What Actually Changes Teaching Practice? My Before-and-After From 8 Years In Elementary Classrooms
Rain streaked the fogged windows of my third-grade portable classroom in mid-October 2016, and I was 10 minutes into my multiplication arrays lesson, the one I’d spent 45 minutes color-coding anchor charts for the night before. Javi, a quiet kid who sat in the back row, had his head bent over his desk, pencil moving fast, and his worksheet was still blank except for his name scrawled in the top corner. I walked over, nodded at the half-drawn spinosaurus covering the page, and said the line I’d repeated to dozens of off-task kids by that point in my second year: “If you put half this much effort into your math as you do drawing, you’d be done already.”
He flinched, flipped the notebook shut, and stared at his scuffed sneakers for the rest of the lesson. I marked “off-task, lacks multiplication fact fluency” in my paper grade book, moved on to call on the three kids who always raised their hands, and didn’t think much of it until the end of the quarter. That year, Javi failed math, got sent to the office twice for shutting down and refusing to speak when teachers pushed him to answer questions out loud, and I wrote on his end-of-year report card that he “needed to build focus and motivation at home” to catch up.
Back then, I had a very clear idea of what made someone a good teacher, and what it would take to get better at the job. I showed up to every mandatory after-school professional development, took pages of color-coded notes on differentiated instruction and positive behavior systems, spent $300 of my own money that year on flexible seating bins, sticker reward charts, and the latest bestselling teacher strategy book. I rearranged my classroom library three times, rewrote my lesson plans every Sunday, and tracked every missing assignment and every clip moved down the behavior chart. I thought changing my practice meant overhauling my whole room, learning a whole new scripted system, checking all the boxes the district told me to check. If a kid still wasn’t succeeding, I figured either I hadn’t implemented the strategy right, or something outside my classroom was holding them back.
I didn’t unlearn that at a summer institute or a district training. It happened at recess duty in January of 2018, when I covered for a fourth-grade teacher who had a last-minute dentist appointment. The wind was sharp enough that most kids had piled inside to play board games, and I spotted Javi on the splintered wooden bench by the fence, hunched over that same beat-up sketchbook. I almost walked over to remind him he could go inside, but I stopped and sat down instead, no lesson plan, no agenda.
He didn’t look up for a minute, then turned the page so I could see. It was a full drawing of a T-Rex facing off against a spinosaurus, each animal marked with tiny lines and numbers. He’d looked up their actual heights and weights on the library computer, he told me, because his mom couldn’t afford internet at home, and he’d scaled them against the outline of a six-foot tall man drawn in the corner to show the size difference. He’d counted the teeth, calculated how much meat each would eat in a day, even worked out how fast they could run compared to a bike. Before I could say anything about math, he mumbled, “I hate when you make people do problems on the whiteboard in front of everyone. My brain goes totally blank and I can’t remember anything.”
I walked back to my classroom after recess and pulled out my old grade book from that third-grade year. Every single note I’d written about Javi was about what he wasn’t doing. He wasn’t paying attention. He wasn’t participating. He wasn’t turning in work. Not one note asked what I was doing that wasn’t working for him.
I didn’t go home that night and throw out all my curriculum or quit following district rules. I still give the required benchmark tests, I still go to most of the PD sessions, I still have a daily schedule posted on the wall. But the small changes I started making after that conversation are the ones that actually stuck, the ones that changed how I teach far more than any workshop ever did.
First, I stopped requiring kids to solve problems in front of the whole class. Instead, everyone writes their answer on their own small personal whiteboard and holds it up all at once. I can scan the room to see who gets it and who needs help, and no one has to stand in front of 25 other people and get embarrassed if they get it wrong. For Javi, who ended up in my fourth-grade math intervention group that semester, I scrapped the required worksheet for the measurement unit and let him turn in his dinosaur drawings instead. He calculated arrays of shark teeth, mapped the square footage of a dinosaur enclosure, converted weights from tons to pounds, and passed the end-of-unit test on the first try.
A year later, I had a girl named Lila who had full meltdowns at least once a week during independent reading, and I’d spent months following the behavior plan I’d learned in PD: send her to the calm-down corner with a timer, give her a sticker if she stayed quiet for 20 minutes, call home if she didn’t. Then she mentioned in passing one morning that her baby brother had severe asthma from mold in their apartment, and he coughed most nights, so she rarely got more than three hours of sleep. I picked up a $10 pair of wired noise-canceling headphones at the drug store on my way home that day, moved a bean bag behind my desk, and told her she could put her head down for 15 minutes right after recess whenever she was tired, no questions asked, and make up her reading work during Friday choice time. The meltdowns stopped almost entirely. I didn’t need a fancy training to make that change. I just needed to listen to what she was already telling me.
This isn’t just a classroom thing, either. I talk to parents every conference who’ve read half a dozen parenting books, attended all the positive discipline workshops, and still beat themselves up because the “proven” homework routine or bedtime schedule doesn’t work for their kid. They think they’re failing because they can’t get the strategy to stick, same as I did back in 2016. What I tell them is that almost no big, generic strategy changes how you show up for kids. What changes is the small, specific thing you learn about one actual kid, that you couldn’t get from a book or a slide deck.
I don’t do big overhauls anymore. When something isn’t working, I don’t immediately go looking for a new system. First, I spend two or three days just watching, no agenda. Instead of walking over immediately to correct a kid who’s doodling instead of writing, or wandering around instead of sitting still, I’ll stop and ask one low-pressure question about the thing they are doing: “What are you drawing?” “How many laps have you done so far?” More often than not, they’ll tell you exactly what the problem is without you having to dig for it. Then you change one small thing, not 10. If a kid can’t focus sitting at a desk, let them stand at the counter. If they can’t do 20 minutes of reading after dinner when they’re exhausted from daycare and soccer practice, let them listen to an audiobook while they build Legos, or read to you for five minutes while you make dinner. It doesn’t have to look like the example in the book to count.
Last year, I had a fifth grader named Mia who never turned in homework, no matter how many reminders I gave or emails I sent home. When I finally talked to her grandma, who was her guardian, I found out Mia watches her two younger cousins every afternoon until 8 p.m., helps make dinner and get them bathed and in bed, and never has a quiet spot or extra time to do worksheets. I’d read a dozen studies saying elementary homework doesn’t improve long-term achievement, but I’d kept assigning it anyway because that’s what teachers are supposed to do. After that conversation, I stopped assigning required homework entirely. All independent practice gets done during class time, and anything kids want to take home for extra practice is optional. That one change eliminated most of the grade-related friction I had that year, and I never would have done it if I’d just kept following the generic rules.
Javi brought me a drawing of a T-Rex wearing a sparkly teacher lanyard when he graduated fifth grade, and he told me he wanted to study paleontology when he grew up. I still have it taped to the inside of my desk cabinet. But I don’t get it right every time, even now. Just last month, I snapped at a boy named Ty who kept getting up and wandering around during writing workshop, telling him he needed to stay in his seat if he wanted to earn his Friday free time. Later, he told me his ADHD medication wears off around 1 p.m., and he can’t sit still for more than 10 minutes at a time. Now he does two quick laps around the edge of the classroom every 12 minutes, and does most of his writing standing up at the back counter.
Some days I still feel like I’m making it up as I go, one kid and one small adjustment at a time. I still get emails advertising the next “game-changing” classroom strategy, and parents still ask me what the best new homework routine or reading program is. I don’t have a big perfect answer. All I know is that none of the changes that actually mattered came from a workshop or a textbook. They came from sitting on that cold recess bench, and pausing long enough to look at what was right in front of me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Actually Changes Teaching Practice