Texas Has a 90% High School Graduation Rate: What Other Measures Tell Us About Real Student Outcomes
Last May, I sat on scuffed folding bleachers in my neighborhood public high school’s gym in San Antonio, watching my neighbor Javi cross the graduation stage. The air smelled like floor wax and lukewarm fruit punch set out for the post-ceremony reception, and when the principal announced the district had hit a 90.3% four-year graduation rate that spring, the crowd of administrators and school board members in the front rows stood to cheer. I leaned over to Javi’s mom Maria, who was twisting her printed program between her fingers, and raised my eyebrows to acknowledge the good news. She leaned in, quiet enough only I could hear. “That’s great,” she said, “but he still has to pass two remedial math classes this summer just to place into entry-level coursework at the fire academy he’s wanted to get into since he was 14.”
Javi failed Algebra II twice: once as a sophomore when his dad lost his construction job and Javi picked up 20 hours a week at a local taco shop to help pay rent, and again first semester junior year when he fell behind after a bout of COVID. His counselor signed him up for self-paced online credit recovery second semester. He knocked out all 12 modules in two months, clicked through open-note quizzes, earned the required credit, and walked the stage on time with the rest of his class. By the official state metric, he was a success. By the metric that mattered to him, he was $600 out of pocket for summer classes and six weeks behind his original academy start date.
A month later, I sat in on a district parent advisory council meeting, where the graduation number was the first slide in the annual update, bolded at the top of the screen. I have a 10th grader of my own, Lila, so I’d showed up mostly to ask about changes to the AP schedule, but I stayed for the whole data presentation. The district’s student outcomes director walked through a dozen other metrics that never make the evening news, and by the end of the hour, I got why the 90% number feels so satisfying, and why it only tells a small sliver of what’s actually happening with kids in Texas schools.
Rising graduation rates are not a trick, or a meaningless win. Ten years ago, the state’s graduation rate hovered around 83%, and many kids who didn’t finish weren’t dropping out because they couldn’t do the work. They were kids like Javi, who had to work full time to help their families, or teen parents who had no childcare during the school day, or kids who got sick and fell so far behind there was no clear path to catch up before aging out. Districts across the state have added flexible evening classes, on-campus childcare for student parents, and credit recovery options specifically to keep those kids from walking away entirely. That is a real, tangible gain. A diploma opens doors for jobs, military enlistment, and trade programs that nothing else does, and thousands more kids have that credential now than did a decade ago.
But the other numbers the team shared that night painted a more complicated picture. Grade-level proficiency in core subjects, measured by annual STAAR tests, has barely moved in that same 10-year window. As of 2024, roughly 40% of Texas third graders aren’t reading on grade level, and 45% aren’t meeting grade-level benchmarks for math. Those gaps don’t disappear when kids move up to high school. State higher education data shows 40% of all public high school graduates who enroll in a two-year college need at least one remedial, non-credit-bearing class before they can start work on a degree or certification. For graduates who qualify for free or reduced lunch, that number jumps to 58%.
I talked to a 12th grade English teacher named Mr. Henderson, who’s worked in the district 18 years, by the cookie table after the presentation. He said the shift has been unmissable in his classroom. Ten years ago, he’d have two or three seniors a semester relying on credit recovery to hit graduation requirements. This year, it’s almost a third of his senior class. Administrators push teachers to prioritize keeping kids on track for graduation, he said, so it’s common for staff to offer full credit for late work turned in at the end of the six weeks, or let students rewrite a failed essay with a one-paragraph addition just to get a passing grade. He gets why it matters—he doesn’t want a kid who’s already showing up every day despite a chaotic home life to drop out over a few missing assignments. But he also sees graduates come back to visit who tell him they had to take two remedial English classes before they could start a nursing degree, because they never had to write a full, properly cited research paper to get their high school diploma.
