Can the Devs Cut Down on the Tutorial Time? Finding the Sweet Spot for Player Onboarding
We’ve all been there. You eagerly boot up a shiny new game, brimming with anticipation for the adventure ahead. The opening cinematic fades, you gain control of your character… and suddenly, you’re trapped in Tutorial Town. “Press X to jump,” instructs a relentlessly cheerful NPC. “Walk forward using the left stick!” they chirp, holding your virtual hand through mechanics that feel instinctive after decades of gaming. A sigh escapes. “Can the developers please cut down on the tutorial time?”
It’s a valid question echoing across forums and social media. While learning is essential, especially in complex modern games, excessive or poorly designed tutorials have become a significant pain point. They can drain excitement, insult player intelligence, and act as a barrier rather than a gateway.
Why Tutorials Feel Like a Drag
The frustration isn’t about learning itself; it’s about how and how long we’re forced to learn:
1. Mandatory Hand-Holding: Forcing players through lengthy, unskippable sequences covering basic controls (walking, jumping, camera movement) feels patronizing to experienced gamers. It assumes zero prior knowledge, which rarely reflects reality.
2. Pacing Killers: A gripping narrative or thrilling opening sequence loses all momentum when abruptly halted for 20 minutes of isolated button prompts and pop-up explanations. The flow of discovery and immersion is shattered.
3. Information Overload: Some tutorials try to cram everything – core mechanics, combat systems, crafting, UI navigation, lore – into one overwhelming initial dump. Players retain little, leading to confusion later when they actually need the knowledge.
4. Lack of Respect for Time: Gamers have limited time. Spending a significant chunk of it passively following instructions instead of actively playing feels like a poor investment, breeding resentment.
5. One-Size-Fits-None: Rigid tutorials often fail to adapt. They don’t account for players who might skip text, those who learn better by doing, or those who simply want to dive in and figure things out through experimentation (and maybe a few failures).
But… Can Tutorials Really Just Disappear?
The answer isn’t a simple “yes, cut them all out.” Tutorials serve crucial purposes:
Accessibility: For newcomers to gaming or a specific genre, clear guidance is vital. Skipping basics entirely alienates potential players.
Complexity: Modern AAA titles often feature intricate systems (combat combos, resource management, skill trees, unique movement mechanics) that genuinely need explanation. Expecting players to intuitively grasp everything is unrealistic.
Unique Mechanics: If your game has a truly novel core system (e.g., gravity manipulation, complex spell crafting, intricate base building), dedicated teaching is necessary to unlock its potential and player enjoyment.
Setting Expectations: A good tutorial subtly teaches the game’s rules and boundaries – what’s possible, what’s not, and the core feedback loops.
The goal isn’t elimination; it’s optimization, integration, and respecting the player.
How Devs Can Cut Down (and Improve) Tutorial Time
The solution lies in smarter, more elegant design that teaches effectively without feeling like a chore:
1. Contextual Learning (Diegetic Tutorials): Weave instruction into the game world and narrative. Instead of a pop-up saying “Press Y to parry,” have an early enemy attack be slow and telegraphed, with a character naturally shouting, “Block now!” Use environmental cues and level design to guide players. Breath of the Wild’s Great Plateau is a masterclass in this.
2. Modular & Optional Paths: Break the tutorial into digestible, optional modules. Offer a “Basic Controls” refresher that veterans can instantly skip, while providing deeper dives into unique systems later, accessible via a menu or in-game expert when the player encounters the need.
3. Adaptive Hints: Track player actions. If they fail a jump three times, then offer a tip. If they struggle with a specific enemy type, provide a combat hint when they respawn or rest. Systems like God of War (2018)’s adaptive hints strike this balance well.
4. “Just-in-Time” Teaching: Introduce mechanics when they become relevant, not all upfront. Teach swimming mechanics when the player reaches water, stealth mechanics when the first stealth opportunity arises, crafting when they find their first materials. Super Metroid remains iconic for its environmental teaching.
5. Respect the Skip Button: For the love of polygons, include a prominent “Skip Tutorial” option for returning players or confident veterans. Make it clear and accessible from the start.
6. Leverage Existing Knowledge: Acknowledge gaming conventions. If your jump button is the industry-standard “A” (Xbox)/”X” (PlayStation), don’t spend minutes explaining it. Assume players know common control schemes for their platform/genre.
7. Embrace Experimentation & Failure: Create safe spaces early on where failure has minor consequences, encouraging players to try things, make mistakes, and learn organically. This is far more engaging than rote instruction.
8. Clear, Concise Communication: When instructions are necessary, keep text brief, voice lines snappy, and visual cues clean. Avoid walls of text interrupting gameplay.
The Sweet Spot: Trusting Your Players
Cutting down tutorial time isn’t just about shortening minutes; it’s about shifting the philosophy. It’s about trusting the player’s intelligence, curiosity, and ability to learn through doing. It’s about respecting their time and desire to engage with the core experience quickly.
Developers can significantly reduce the feeling of slog. By prioritizing integration over interruption, optionality over obligation, and contextual learning over isolated lectures, they can create onboarding experiences that feel seamless, engaging, and respectful. The result? Players hit the ground running, immersed in the world and excited for the journey, rather than sighing and asking, “Can we please just play the game now?” The answer, thankfully, can increasingly be a resounding “Yes.”
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Can the Devs Cut Down on the Tutorial Time