Do I Deserve an A+? Unpacking the Weight of a Single Letter
That question – “Do I deserve an A+?” – can echo like a shout in a quiet room when a report card lands, or when you stare at a final project submission button. It’s more than just wondering about a grade; it’s often tangled up with self-worth, validation, and the immense pressure we place on academic achievement. It’s a question that deserves more than a simple yes or no. Let’s dig into what that little plus sign really means and why asking the question itself reveals something important.
Beyond the Percentage: What Does an A+ Even Represent?
On the surface, an A+ typically signifies near-perfect mastery of a subject. It means you consistently exceeded expectations, demonstrated deep understanding, completed work flawlessly (or nearly so), and perhaps even showed exceptional creativity or insight. It’s the summit of the grading scale, the gold star.
But the reality is rarely that simple. What an A+ means can shift dramatically:
1. Subjectivity in the System: Grading isn’t pure science, especially in subjects like literature, history, or art. One teacher might value original thought above all else, awarding an A+ for a risky, imperfect but brilliant essay. Another might prioritize strict adherence to formatting and structure, docking points for a single citation error. Your “deservedness” can depend heavily on who’s holding the red pen.
2. The Effort vs. Outcome Trap: Did you pour your heart and soul into a class, battling difficult concepts and working tirelessly, yet landed a solid B+? Conversely, did you find a subject naturally easy, coasting through without breaking a sweat, and snagged the A+? Does effortless brilliance “deserve” it more than hard-fought competence? This is where the question starts to sting – effort doesn’t always correlate perfectly with the letter grade outcome.
3. The Curve and the Context: Sometimes, an A+ isn’t just about your performance, but how you stack up against others (grading on a curve). Or, maybe the course material was unexpectedly easy, making an A+ less an indicator of exceptionalism and more a reflection of the baseline. The context matters.
Why Are We Asking “Do I Deserve It?”?
The sheer emotional weight behind the question points to deeper currents:
Seeking External Validation: For many students (and honestly, adults too), grades become a primary measure of success and self-worth. An A+ feels like tangible proof you are smart, capable, and “good enough.” The question arises from a need for that external confirmation.
The Pressure Cooker: We live in a world obsessed with measurable achievement. College admissions, scholarship applications, parental expectations, and competitive peer environments constantly reinforce the message: A+ = Success. Anything less can feel like failure, fueling the anxiety behind the question.
Perfectionism’s Grip: The A+ is the ultimate symbol of perfection. Asking “Do I deserve it?” can be the voice of the inner perfectionist, terrified of any perceived flaw or shortcoming, no matter how minor. It sets an incredibly high, often unsustainable, bar.
Imposter Syndrome Whispers: Even high achievers often feel like frauds. Receiving an A+ can sometimes trigger the thought, “Do they know how much I struggled? What if I just got lucky?” This undermines the sense of genuine deservingness.
Shifting the Focus: What’s More Important Than the +?
Instead of obsessing over whether you deserved that specific A+ (or didn’t get one you thought you deserved), consider reframing the narrative:
1. Focus on Mastery, Not Just Marks: Did you truly learn? Did you grapple with complex ideas, develop new skills, and deepen your understanding? That intellectual growth is the real prize, far more valuable and lasting than any grade. An A+ achieved through rote memorization without deep comprehension is arguably less “deserved” than a B+ representing genuine conceptual grasp.
2. Value the Process: Recognize the effort, discipline, and strategies you employed. Did you manage your time well? Did you seek help when stuck? Did you persevere through challenges? These are critical life skills an A+ alone doesn’t capture. Acknowledge your own hard work, regardless of the outcome.
3. Understand the Feedback: If you got the A+, what specific strengths did you demonstrate? If you didn’t, why not? Was it conceptual gaps, execution errors (like messy work or missed deadlines), or something else? Grades are feedback mechanisms. Dig into that meaningfully, rather than just the letter itself.
4. Define Success Holistically: Your intelligence, worth, and potential are not encapsulated by a single grade. Success includes creativity, resilience, collaboration, curiosity, empathy, and practical skills – things rarely measured on a traditional report card. How are you developing those?
5. Talk About It: If the question is haunting you, talk to your teacher! Ask, “Can you help me understand what distinguished an A+ level performance in this assignment?” Frame it as a desire to learn, not a challenge to the grade. Their insights might surprise you and provide valuable clarity.
So, Do You Deserve That A+?
The honest answer? It depends. It depends on the course, the teacher, the specific criteria, your effort, your learning, and frankly, a bit of luck and subjectivity. Sometimes you absolutely earned it through exceptional work and deep understanding. Other times, the system might have swung in your favor, or perhaps the grade doesn’t fully reflect the hurdles you overcame.
The more crucial question isn’t “Did I deserve this specific grade?” but:
“Did I learn?”
“Did I give it my best effort given my circumstances?”
“What skills did I build?”
“How can I improve next time?”
“Am I defining my worth by my growth, not just a letter?”
An A+ is a moment in time, a data point. It can be a wonderful recognition of excellence. But it shouldn’t be the sole measure of your capabilities or your value. True “deservingness” comes from the commitment to learning, the resilience in the face of difficulty, and the understanding that your potential is vast and ongoing, far exceeding the confines of any grade scale. Keep striving, keep learning, and remember that you are more than the sum of your pluses.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Do I Deserve an A+