Chronic absenteeism is another rarely highlighted metric that tells a very different story than the graduation rate. The district’s number hit 32% last year, up from 17% pre-pandemic, even as graduation rates stayed steady. Schools are flexible about making up missed work now, which means kids don’t fail out just because they miss a week for a family emergency or a stretch of bad health. But that flexibility also means kids can miss 15 or 20 days of school a year and still graduate, without ever building the habit of consistent attendance that every trade program, college, and full-time job expects.
I thought back to when Lila was in fourth grade, and her reading test scores came home showing she was almost a full grade level behind. Her teacher at the time told me not to stress, that she’d pass the STAAR and move on to fifth grade with everyone else. I didn’t know what else to ask back then, so I just started doing 15 minutes of paired reading with her every night after dinner: no worksheets, no quizzes, just taking turns reading the young adult fantasy novels she checked out from the library, stopping every few pages to ask what she thought the main character would do next. It wasn’t fancy tutoring, it didn’t cost anything, and by the end of fifth grade she was testing at grade level. At that meeting, I realized how lucky I was that I had the time to do that, and that I knew to check smaller, less publicized scores instead of just waiting for the end-of-year graduation update.
Since that meeting, I’ve talked to half a dozen other parents in the district about what numbers actually matter to ask about, and it’s not complicated. If you have a kid in elementary or middle school, ask for their fall and winter benchmark assessment scores (most districts use MAP or a similar test three times a year), not just end-of-year STAAR results. If they’re more than one grade level behind in reading or math, ask the counselor specifically what in-class push-in support they’re getting, not just generic “after school help.” A lot of campuses have reading and math specialists on staff, but they don’t automatically assign support unless a parent asks.
If you have a high schooler who’s been told they need credit recovery to stay on track for graduation, ask two specific questions: Does this course require a proctored, closed-note final exam to pass, and is there an in-person teacher-led option instead of self-paced online? If the only option is self-paced online, block 20 minutes one evening a week to sit with your kid while they work, and ask them to explain one concept or problem they worked through that session out loud to you. You don’t have to understand algebra or rhetorical analysis to do this. If they can walk you through what they’re doing clearly, they’re actually learning it. If they can’t, they’re just clicking through quizzes to get to the next module, and you can flag that to their teacher before they end up in a remedial class after graduation.
For teachers I’ve talked to, small shifts make a difference too. Mr. Henderson told me he added 10-minute, low-stakes mastery quizzes every Friday this year, and students can’t get credit for the unit until they come in and work through any missed problems with him during advisory period. He doesn’t turn down late work entirely, but he doesn’t let kids turn in a whole semester’s worth of assignments the week before grades are due. His credit recovery numbers are down 12% this year, and he’s already heard from two last semester’s graduates who placed directly into college English, no remedial classes required.
Last weekend, I helped Javi carry his duffel and textbooks into his fire academy dorm, about an hour outside the city. He has his high school diploma taped to the lid of his plastic storage bin, right next to the completion certificate he got for his summer remedial math class. “One got me in the door,” he said, when I nodded at the two papers. “The other one made sure I can do the dosage math for the EMT certification I need to get hired.” He passed his remedial classes with a B, and he’s on track now, but he still talks about the $600 he spent on tuition that would have gone toward his gear fees if he’d actually learned Algebra II the first two times he took it.
Earlier this month, I went to Lila’s 10th grade planning meeting, and I asked her counselor for the campus’s TSI (the Texas college placement exam) pass rate for juniors, and the percentage of graduates who complete a trade certification or two-year degree within three years of graduation. Those numbers weren’t in the standard printed handout, but she pulled them up on her computer and gave me a copy. After a group of us brought it up at the advisory meeting, the district said they’re going to start posting all those metrics right next to the graduation rate on the public website starting next school year.
The 90% graduation rate isn’t a lie, and it isn’t a failure. It’s just one measurement, counting how many kids made it across the stage. It doesn’t count what they know when they leave, or how much extra time and money they have to spend to catch up after they walk, or what habits they built while they were there. No one number can sum up how 3 million public school kids across the state are doing, and we’re all still figuring out which ones are worth paying attention to.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Texas Has a 90% High School Graduation Rate: What Other Measures Tell Us About Real Student Outcomes