Anti-Bedsharing Parents… When Does Sharing a Bed Become Safer?
For many parents, the phrase “bedsharing” instantly triggers concern. Images of suffocation risks, entrapment hazards, and the devastating specter of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) understandably push them firmly into the “anti-bedsharing” camp. The official recommendations from bodies like the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) are clear: room-sharing (baby sleeping in the same room, but on a separate surface like a bassinet or crib) is safest for at least the first 6 months, ideally the first year. Bedsharing with an infant under 4 months old is strongly discouraged due to significantly increased risks.
But parenting isn’t static. Babies grow, toddlers emerge, and preschoolers assert their independence. If you started out staunchly anti-bedsharing, driven by safety protocols, you might eventually find yourself wondering: Is there a point where sharing a bed becomes less risky? Maybe your toddler crawled in during a thunderstorm, or your preschooler begs for morning snuggles that drift back into sleep. The “never” position can start to feel less absolute as children get older. So, when, if ever, does the risk profile change?
Understanding the Initial Risks: Why the “Anti” Stance Exists
The anti-bedsharing stance for infants isn’t arbitrary fearmongering; it’s grounded in evidence. The primary dangers associated with bedsharing, particularly in the first year, include:
1. Suffocation/Asphyxiation: A baby can suffocate if:
They become trapped between the mattress and a wall, headboard, or furniture.
An adult or another child rolls onto them during deep sleep.
Their face becomes covered by soft bedding, pillows, or even an adult’s arm or chest.
They get wedged against a soft mattress or waterbed.
2. Entrapment: Similar to suffocation, becoming stuck in an unsafe position.
3. Overheating: Sharing body heat with adults under blankets increases the risk of overheating, a known SIDS risk factor.
4. SIDS Risk: While the exact causes of SIDS are complex, unsafe sleep environments, including bedsharing with risk factors present (like parental smoking, alcohol/drug use, or extreme fatigue), significantly elevate the risk.
These risks are highest for newborns and young infants who lack the strength and coordination to move their heads or bodies effectively if their breathing is compromised. They are entirely dependent on their sleep environment being safe.
The Shifting Landscape: Developmental Milestones Matter
As babies grow and hit key developmental milestones, some of the risks associated with accidental bedsharing (like a child climbing in during the night) or intentional bedsharing begin to decrease. However, it’s crucial to understand that “safer” does not mean “risk-free,” and recommendations still generally favor independent sleep surfaces. Here’s how development plays a role:
Head Control & Rolling (Around 4-6 months): Babies gain the ability to lift and turn their heads. They start rolling both ways. This means they might have a slightly better chance of moving their face away from an obstruction if they are awake and alert enough. However, deep sleep still leaves them vulnerable. The AAP recommendation against bedsharing remains strong for this age group.
Sitting Up & Crawling (6-9 months+): Increased mobility allows a child to change position more readily. They become stronger. If they roll into an uncomfortable spot, they might be able to adjust somewhat. However, they are still small relative to an adult and can easily be rolled onto or trapped. Significant risk still exists.
Walking & Strong Communication (12 months+): By their first birthday, toddlers are much more robust. They can actively push away, vocalize loudly if distressed, and maneuver themselves more effectively. They are less likely to be accidentally smothered simply due to their size and strength compared to a newborn. This is often seen as a significant turning point where the immediate suffocation risk decreases considerably, provided the sleep environment is made as safe as possible. However, entrapment hazards and other risks (like falling) remain.
Preschool Age (3 years+): Children are significantly larger, stronger, and more capable. They can communicate clearly about discomfort. The risk of accidental smothering by a parent is extremely low at this stage. For many families who were previously strictly anti-bedsharing, this is the age where occasional or regular bedsharing might feel like a manageable, lower-risk option, especially for comfort during illness or after nightmares.
