Can the Devs Cut Down on the Tutorial Time? Finding the Sweet Spot for Onboarding
Let’s be honest. You’ve just booted up that hotly anticipated new game. The intro cinematic fades, the controller feels perfectly balanced in your hands… and then the tutorial messages start flooding in. “Press X to Jump.” “Move the Left Stick to Move.” “Press Square to Interact.” For what feels like an eternity. That initial excitement can quickly curdle into impatience. So, the question echoes in forums and comment sections: Can the Devs cut down on the tutorial time?
It’s a valid frustration. Nobody enjoys feeling like they’re stuck in game kindergarten, especially seasoned players encountering mechanics they’ve mastered a hundred times before. But the answer isn’t a simple “Yes, make them shorter!” The real challenge for developers is far more nuanced: How can we make learning the game efficient, effective, and actually enjoyable?
Why Tutorials Feel Like Molasses:
The Fear of the Lost Player: Developers dread players bouncing off their game because they got stuck early. This leads to over-explaining, bombarding players with text boxes and forced walkthroughs for even basic actions, assuming zero prior knowledge. It’s safety-first design, often at the expense of flow.
Complexity Creep: Modern games are intricate beasts. Open worlds, crafting systems, skill trees, relationship meters, unique movement mechanics – the sheer number of interlocking systems demands explanation. Packing all that into the first hour creates a dense, overwhelming info dump.
Treating Everyone Like a Beginner: Not every player is a beginner. Veterans often chafe at being forced through basic controls they’ve known for decades across countless games. The lack of options to skip or streamline this process is a major pain point.
The Hidden Costs of the Long Tutorial:
1. Momentum Killer: That initial burst of excitement and discovery is crucial. A sluggish, hand-holdy tutorial saps that energy, replacing wonder with tedium before the real game even begins.
2. Player Agency Stifled: Games are about agency. Forced tutorials, especially unskippable ones, remove player choice. You’re not playing; you’re being instructed. This contradicts the core appeal of the medium.
3. Teaching Bad Habits: Paradoxically, lengthy tutorials can make players less engaged. If the game constantly pauses to tell you exactly what button to press next, players might stop actively observing their environment or experimenting. They become passive receivers of instruction rather than active learners.
4. Day 1 Drop-off: If the opening hour is a slog, players are far more likely to quit and never return. First impressions matter immensely.
So, Can They Cut It Down? Absolutely – But It’s About Smart Design, Not Just Scissors.
Simply chopping the tutorial duration isn’t the solution if it leaves players confused. The goal is smarter, more integrated, and more respectful onboarding. Here’s how devs can achieve that:
1. Contextual Learning (Show, Don’t Tell): This is the gold standard. Instead of a text box saying “Press X to Jump,” place a small gap players must jump over. Instead of explaining stealth mechanics, design an opening area where being seen has immediate, clear consequences (guards sound alarms, enemies swarm). Games like Dark Souls, Elden Ring, and the Metroid series excel at this. The environment itself teaches you.
2. Progressive Unfolding: Don’t dump every system at the door. Introduce core movement and interaction first. Then, as the player naturally progresses and needs it, introduce crafting, skill trees, or advanced combat techniques. God of War (2018) did this masterfully, slowly layering complexity onto Kratos’s moveset and gear over many hours.
3. Respect Player Intelligence & Experience:
Offer Skipping: A simple “Hold Button to Skip Tutorial” for experienced players is a baseline courtesy.
Dynamic Hints: Use optional, contextual hints that appear briefly when the player seems stuck (lingering near a puzzle element, repeatedly failing a jump). Make them easy to dismiss.
Granular Options: Allow players to toggle different tutorial elements (basic movement, combat hints, system explanations) independently in the options menu.
4. The Genius of the Interactive Sandbox: Give players a safe, consequence-free space early on to experiment with controls and basic mechanics. Super Mario Bros.’ iconic World 1-1 is a masterclass – simple jumps, basic enemies, and hidden secrets teach everything through play.
5. Diegetic Integration: Weave tutorials into the game’s world and narrative. A mentor character showing you how to parry feels more natural than a floating UI prompt. A discovered journal explaining the alchemy system fits better lore-wise than a sudden menu pop-up. Horizon Zero Dawn integrated learning how to override machines directly into Aloy’s journey of discovery.
6. Embrace Failure as a Teacher: Allow players to fail safely and learn from it. A pit you can fall into teaches jumping distance better than a text box. Getting spotted by a guard teaches stealth better than a pre-mission lecture. Design early challenges where failure is low-stakes but highly informative. Portal is built on this principle.
7. Leverage Existing Conventions: While innovation is great, leveraging established control schemes (WASD for movement on PC, standard controller mappings) means many players arrive with foundational knowledge. Respect that baseline.
The Verdict: It’s Not (Just) About Time
So, can the Devs cut down on the tutorial time? Yes, they can and often should. But the focus shouldn’t solely be on the clock. The real win is eliminating the feeling of being trapped in a tutorial.
The best onboarding is often invisible. It’s the game world teaching you organically through smart design and player agency. It’s respecting your time and intelligence, offering help when needed without interrupting your flow. It’s integrating learning so seamlessly into the experience that you barely notice you’re being taught.
Players aren’t asking for less guidance; they’re asking for better guidance. They want to dive into the fun, the challenge, the story. They want the devs to trust them to explore, experiment, and sometimes fail – because that’s where the real magic of discovery and mastery happens. Cutting down on explicit instruction time is possible, but the path forward is paved with intelligent design, contextual learning, and profound respect for the player sitting down to experience the world the developers crafted. That’s the sweet spot we should all be aiming for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Can the Devs Cut Down on the Tutorial Time