Anyone Here Familiar with SoTL? Unlocking the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
Ever had that moment in the classroom? You try a new activity, brimming with hope, only to be met with blank stares or disengaged muttering. Or maybe you’ve tweaked an assignment for the tenth time, wondering if it actually helps students grasp the core concept any better than the last version. You know you’re a dedicated educator, pouring energy into your teaching. But how often do you step back and ask, systematically and rigorously: “Is what I’m doing genuinely working? How do I know? And how could I make it even better?”
If these questions resonate, then you’re already touching on the spirit of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL). Heard of it? Maybe in passing? Perhaps it sounds like something reserved for education researchers in ivory towers? Let’s demystify it. SoTL is fundamentally about educators – that means you – bringing scholarly rigor to the questions that arise naturally in our teaching practice. It’s about transforming curiosity about student learning into systematic inquiry that benefits both your students and the wider educational community.
Beyond “Trial and Error”: What Exactly is SoTL?
Think of SoTL as a mindset and a methodology. It moves beyond anecdotal evidence (“Seemed like that group activity went okay?”) or casual experimentation. Instead, it asks educators to:
1. Identify a Question: Pinpoint a specific aspect of teaching or learning you want to understand better. It could be:
“Does using concept maps improve students’ ability to see connections in this complex topic?”
“How does specific, timely feedback influence revision quality in student writing?”
“What impact does a flipped classroom model have on student preparedness for in-class problem-solving?”
“Why do students consistently struggle with this particular threshold concept?”
2. Investigate Systematically: Design a way to explore your question. This might involve:
Collecting student work samples (anonymized, ethically).
Designing short surveys or conducting confidential focus groups.
Analyzing pre/post-test data related to the concept.
Using classroom observation notes (yours or a trusted colleague’s).
Implementing a small change and comparing outcomes with a previous iteration.
3. Gather Evidence: Apply appropriate methods to collect data relevant to your question. This isn’t about massive, grant-funded studies (though it can be), but about focused, manageable inquiry within your context.
4. Analyze and Reflect: Look at the evidence you gathered. What patterns emerge? What surprises you? What does it tell you about the effectiveness of your approach and student learning? Crucially, SoTL involves critical reflection – challenging your assumptions.
5. Share and Apply: This is key to “scholarship.” SoTL isn’t just private reflection; it’s about making your findings public – through department presentations, teaching conferences, institutional repositories, or even peer-reviewed publications. This allows others to learn from your work, build upon it, and apply insights in their own contexts.
In essence, SoTL asks us to treat our classrooms and our teaching as sites for scholarly investigation, using evidence to improve practice and contribute to broader knowledge about how learning happens in our disciplines.
Why Bother? The Power of Engaging with SoTL
You’re already busy. Why add “research” to your plate? The benefits of engaging with SoTL are compelling, both personally and professionally:
Deeper Understanding of Student Learning: SoTL moves you beyond assumptions and grades. You gain concrete insights into how and why students learn (or struggle to learn) specific concepts in your course. This is invaluable.
More Effective Teaching: Evidence-based decisions replace guesswork. You discover what truly enhances learning in your specific context, allowing you to refine assignments, activities, explanations, and assessments with confidence.
Increased Job Satisfaction: Tackling teaching challenges systematically and seeing tangible improvements in student understanding is incredibly rewarding. It combats burnout by reigniting intellectual curiosity about your teaching craft.
Professional Growth & Recognition: Engaging in SoTL is a powerful form of professional development. Presenting or publishing your work builds your profile as an educator-scholar, contributing to tenure, promotion, or simply recognition among peers.
Contribution to the Educational Community: By sharing your findings, you move beyond isolated practice. You contribute to a collective understanding of effective teaching strategies within your discipline and across higher education. Your insights might solve a problem another instructor is facing.
Alignment with Institutional Goals: Universities increasingly value teaching effectiveness and innovation. SoTL provides a rigorous framework to demonstrate and enhance your teaching impact, aligning perfectly with institutional missions focused on student success.
How Can You Start? Making SoTL Accessible
SoTL might sound daunting, but it doesn’t require a PhD in Education Research. The core principle is systematic inquiry. Here’s how to dip your toes in:
1. Start Small: Don’t try to overhaul your entire course. Pick one small, manageable question. “Does adding a brief reflective prompt at the end of lab reports improve the quality of their conclusions?”
2. Leverage What You Already Do: Your assignments, exams, student work, and even mid-semester feedback surveys are potential data sources. How can you look at this existing information differently to answer your question?
3. Focus on Your Own Classroom: SoTL is deeply contextual. The goal isn’t necessarily generalizable “truth” but actionable insights for you and your students in your specific setting. What works in Physics 101 might differ from Sociology 200, and that’s okay.
4. Seek Community: Connect with colleagues! Discuss teaching challenges. Many institutions have teaching centers or faculty learning communities focused on SoTL. These are goldmines for support, brainstorming methods, and sharing findings.
5. Explore Frameworks: Models like Decoding the Disciplines (identifying and addressing bottlenecks to learning) or Classroom Assessment Techniques (CATs) offer structured, low-barrier approaches to inquiry.
6. Embrace Iteration: Your first SoTL project won’t be perfect. It’s a cycle: Question -> Investigate -> Gather Evidence -> Analyze -> Apply Changes -> New Question. See it as ongoing professional learning.
7. Ethics First: Always ensure your inquiry adheres to ethical guidelines. Usually, this involves anonymizing student data and often getting Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval or exemption, especially if you plan to share findings beyond your immediate department. Check your institution’s policies.
Overcoming the Hurdles: Addressing Common Concerns
“I’m not a researcher!” SoTL isn’t about becoming a full-time researcher; it’s about applying research principles to your teaching. Start with simple methods. You already analyze student work – do it more systematically to answer a specific question.
“I don’t have time!” Begin with micro-projects integrated into your regular teaching. Dedicate small pockets of time to analysis. The time invested often saves time later by making your teaching more efficient and effective.
“My discipline doesn’t value this.” The landscape is changing. Frame SoTL as discipline-specific inquiry – you’re investigating how students learn your subject. Highlight how it improves student outcomes, a goal valued in every field.
“What if I ‘prove’ my teaching is bad?” SoTL is about improvement, not judgment. It’s a discovery process. Finding something isn’t working is the first step to making it better – that’s success, not failure.
So, Anyone Familiar with SoTL?
If the core idea – bringing thoughtful, evidence-based inquiry to the heart of your teaching practice – strikes a chord, then you’re already closer than you think. The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning isn’t an exclusive club; it’s an invitation to any educator who cares deeply about student learning and wants to understand it better.
It’s about moving from “I think this works…” to “Here’s what the evidence shows about how my students learn this, and how I can support them better.” It transforms teaching from a private act to a scholarly, collaborative endeavor. Whether you’re reading an article in your discipline’s teaching journal, chatting with a colleague about a classroom experiment, or systematically analyzing the results of a new assignment you designed, you’re engaging with the vital spirit of SoTL.
Why not start by asking yourself just one small question about your next class? That curiosity is the spark. Exploring it systematically is the path of the scholarly teacher.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Anyone Here Familiar with SoTL