When Your Father-in-Law Hasn’t Met His Toddler Granddaughter: How We’re Preparing for Their First Meeting
Last Tuesday night, I was wiping spaghetti sauce out of the cracks of Lila’s high chair when my husband Jake propped his phone up against the Cheerios box, right where she could see it. It was 6:30 p.m., our usual weekly call with his dad Tom, who lives 3,000 miles away in northern Maine. Tom held up a stack of wooden blocks he’d just built on his kitchen table, the same set he’s been saving for her since before she was born. Lila took one look, ducked behind my leg, and pressed her face into the back of my jeans. She didn’t make a sound for the rest of the 12-minute call.
Tom has never met Lila in person. She’s two and a half now. There was no big fight, no falling out, no hard feelings that kept us apart. He went in for a scheduled knee replacement six weeks before she was born, and picked up a staph infection in the hospital that kept him mostly housebound for 18 months. His doctor said flying was too risky, and the three-day drive across the country in his old pickup would leave him in too much pain. Back then, Jake was finishing his electrician apprenticeship, making half his current wage, and we were putting $1,200 a month toward daycare. We couldn’t afford three plane tickets, and Jake couldn’t take two weeks off work without risking his spot in the program. So we waited. Life just stacked that way.
For a long time I felt guilty about it. I’d see posts from other new parents in my local mom group of multi-generational family photos, grandparents holding newborns in the hospital delivery room, and I’d spiral a little. I’d apologize to Tom after calls where Lila refused to wave, like it was my fault we hadn’t made the trip work, like I was already ruining their relationship before it even started. I brought it up at Lila’s two-year well visit, half expecting our pediatrician to tell me I’d messed up her sense of family or something. Instead, she leaned against the exam table and shrugged. Stranger wariness between two and three is normal, she said. It’s not shyness, and it’s not a sign you’ve done something wrong. It’s her brain learning to tell the difference between people she knows and trusts in real life, and people she doesn’t. Kids that age don’t connect a face on a flat phone screen to a whole, physical person the way adults do. She can recognize Tom’s smile and his voice through the speaker, but she doesn’t have a bank of small, sensory memories to go with it: what his sweater smells like (campfire and peppermint, Jake says), how scratchy his beard is when he gives hugs, the way his boots thump on the floor when he walks in. Those little things are what build trust for toddlers, and you can’t get them over FaceTime.
That conversation changed how we handled everything. We stopped pushing Lila to perform affection on calls. Before, we’d nudge her, say “Say hi to Papa! Give him a kiss! Don’t be rude,” and she’d just shrink further into the couch. Now, if she hides or runs off to play, I just say casually to the screen, “Lila’s feeling quiet right now, she’s going to build blocks while we talk.” If she peeks around the corner to look, I don’t call attention to it. I just say, soft enough only she can hear, “Papa brought his new puppy with him today. You can come look whenever you want.” No pressure, no expectation that she owes anyone a hug or a smile just because they’re family.
We also started weaving Tom into the background of ordinary days, instead of only talking about him once a week on a call. When we make blueberry pancakes on Saturday, Jake will nod at the stack and say, “My dad makes pancakes this thick. He dumps twice as many blueberries in as the recipe says, just like we do.” When we rake leaves in the fall, I’ll tap the framed photo of Tom we keep on the fridge—him grinning next to his old coonhound Max, leaning against that beat-up Ford F-150—and say, “Papa rakes leaves at his house too. He always jumps in the pile when he’s done.” We don’t sit her down for a big lesson about who grandpa is. We just drop him into the same casual rotation as the librarian at storytime, the neighbor’s tabby cat, and the garbage man who waves every Tuesday.
Tom started sending small, cheap, regular things instead of big fancy birthday presents he thought he had to ship out to make up for missing time. In October he sent a stack of pressed red maple leaves from his yard, tucked into a folded piece of notebook paper. In January it was a sheet of pickup truck stickers he found at his local Dollar General. Last month he sent a tiny, worn plaid flannel shirt that was Jake’s when he was Lila’s age. We put it on her favorite stuffed rabbit, and it sits on her pillow every night. Those little physical things matter more than any expensive toy for a kid her age. She can hold the shirt, touch the leaves, stick the stickers on her water bottle, and tie all those things back to the man on the phone, no big effort required.
Last week, she grabbed the phone off the counter mid-call, held it right up to her stuffed rabbit’s face, and mumbled “Bunny say hi Papa.” Then she dropped it back on the counter and ran off to chase our cat. Tom wiped his eye on his sleeve and laughed, and we didn’t cheer or make a huge deal out of it, because we’ve learned if we react too big she’ll get self-conscious and stop.
Tom got cleared to fly last month. He’s coming to stay for 10 days in three weeks. We’ve already talked through how the first meeting will go, and it’s not the big, tearful airport reunion you see in movies. Jake will go pick him up alone. I’ll stay home with Lila, leave the front door propped open, and leave her block set spread out on the living room rug like it is every afternoon. No aunts or uncles or cousins are invited over the first day, no big welcome dinner, no crowd of people hovering and asking for hugs. We told Tom he can walk in, say hi, sit down on the end of the couch, and not reach for her for as long as she needs. He’s bringing his 6-month-old black lab puppy, the one he’s brought on every call for the past three months, and that’s our low-key icebreaker. Most toddlers care more about a puppy than any grown-up, anyway.
We don’t know how it will go. She might grab his hand five minutes in and drag him to her room to show him her sticker collection. She might refuse to be in the same room as him for the first two days. We’re not expecting instant, perfect grandparent bonding, like two and a half years of missed time can be fixed in one afternoon. I still get that little twinge sometimes when I look at baby photos, when I think about him missing her first steps, her first word, the time she got into the peanut butter jar and smeared it all over the couch. But that twinge doesn’t help any of us.
Last night, Lila pulled the tiny flannel shirt off her stuffed rabbit, dragged it across the kitchen to the fridge, and held it up next to Tom’s photo. “Papa coming soon,” she said. Then she dropped the shirt on the floor and ran off to chase the cat again. That’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Father-in-Law Hasn’t Met His Toddler Granddaughter: How We’re Preparing for Their First Meeting