My 5-Year-Old Said His Teacher Doesn’t Like Him: What It Actually Means and How I Responded
I’m kneeling in the school parking lot, rain spitting on the back of my neck, fighting to get Milo’s stuck jacket zipper back on its track, when he mumbles it into the top of my hood. Goldfish cracker crumbs dust the cuff of his dinosaur sweatshirt, and one scuffed rain boot prods a half-crushed acorn into the asphalt. “Ms. Henderson doesn’t like me.”
My fingers freeze on the zipper. For half a second my brain spins through every worst case: she’d snapped at him for fidgeting during circle time, he’d been excluded from a birthday treat, I’d accidentally said something awkward at back-to-school night that turned her against him. I zipped the jacket the rest of the way, stood up, and tried to keep my voice even. “Want to tell me more about that?” He just shook his head, grabbed my hand, and dragged me toward the car, his backpack thumping against his back.
It hadn’t come out of nowhere, I realized later. For the 10 days before that, he’d dragged his feet getting out of the car in the morning, where the first two weeks of kindergarten he’d bolted for the door before I could say goodbye. He stopped chattering about story time and block towers on the drive home, answering every “what did you do today” with a shrug and “nothing.” I’d written it off as full-day kindergarten tiredness, the slow drag of the first school year catching up to him.
I didn’t push for details in the car. I’ve learned the hard way that 5-year-olds don’t do big serious conversations when they’re still drained from six hours around 21 other kids. After dinner, when he was spread out on the kitchen floor coloring dinosaur pictures, I grabbed my mug of tea and sat down next to him, not across the table, no forced eye contact, just grabbed a purple crayon and started doodling a tree on the corner of his paper. A minute later he said, quiet, “She never calls on me. Ever.”
Over five minutes of coloring, it all came out. She’d made him put the blocks away before his friend Javi had to stop playing, because he’d gotten to the center first. She’d sent him to sit at the end of the snack table for five minutes after he laughed milk out his nose and got three other kids snorting too. Every time he raised his hand as high as it would go, waving it even, she called on someone else. None of it sounded like abuse, or even meanness, but to Milo, it all added up to the same thing: she didn’t want him around.
That night after he went to bed, I pulled up my email and typed out a huffy, defensive note to Ms. Henderson, subject line “Concern about Milo’s experience in class.” I got two sentences in before I remembered my sister, who teaches first grade, complaining once that parents regularly fire off angry emails because their kid came home saying the teacher “hated” them, 90% of the time over a tiny rule reminder the kid misinterpreted. I saved the draft, put my phone down, and sent a much shorter note the next morning: “Quick question when you have 10 minutes after school this week? Milo’s been a little quiet about class lately and I’d love to check in.”
She called that Wednesday while I stirred boxed mac and cheese on the stove, the dog scratching at the back door to come in, Milo curled up on the couch rewinding the same Bluey episode for the third time. When I repeated what Milo had said, she laughed soft, no defensiveness, just recognition. “Oh, that makes so much sense,” she said. She walked through every incident, just like Milo had, from her side. He’d started blurting answers before she finished asking the question during math circle, so she’d started waiting to call on him until he was sitting still with his hand quiet, to give shyer kids a chance to work through the answer too. The block center timer went off for everyone 12 minutes after they arrived, so of course he had to clean up before Javi, who showed up five minutes late. The milk incident had turned into three kids blowing milk bubbles, and she just needed five minutes for everyone to calm down before they moved to art. “I never even thought he’d take that personally,” she said. “Twenty-two 5-year-olds, you’re just moving from one thing to the next, you don’t stop to explain every little call.”
That’s the thing no one really warns you about this age. 5-year-olds’ thinking is still completely concrete. They can’t separate “this adult corrected one choice I made” or “this adult didn’t give me what I wanted right now” from “this adult doesn’t like me as a person.” Grown-ups spend years learning to parse that nuance—your boss can give you feedback on a project without hating you, a friend can be busy without being mad—and 5-year-olds just don’t have that skill yet. They don’t stop to think a teacher has 21 other kids to split attention between, or that rules apply to everyone even when it’s inconvenient. The only story they can tell to explain that crummy, left-out feeling is that they’re disliked.
I also almost made the other common parent mistake in that first parking lot conversation: asking leading questions like “Was she mean to you? Did she yell?” That would have pushed him to agree with the dramatic version of events just to give me the answer he thought I wanted. Waiting for him to volunteer details on his own time kept the whole thing from blowing up bigger than it needed to be.
After I hung up with Ms. Henderson, I didn’t sit Milo down for a big serious talk. We played circle time with his stuffed animals after bath that night, no lecture attached. I was the teacher, his T-Rex, stuffed rabbit, and he were the students. I called on rabbit first, then T-Rex, then him, and when he waved his hand and yelled the answer, I reminded him, just like Ms. Henderson, that I needed him to hold it quiet so everyone got a turn. After a couple rounds, he got it, no eye-rolling, no fight. The next morning on the walk to school, I asked him to name one nice thing Ms. Henderson had done for him that week. He thought for a block and a half, then said she helped him open his glue stick when the cap was stuck. I didn’t say “see, she likes you!” I just said “that was nice of her, huh?”
Ms. Henderson did one small thing too, she told me later. She started greeting Milo by name at the door every morning, and asked him to do one tiny helper job a week, passing out crayons or taking the lunch count to the office. Thirty seconds out of her day, max.
It’s been a month now. He still comes home huffy some days. Last Tuesday he had to sit out five minutes of recess for running in the hallway, and he complained the whole drive home that the rule was stupid. But he hasn’t said Ms. Henderson doesn’t like him again. Last week he picked a scraggly dandelion on the walk to school and handed it to her when he walked in, and she taped it to the edge of her desk, right where he can see it when he comes in. When I asked him last night if he still thought she didn’t like him, he rolled his eyes like I’d asked if the sky was green. “She likes me,” he said, around a bite of apple. “She just doesn’t like running in the hall.” It’s not perfect. Some days he still comes home grumpy because she called on someone else three times in a row. But he’s learning, slow, that not every “no” or “wait” is about whether you’re liked. That’s a lesson I’m still learning sometimes, too.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 5-Year-Old Said His Teacher Doesn’t Like Him: What It Actually Means and How I Responded