What Actually Changes Teaching Practice? A Teacher’s Before and After (That No PD Workshop Taught Me)
The blue dry-erase marker was chipped at the tip, and the air still smelled like the apple juice Mia spilled at morning snack when I leaned over Javi’s desk in October of 2014. It was my third year teaching second grade, and I’d just run three straight small groups on two-digit subtraction with regrouping. His worksheet was covered in half-erased scrawls, every answer wrong. I’d sat through a district professional development on growth mindset just two days before, so I pulled out my cheeriest, most encouraging voice.
“Remember the steps we went over?” I said, tapping the anchor chart taped to the wall behind us. “Just take it one problem at a time. You’ve got this.”
He blinked at the paper, erased so hard the thin worksheet tore right through the 32 minus 17 problem, and dropped his head onto his folded arms. I walked away feeling frustrated, the same frustration I felt every time I followed the lesson plan exactly, did all the moves the workshop told me to do, and still nothing clicked. Back then, I thought changing my teaching worked like updating a cookie recipe: go to a training, get a new list of steps, swap out the old ingredients, and you’d get a better result on Monday morning. I had a shelf of binders crammed with PD handouts, color-coded anchor charts, sticker charts for on-time work, and a pacing guide I followed to the minute. If kids didn’t get it, I figured one of three things was true: I hadn’t explained it clearly enough, they weren’t paying enough attention, or something going on outside school was getting in the way. It never occurred to me that the problem might be that I was asking them to leave what they already knew at the classroom door.
A week later Javi crumpled his entire math packet and threw it in the classroom trash can on his way out to recess, and the office asked me to call home after school. I sat at my desk with my grade book open, the copy machine humming down the empty hall, and had the district interpreter on the line ready to tell his grandmother he was capable but refused to put in the work. Before I could get through my script, she beat me to it. He comes home every afternoon saying he’s stupid, she told me through the interpreter, who had a faint cold and kept pausing to cough. He hides his math homework under his mattress because he doesn’t want you to be mad. Then she said something that stopped me mid-note: he helps me run my taco stand at the flea market every Saturday. He counts change for three customers at a time, faster than I can. He never gets it wrong.
I showed up to class the next morning with a jar of sticky, chewed-on plastic coins I’d been storing in the closet for indoor recess. I pulled Javi aside while the rest of the class did their morning journaling, dumped the coins on the table between us, and told him I heard he was good at counting change. I asked him to show me how he’d give a customer 63 cents back if they paid a dollar for 37 cents worth of tacos. He didn’t hesitate. He didn’t use the base-10 blocks I’d spent two weeks demonstrating, and he didn’t write numbers stacked on top of each other the way the textbook required. He started at 37, counted out three pennies to get to 40, then grabbed six dimes to get to 100, and pushed the pile across the table to me. The whole thing took 10 seconds. I stood there for a minute, staring at the pile, and realized I’d spent three weeks correcting him for not being able to map the math he already did every weekend onto the arbitrary, step-by-step paper algorithm I was required to teach. He didn’t lack number sense. He lacked patience for a method that made no sense to the way his brain already worked.
That 10-minute conversation did more to change how I teach than every three-day district workshop I’ve attended in 12 years combined. Before that day, I thought lasting change had to be big: a brand new curriculum, a viral classroom management hack, a whole-school shift to a new framework. I’d try whatever the district rolled out that August, stick with it for three or four days, and when it didn’t fix every gap, I’d quietly go back to my old ways and figure I just wasn’t trying hard enough. What I didn’t get then is that teaching practice doesn’t change from a binder or a slide deck. It changes one small, unplanned observation at a time, when you stop talking long enough to notice that the kid in front of you doesn’t fit the plan you wrote on Sunday night.
A few years later, I had a student named Lila who never turned in the required three-sentence reading response every week. Old me would have marked her down for missing work, called home about accountability, added her to a lunch bunch homework club. Instead, I’d spent enough time watching her during independent reading to notice she filled every margin of her chapter book with pencil drawings of the characters. Instead of reminding her again about the three-sentence rule, I pulled her aside and asked if she’d rather draw the main character’s bedroom after that week’s chapter, and add one speech bubble of what they were thinking right after the big fight with their best friend. She turned it in the next morning, fully colored in, with a speech bubble that showed more understanding of character motivation than half the written responses I got that week. I didn’t get that idea from a differentiation training. I got it from looking.
These days, my lesson plans don’t look anything like the neat, typed documents I turned in to my principal my first few years. I leave half the small-group plan space blank, so I can jot down what kids actually say and how they actually solve problems, instead of only writing down what I plan to say. I start every new math unit with a 10-minute warm-up that has nothing to do with the textbook: I’ll ask, “If you and two friends split three cookies after school, how would you do it?” or “If you save $5 a week for a new video game, how do you keep track of how much you have?” and I write every single different method kids share on the board, not just the one that matches the end-of-unit test.
For parents who sit at the kitchen table fighting homework every night, the same trick works with almost no extra effort. Instead of opening with “let me show you how to do this,” try “show me how you’ve been trying to do this so far.” More often than not, you’ll find they don’t lack effort. They’re just taking a route you didn’t know existed. I still grade for right and wrong answers, but before I mark a problem wrong, I spend two seconds asking how they got that number. Half the “wrong” answers I see are logical, consistent mistakes: subtracting the smaller digit from the larger one in each column when regrouping is needed, for example, not proof a kid doesn’t care or can’t do the work. Pulling three kids for five minutes to talk through that one mistake works better than making the whole class redo 20 problems the next day.
None of this means I get it right every day. Last month, I rushed through a whole-group lesson on topic sentences because district benchmark testing was two weeks away and I was three days behind the pacing guide. I looked up halfway through and saw half the class picking at their shoelaces or drawing in their notebooks, and I had to stop mid-sentence, scrap the worksheet I’d copied that morning, and spend 10 extra minutes letting kids turn and talk about their own writing instead. I still have days where I default to “just follow the steps” when I’m tired or stretched too thin. I still have binders full of PD handouts on my shelf, most of which I’ve never opened a second time.
I saw Javi last spring, at that same flea market, running the taco stand while his abuela rang up orders. He’s 16 now, tall, with the same faded soccer hoodie he wore to class most days. He didn’t remember crumpling that math worksheet, or the jar of plastic coins. I didn’t bring it up. I ordered two carnitas tacos, paid with a 20, and he counted my change before the card reader next to him even booted up. I still don’t have a perfect system, and I still fall behind the pacing guide most months. But these days, I don’t ask kids to leave what they already know at the door while I teach the lesson I planned. That’s the only change that’s ever really stuck.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Actually Changes Teaching Practice