When Can “Safer” Bedsharing Be Considered? (Proceeding with Caution)
Most pediatric safety experts agree that the most significant drop in SIDS and suffocation risk occurs by age 1. Consequently, the strictest prohibitions against any bedsharing relax somewhat after the first birthday in terms of the most critical infant-specific risks. However, this doesn’t mean bedsharing becomes universally “safe” overnight. Here’s what “safer” might look like for older toddlers and preschoolers:
1. Age is Key: Generally, waiting until at least 12 months old is the minimum threshold where the suffocation risk drops substantially. Many experts and parents feel more comfortable waiting until 18 months, 2 years, or even older.
2. A Safe Sleep Environment is Non-Negotiable: Even for an older child, the bed must be made safe:
Firm Mattress: No soft mattresses, waterbeds, or memory foam toppers that could create indentations.
Minimal Bedding: Avoid heavy blankets, duvets, pillows near the child (especially under 2), and stuffed animals. Use lightweight blankets tucked in securely or consider a wearable blanket/sleep sack for the child.
No Gaps: Ensure the mattress fits tightly against the headboard and footboard. Move the bed away from walls or furniture to prevent entrapment.
Guard Rails: Consider safety rails if the bed is high or the child is prone to rolling.
No Other Children/Pets: Only one adult (or the child alone) should be in the bed initially. Avoid adding siblings or pets who could inadvertently harm the child.
Sober & Alert: Parents/caregivers must never be under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or medications causing extreme drowsiness. Extreme fatigue also impairs awareness.
No Smoking: Absolutely no smoking in the home or around the child.
3. Child Factors: Consider your child’s individual health and development. Are they generally robust and healthy? Do they have any conditions affecting breathing, muscle tone, or awareness? Prematurity or ongoing health issues might warrant extra caution.
4. It’s Still Not Risk-Free: Falling out of bed remains a possibility. There’s also ongoing debate about potential impacts on sleep quality (for both child and parents) and fostering independence. Bedsharing can become a hard habit to break.
Alternatives: The “Anti-Bedsharing” Toolkit for Older Kids
Even if bedsharing feels less risky with an older child, many parents who started out anti-bedsharing prefer to maintain independent sleep spaces. That’s perfectly valid and often recommended for consistent sleep routines. Effective alternatives include:
Room-Sharing: Continue having the child sleep in their own crib, toddler bed, or mattress on the floor in your room. This provides proximity and reassurance without sharing the sleep surface.
Floor Bed: A toddler mattress or low bed on the floor in the child’s room (or your room) eliminates fall risks and allows easy access for comforting.
Quick Comfort & Return: If a child wakes scared or upset, go to them quickly, comfort them in their own space, and then return to your bed. This teaches them they are safe in their own bed.
“Okay to Wake” Clocks: For preschoolers, these clocks can signal when it’s acceptable to come into the parents’ room in the morning, discouraging nighttime wanderings.
Consistent Routine: Predictable bedtime routines create security, reducing the need for nighttime intervention.
The Bottom Line: Safety First, Then Choice
For parents who began as staunchly anti-bedsharing due to infant safety concerns, the question of “when it becomes safe” is natural as their child grows. The suffocation risk that drives early recommendations significantly decreases after the first year, particularly by 18 months to 2 years and beyond. A preschooler sharing a bed poses a vastly different risk profile than a newborn.
However, “safer” is not synonymous with “safe.” Bedsharing with any child requires meticulous attention to creating a hazard-free sleep environment and careful consideration of parental factors like alertness. Many families find that alternatives like room-sharing or quick comforting in the child’s own space offer the reassurance they seek without reintroducing the sleep surface sharing they initially avoided.
Ultimately, if you are considering transitioning from an anti-bedsharing stance as your child gets older, do so thoughtfully. Make the environment as safe as possible, understand the reduced but not absent risks, and respect your own comfort level. The safest choice is always the one made with clear eyes, prioritizing your child’s well-being and your family’s unique needs. Consulting your pediatrician can provide personalized guidance based on your child’s health and development.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Anti-Bedsharing Parents… When Does Sharing a Bed Become Safer