Developmental Differences Between Boys and Girls: What Grandparents Need to Know
Last Sunday after church, my mom leaned against her kitchen counter and watched my 7-year-old son Jax bounce a plastic T-Rex against her kitchen window, while my 6-year-old niece Lila sat cross-legged on the peeling linoleum sorting her old mason jar of vintage buttons into neat color-coded piles. Jax bounced too hard a minute later, and the tiny succulent on the windowsill tipped over, spilling dark potting soil across the linen placemats she’d ironed that morning. She sighed, wiped her hands on her flour-dusted apron, and said, “Boys will be boys, I swear. Why can’t he sit still and be calm like Lila?” Jax’s ears turned red. He dropped the dinosaur and ran out to the back porch before anyone could say another word.
I found him perched on the top step picking at a splinter in the porch rail, muttering that he hadn’t meant to knock the plant over. He just couldn’t sit still any longer after 20 minutes stuck at the dinner table. When I carried him back inside, mom was helping Lila scoop scattered buttons back into the jar, and she repeated the line she’s said for as long as I can remember: her two sons were always wild, her only daughter (me) was always quiet, so that’s just how boys and girls are. It’s the default assumption most grandparents our age grew up with, but a lot of what looks like inherent “boy behavior” or “girl behavior” is just small, average developmental differences that get mixed up with old, rigid stereotypes.
I didn’t pull out a textbook or lecture her. I just repeated what Jax’s first grade teacher had mentioned at parent-teacher conferences a few weeks earlier. On average, boys build gross motor skills— the big-muscle control used for running, climbing, bouncing, and wiggling— a little faster than they master fine motor skills, the small hand control needed to hold a pencil, measure a cup of flour, or button a shirt. Most girls hit those fine motor and early language milestones one to two months earlier, on average. It’s not that Jax chooses to be disruptive, or that Lila chooses to be well-behaved. Their brains and bodies are just growing on slightly different timelines, for most kids. A lot of the gap gets bigger from socialization, too: we’ve all handed fussy baby boys trucks and baby girls dolls without thinking, so small early differences get amplified over time. It’s never all hardwiring.
The teacher’s trick for wiggly boys, I told mom, isn’t scolding them to sit still. It’s giving them a low-key way to move without disrupting everyone else. I suggested three tiny changes she could make that wouldn’t cost a thing, all pulled straight from Jax’s classroom routine. First, move breakable plants and knickknacks off the low windowsill where kids lean when they’re restless. Second, tuck a handful of the smooth river rocks Jax collected at the lake last summer into a jar by the dinner table, so he can roll one around under the table when he gets antsy instead of bouncing toys. Third, if he can’t make it through a whole meal on a chair, let him stand on a step stool at the counter instead of forcing him to stay seated. None of it required a big overhaul, just a little adjustment to what she expected “good behavior” to look like.
The language gap trips grandparents up just as often, especially when kids get upset. Mom grew up hearing “big boys don’t cry,” and she still defaults to telling Jax to tough it out when he falls or gets frustrated. Last summer he tripped off her porch rail and scraped his palm open, and her line “stop crying, it’s not that bad” triggered a 20-minute meltdown that none of us could calm. Most 7-year-old boys don’t have the words for “I’m embarrassed and hurt and overwhelmed” ready the way many girls the same age do. When big feelings hit, they come out as running away, throwing things, or yelling first, because they can’t name the emotion fast enough. Pressuring them to “use your words” mid-meltdown only makes it worse. I gave mom a specific line to try instead, one Jax’s teacher uses all the time: “I can see you’re really upset. Let’s sit here for a minute, and you can tell me about it when you’re ready.”
It’s just as easy to misread girls’ early language skills as a sign they’re naturally more mature or easygoing, which leads to its own set of bad habits. Mom has called Lila her “little helper” since she was a toddler, and she regularly asks Lila to give in to Jax to keep the peace— “you’re the good girl, just let him play with that for a minute.” Last Easter Jax grabbed Lila’s chocolate bunny off the table, and mom told Lila to share a bite instead of making him give it back. Being able to name her feelings doesn’t mean Lila has to set her own boundaries aside to keep everyone else happy. I told mom the rule is simple: treat Lila’s frustration the same way she’d treat Jax’s. If he takes her things, make him give them back and ask first, no exceptions. And don’t assume she only wants quiet, indoor activities. For months Lila has rambled about wanting to play soccer, and mom’s first response was always “little girls don’t get all muddy running around.” That’s a stereotype, not a developmental fact.
A month later, the changes are small but noticeable. Mom moved all her succulents to the top shelf above the fridge, and the river rock jar sits right next to the salt and pepper shakers on the dinner table. Ten minutes into our last meal, Jax reached for a rock without anyone prompting him, rolled it around under the table for 20 minutes, and made it all the way to chocolate chip cookie dessert without standing up once. When Jax knocked over Lila’s button pile mid-sort, mom didn’t tell Lila to calm down and be sweet. She said, “That took you so long to line up, I’d be mad too. Let’s pick them up together, then we’ll go tell Jax he needs to ask before he touches your things.” Lila nodded and didn’t pout for the rest of the afternoon. When she announced she wanted to climb the big oak tree in the front yard after cookies, mom didn’t say a word about little ladies. She just helped her tie her sneakers tighter and warned her about the low dead branch.
None of this means gender is a rulebook, of course. There’s a boy in Jax’s class who sits and draws detailed dinosaur pictures for an hour at recess, and a girl in Lila’s dance class who’s the first one to climb to the top of the monkey bars every day. Plenty of kids don’t fit the average timelines at all, and that’s not a problem. The point isn’t to sort grandkids into boxes based on whether they’re a boy or a girl. It’s to let go of the rigid expectations many grandparents grew up with, that say all boys have to be tough and still and all girls have to be quiet and compliant. A lot of what gets labeled misbehavior or natural goodness is just a kid moving through development at their own pace.
Mom still slips up, of course. Last week she showed me the Easter gifts she’d already bought: a frilly baby doll for Lila, a plastic construction truck for Jax. When I reminded her Jax has been begging for a watercolor set for months and Lila talks nonstop about wanting a size 3 soccer ball, she blinked and laughed and said “Old habits, I guess.” She kept the gifts, but she pulled a fridge magnet off the door that night and wrote down both kids’ actual birthday requests, so she doesn’t forget.
Last Sunday, the two kids spent an hour running around the backyard chasing mom’s tabby cat, both covered in grass stains and blue popsicle juice. Mom sat on the porch step next to me sipping iced tea, watching them trip over the garden hose cackling. “I still don’t always get why they do the things they do,” she said. “But at least I’m not yelling at Jax for wiggling every five minutes. And Lila’s got a better throwing arm than I ever did.” It’s not perfect, but it’s working for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Developmental Differences Between Boys and Girls: What Grandparents Need to Know