal grants (like Title I for disadvantaged students or IDEA for special education) are crucial. Chronic underfunding of these mandates places enormous strain on state and local budgets.
The Broader Societal Value Placed on Education: Ultimately, funding reflects priorities. Are we, as a society, willing to invest in public education as the essential bedrock of democracy and economic prosperity that it is? Or are we content with chronically underfunding it while demanding ever-increasing results?
What Actually Helps? Moving Beyond Blame to Action
Instead of directing anger inward at administrators, we need to channel it outward effectively:
1. Get Educated on the Funding Streams: Understand where your school’s money actually comes from (state, local, federal) and the rules governing its use. Attend school board budget workshops. Ask for transparency. Knowledge is power.
2. Hold Elected Officials Accountable: This is paramount. Who are your state representatives and senators? What is their track record on fully funding public education? Have they supported equitable funding formulas? Attend town halls, write letters, make calls, vote based on their actual education funding actions, not just rhetoric. Demand they address the structural flaws.
3. Support Local Funding Initiatives (Understanding the Limits): While local levies are often necessary stopgaps, recognize they aren’t a long-term solution to statewide inequity. Support them when needed, but simultaneously demand your state officials fix the underlying system.
4. Advocate Collaboratively: Teachers, parents, support staff, and yes, administrators, need to be allies in the fight for adequate funding. Present a united front to lawmakers. Stop seeing admin as the enemy; see them as partners navigating the same storm in different parts of the ship.
5. Focus on Systemic Solutions: Advocate for policy changes like overhauling inequitable state funding formulas, ensuring adequate funding for mandated programs (like special education), and exploring more stable revenue sources for schools.
Administrators aren’t blameless angels – like anyone, they can make poor decisions. But making them the perpetual whipping boys for a funding crisis they didn’t create and lack the power to fundamentally fix is counterproductive. It saps morale, fuels division, and lets the actual decision-makers off the hook.
The next time you feel the urge to rant about “admin wasting money,” pause. Ask yourself: Do I actually know where the budget constraints come from? Have I directed my frustration towards the people who can actually change the equation – my elected state officials?
Let’s stop the circular firing squad. The funding crisis is real and painful. But the solution isn’t found in the principal’s office or the district HQ. It’s found in the state capitol, in the ballot box, and in our collective demand that society prioritizes its children’s future. That’s where the fight needs to be.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Enough Already: Why Pointing Fingers at Admin Won’t Fix School Funding Woes