Beyond the Viral Confession: What Are Kids Actually Reading in High School Today?
That online confession – “I’m 26 and have only read 3 books all the way through” – resonates uncomfortably. It sparks immediate questions, especially for parents and educators: If high school is supposed to build lifelong readers, what exactly are students encountering in their assigned reading? Is the curriculum itself contributing to this disconnect?
Gone are the days of a single, monolithic “high school canon.” While certain classics endure, today’s high school reading lists are more diverse, complex, and often contentious than ever. Let’s explore the landscape:
The Enduring Titans (But Maybe Not How You Remember):
Shakespeare: Romeo and Juliet (9th grade staple), Macbeth, Hamlet, and Julius Caesar remain fixtures. However, modern teaching emphasizes performance, film adaptations, and exploring contemporary parallels in themes like power, ambition, and prejudice. The goal is often less about decoding every archaic word and more about engaging with universal human drama.
Steinbeck: Of Mice and Men and The Grapes of Wrath still pack a powerful punch, prompting discussions about the American Dream, social injustice, and human resilience during hardship. Teachers often connect these to modern economic struggles and migrant experiences.
Orwell: 1984 and Animal Farm feel startlingly relevant in the digital age. Discussions now frequently pivot towards surveillance capitalism, misinformation (“fake news”), and the erosion of privacy, making Orwell feel less like a historical relic and more like a chilling prophecy.
Lee: To Kill a Mockingbird continues to be widely taught, though increasingly alongside critical discussions about its perspective (the “white savior” narrative) and limitations in portraying the Black experience in America. Many schools pair it with supplementary texts offering different viewpoints.
The Expanding Universe: Diversity Takes Center Stage
This is where the most significant shift has occurred. Reflecting a commitment to representing a wider range of voices and experiences, schools are incorporating:
Contemporary & Diverse Fiction: Books like Sandra Cisneros’s The House on Mango Street (exploring Chicana identity), Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner (Afghanistan, guilt, redemption), Marjane Satrapi’s graphic novel Persepolis (Iranian revolution), and Angie Thomas’s The Hate U Give (police violence, Black Lives Matter) are now common. These resonate powerfully with students’ own lives or expose them to crucial perspectives.
Post-Colonial & Global Voices: Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart provides a vital counter-narrative to colonial literature. Works by authors like Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie (Purple Hibiscus) or Julia Alvarez (In the Time of the Butterflies) offer insights into different cultures and histories.
Exploring Identity & Social Issues: Texts delving into race, gender, sexuality, class, and immigration are increasingly prominent. Examples include Toni Morrison’s The Bluest Eye (though its intensity often places it in higher grades or AP), Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, and Jason Reynolds’s powerful YA novels tackling contemporary struggles.
Non-Fiction & Memoir: Elie Wiesel’s Night remains a crucial Holocaust testimony. Increasingly, memoirs like Tara Westover’s Educated or Jeannette Walls’s The Glass Castle offer gripping narratives exploring family, resilience, and education itself. Ta-Nehisi Coates’s Between the World and Me sparks essential conversations about race in America.
The “Why?” Behind the Choices
The selection isn’t random. Teachers and curriculum specialists weigh multiple factors:
1. Literary Merit: Does the text offer rich language, complex characters, and enduring themes?
2. Relevance: Will it connect with students’ lives, interests, or the world they live in? Can it spark meaningful discussion about current issues?
3. Diversity & Representation: Does the list reflect the experiences of the student body and the broader world? Does it offer windows into other lives and mirrors for students’ own identities?
4. Skill Development: Does the text challenge students’ reading comprehension, analytical thinking, vocabulary, and ability to discuss complex ideas?
5. Age-Appropriateness: Is the content suitable for the maturity level of the students?
6. Availability & Resources: Are copies affordable and accessible? Are there supporting materials for teachers?
The Engagement Challenge: Why Doesn’t It Always Stick?
Despite these thoughtful (and often improved) selections, the “read 3 books” phenomenon persists. Why?
The “Required” Effect: Mandating anything can breed resentment. Reading becomes a chore, not a choice.
Pace & Depth: Covering dense classics within tight semesters often means rushing, focusing on plot summaries for tests, rather than savoring language or exploring personal connections. Students might “get through” The Scarlet Letter but never truly engage with it.
Accessibility Barriers: Archaic language (Shakespeare, Dickens), complex sentence structures (Melville), or culturally distant settings can be significant hurdles without strong contextual support and modern teaching strategies.
The Digital Avalanche: Competing for attention with smartphones, social media, streaming services, and gaming is an immense challenge. Sustained focus on long-form text is harder to cultivate.
The Assessment Problem: If assessment focuses solely on memorizing plot points or literary devices for multiple-choice tests, rather than personal response or critical thinking, the joy and deeper meaning can get lost.
Beyond the Assigned List: Cultivating Readers
The viral confession highlights a complex issue. Today’s high school reading lists are often more vibrant and relevant than critics might assume, featuring powerful classics alongside essential contemporary and diverse voices. The books themselves aren’t necessarily the sole problem.
The deeper challenge lies in how we teach them and how we foster a genuine reading culture that extends beyond the classroom walls. It requires:
Teacher Passion & Skill: Educators who model enthusiasm and use dynamic methods (Socratic seminars, creative projects, connecting texts to media).
Choice Within Structure: Offering some student choice (book clubs within units, selecting from thematic lists) builds ownership.
Focus on Connection: Prioritizing discussion about themes, characters’ motivations, and relevance over rote memorization.
Valuing All Reading: Encouraging independent reading (graphic novels, magazines, genre fiction) alongside assigned texts validates different reading preferences.
Parental/Community Support: Encouraging reading at home and discussing books as a family or community.
The goal isn’t just to check off a list of “great books” before graduation. It’s to equip students with the tools to understand complex texts, to ignite curiosity about different human experiences, and, hopefully, to plant the seed that reading isn’t just an assignment – it’s a lifelong source of understanding, empathy, and discovery. The books assigned in high school today can be powerful catalysts for that journey, but it takes more than just the list; it takes a shared commitment to making the words truly come alive.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Beyond the Viral Confession: What Are Kids Actually Reading in High School Today