Choosing Between a GED and Finishing High School: What You Need to Know
Deciding whether to pursue a General Educational Development (GED) credential or stick with traditional high school is a big crossroad for many students. Both paths have unique pros and cons, and the “right” choice depends on your personal circumstances, goals, and learning style. Let’s explore what each option involves so you can make an informed decision.
Understanding the Basics
High school offers a structured environment where you earn a diploma by completing required courses over four years. It’s the traditional route, often accompanied by extracurricular activities, social experiences, and teacher support. On the other hand, a GED is a series of exams that certify your knowledge in core subjects (math, science, social studies, and language arts). Passing these tests grants you a credential equivalent to a high school diploma, often in less time.
So, which path makes more sense for you? Let’s break it down.
The Case for Sticking with High School
For many students, staying in high school is the default choice—and for good reasons. First, the social and emotional growth that happens during these years is hard to replicate elsewhere. Clubs, sports, friendships, and even classroom debates contribute to skills like teamwork, communication, and resilience. High school also provides access to counselors, college prep resources, and specialized programs (like Advanced Placement or vocational training) that aren’t available to GED candidates.
Another advantage is college readiness. While a GED is widely accepted, some colleges and scholarships still view a traditional diploma as a stronger indicator of preparedness. For example, competitive universities might prioritize applicants with a full high school transcript showcasing consistent performance. Additionally, finishing high school keeps doors open for internships, dual-enrollment programs, or apprenticeships that require enrollment in a school.
However, high school isn’t ideal for everyone. If you’re struggling with bullying, health issues, family responsibilities, or a rigid schedule that clashes with work, the traditional route might feel overwhelming.
When the GED Route Shines
The GED is designed for people who need flexibility. If you’ve left high school due to personal challenges or simply want to fast-track your education, the GED lets you study at your own pace and take the tests when you’re ready. This is especially helpful for older students, parents, or those balancing work and education.
Financially, the GED can also save time and money. Instead of spending years in high school, you could earn your credential in months and enter the workforce or start college earlier. According to the GED Testing Service, over 20 million people have earned their GED since 1942, with many using it as a stepping stone to higher education or better-paying jobs.
But there are downsides. Self-discipline is critical—you’ll need to create a study plan without the structure of a classroom. Some employers and colleges still stigmatize the GED, assuming it reflects a lack of commitment (though this bias is fading). Also, while the GED proves academic competence, it doesn’t provide the extracurriculars or teacher recommendations that boost college applications.
College and Career Impact
Both paths can lead to college, but preparation differs. High school students often have access to SAT/ACT prep, college fairs, and guidance counselors. GED holders might need to take additional steps, like completing community college courses first, to demonstrate readiness for a four-year university.
In the workforce, most employers accept a GED as equal to a diploma. However, fields requiring hands-on training or internships (like healthcare or trades) might prefer candidates who’ve completed high school programs with relevant experience. On the flip side, if you’re aiming to start a business or enter a field where credentials matter less, the GED could free up time to gain real-world experience.
Consider Your Personal Situation
Ask yourself these questions:
– Is your current high school environment supportive? If you’re thriving socially and academically, staying might be worthwhile. If not, the GED could offer relief.
– What are your long-term goals? Research colleges or careers you’re interested in. Do they favor diplomas or accept GEDs?
– Can you manage independent learning? The GED requires self-motivation. Are you prepared to study solo or seek online resources?
– Do you need to work or care for family? The GED’s flexibility might align better with your responsibilities.
Real-Life Scenarios
Take Maria, a 17-year-old who left high school to support her sick parent. She studied for the GED while working part-time, passed the exams in six months, and later enrolled in community college. For her, the GED was a lifeline.
Then there’s Jake, who struggled academically but stayed in high school. With tutoring and participation in auto shop classes, he graduated with a diploma and landed an apprenticeship at a local garage. The structure of school kept him on track.
What Experts Say
Educators emphasize there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Dr. Lisa Thompson, a college admissions consultant, notes, “Colleges care more about what you’ve done since earning your credential. A GED holder with community college credits or work experience can be just as competitive as a diploma student.”
At the same time, high school teachers like Mr. Rodriguez argue, “Unless there’s a compelling reason to leave, students should stay. The life skills you gain—like meeting deadlines and collaborating—are invaluable.”
Making the Decision
If you’re leaning toward the GED, start by visiting the official GED website to review test subjects and local prep programs. Many communities offer free or low-cost classes. For those staying in high school, talk to counselors about credit recovery options or alternative schools if your current setup isn’t working.
Remember, this decision isn’t irreversible. Some students return to high school after attempting the GED, while others earn their GED and later pursue degrees. What matters is choosing the path that aligns with your current needs and future vision.
In the end, education is about growth—whether that happens in a classroom or through independent effort. Trust yourself to weigh the trade-offs, and don’t hesitate to seek advice from mentors who know your situation. Your future isn’t defined by how you earned your credential, but by how you use it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Choosing Between a GED and Finishing High School: What You Need to Know