“Did I Make the Right Decision?” How to Find Clarity When Doubt Creeps In
We’ve all been there. Whether it’s choosing a college major, switching careers, moving to a new city, or even ending a relationship, big decisions often leave us questioning: Did I make the right choice? This nagging doubt can feel like a mental loop, replaying scenarios of “what if” and “if only.” But here’s the truth: second-guessing isn’t a sign of failure—it’s part of being human. Let’s unpack why we doubt ourselves and how to navigate these feelings constructively.
Why We Question Our Choices
Decision-making is rarely black and white. Even with careful planning, uncertainty lingers because life is unpredictable. Psychologists call this “post-decision dissonance”—the discomfort of wondering if we’ve chosen wisely when faced with multiple valid options. For example, a student who picked engineering over art might worry they’ve sacrificed passion for practicality. A parent returning to school later in life might wonder if the time and financial investment will pay off.
These doubts often stem from three sources:
1. Fear of regret: We imagine worst-case scenarios, like missing out on opportunities or disappointing others.
2. Social comparison: Seeing peers take different paths can make our own choices feel “less than.”
3. Overvaluing permanence: We treat decisions as final verdicts rather than steps in a longer journey.
The key is to recognize that questioning a choice doesn’t mean it was wrong. It means you care about the outcome—and that’s a good starting point for reflection.
How to Evaluate Your Decision Objectively
When doubt strikes, avoid spiraling into emotional reactions. Instead, approach the situation with curiosity. Ask yourself these questions:
1. What motivated the decision initially?
Revisit your original reasons. Did you prioritize financial stability, personal growth, or happiness? For instance, if you left a stressful job to prioritize mental health, remind yourself that well-being was nonnegotiable. If you chose a school based on its scholarship offer, acknowledge that affordability mattered most at the time.
2. What’s working, and what isn’t?
Break down the outcomes. Maybe your new job has a longer commute but offers better work-life balance. Perhaps your degree program feels challenging, but the coursework aligns with your long-term goals. List tangible pros and cons to see patterns.
3. Can you course-correct?
Few decisions are irreversible. If you’re unhappy, identify small adjustments. A teacher who regrets leaving the classroom might explore hybrid roles in curriculum design. A student struggling in their major could add a minor in a field they love. Flexibility reduces the pressure to be “perfect” the first time.
4. Are you comparing your journey to others’ highlights?
Social media often showcases polished versions of people’s lives. A friend’s “dream job” might come with unspoken sacrifices, while a colleague’s seemingly perfect relationship could hide challenges. Focus on your unique priorities, not external benchmarks.
When Regret Becomes a Teacher
Regret isn’t inherently bad. Research by psychologist Neal Roese shows that reflecting on past choices can improve future decision-making—if we channel it productively. For example, someone who rushed into a career path might learn to seek mentorship next time. A person who stayed in a toxic relationship too long might prioritize boundaries moving forward.
However, dwelling on regret becomes harmful when it paralyzes you. If thoughts like “I’ve ruined my life” or “It’s too late to change” dominate your mind, challenge them. Author and professor Brené Brown notes that shame thrives in secrecy. Talk to a trusted friend, mentor, or therapist to gain perspective.
The Power of “Good Enough” Decisions
The quest for a “perfect” decision is exhausting—and unrealistic. Psychologist Barry Schwartz argues that satisficing (settling for “good enough” options) often leads to greater happiness than endlessly chasing the best possible outcome. For example, choosing a college that meets 80% of your criteria is better than agonizing over a mythical “perfect” campus.
This mindset also embraces trial and error. Thomas Edison famously framed his 10,000 failed attempts to invent the lightbulb as steps toward success. Similarly, a “wrong” decision today might reveal insights that guide you tomorrow.
Practical Steps to Move Forward
1. Create a decision journal: Write down your reasoning for big choices. Revisiting this during moments of doubt can anchor you.
2. Set a review date: Give yourself 3–6 months to assess outcomes before labeling a decision as “good” or “bad.” Progress takes time.
3. Practice self-compassion: Replace “I should’ve known better” with “I did my best with the information I had.”
4. Focus on action: If adjustments are needed, brainstorm one small step you can take this week.
Final Thoughts: Redefining “Right”
The question “Did I make the right decision?” assumes there’s a single correct path. But life is more like a branching maze than a straight line. What feels “wrong” today might open unexpected doors. A failed business venture could lead to a fulfilling career pivot. A rejected scholarship application might push you to seek alternatives that build resilience.
As philosopher Søren Kierkegaard said, “Life can only be understood backwards, but it must be lived forwards.” Trust that every choice—even the messy ones—adds depth to your story. Instead of asking, “Was this right?” try asking, “What can I learn from this?” The answer to that question will always move you forward.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » “Did I Make the Right Decision