Why You Should Ask Your Child What They See and Hear in Their Head When Solving Problems
My daughter was stuck on a math problem last Tuesday, and I could feel the familiar tension creeping into the room. She was hunched over her worksheet, eraser shavings scattered across the table like little snowdrifts. The problem was simple enough: if a train leaves the station at 2:15 and travels for 45 minutes, what time does it arrive? She had been staring at it for five minutes.
I did what I usually do. I pointed at the numbers and started explaining. “Okay, so if it leaves at 2:15, and we add 45 minutes, we can break that into…”
She wasn’t looking at the paper anymore. She was looking at the wall.
“Honey, are you listening?”
“I am,” she said, but her voice had that flat quality that told me she wasn’t.
I leaned back in my chair. The dishwasher was humming in the kitchen. My son was in the other room, watching something with a laugh track. I almost launched into another explanation, but instead, I asked something I’d never asked before.
“When you look at this problem, what do you see in your head?”
She turned to me, surprised. “What do you mean?”
“Like, when you read the words, does anything pop into your mind? Pictures? A voice?”
She thought about it. “I see the numbers,” she said slowly. “But they’re kind of… foggy. And I hear a voice telling me I’m going to get it wrong.”
That stopped me. I had been so focused on the mechanics of the problem—the addition, the regrouping, the answer—that I had never once considered what was happening inside her head while she worked. I assumed she was either trying or not trying. It hadn’t occurred to me that she was trying, but that her internal experience was cluttered with something I couldn’t see.
This is not a unique story. Over the past few months, I’ve started asking this question more often, both with my own kids and with the students I work with. The answers have been illuminating, sometimes funny, and often a little heartbreaking. One boy told me that when he reads, he hears his own voice but it sounds like it’s coming from far away, like someone shouting through a tube. A girl in my class said that when she does long division, she sees the numbers rearranged on a chalkboard that keeps getting erased before she can finish.
We tend to think of learning as a straightforward input-output system. You give a child a problem, they process it, and they produce an answer. If the answer is wrong, we assume the processing was faulty. So we re-explain. We offer a different strategy. We practice more. But we rarely ask about the processing itself.
Part of this is practical. In a classroom of twenty-five kids, there isn’t time to interview each one about their mental imagery. At home, when you’re trying to get dinner on the table and homework finished before bedtime, it’s easier to just correct the answer and move on. But the more I ask, the more I realize that the internal experience of problem-solving is where the real work happens—and where the real obstacles live.
For some children, the problem isn’t that they don’t understand the concept. It’s that their mind is noisy. They might be hearing a running commentary of self-doubt, or seeing distracting images, or feeling a physical sense of pressure that makes it hard to think. They aren’t choosing to be distracted. Their brain is just doing what brains do.
When I asked my daughter about the train problem, I didn’t immediately solve it for her. Instead, I asked her to describe the fog. Was it gray? Was it thick? Did it move? She said it was like trying to read through a steamed-up window. So I told her to imagine wiping the window with her sleeve. It sounds silly, but she did it. She made a little wiping motion with her hand, and then she looked at the problem again.
“I can see the numbers now,” she said.
She still got the answer wrong the first time. She added the minutes but forgot to change the hour. But she wasn’t stuck anymore. She was working.
What I’ve learned from these conversations is that children often have vivid, specific internal experiences that they don’t know how to describe—and that we don’t know to ask about. When we ask, we give them permission to notice what’s happening inside their own minds. We also give ourselves information we can actually use.
If a child says they hear a critical voice, you can ask whose voice it is. Sometimes it’s a teacher from a previous year. Sometimes it’s their own. Sometimes it’s a parent, which is a humbling thing to hear. Once you know, you can help them practice responding to it. “That voice is just a voice,” you might say. “It’s not the boss of your brain.”
If a child says they see nothing—just blankness—that’s useful too. It might mean they’re overwhelmed, or that they need to talk through the problem aloud before they can visualize it.
The practical applications are simple, and they don’t require any special training. You can ask the question casually, without making it a big deal. “What’s going on in your head right now?” works. So does “When you look at this, what do you notice?” The key is to ask without judgment, and to be genuinely curious about the answer.
I’ve started doing this with my son, who is seven and hates writing. When I asked him what he sees when he tries to write a sentence, he said, “A bunch of letters fighting.” We talked about it, and it turned out he was trying to hold the entire sentence in his mind at once, and the letters were getting jumbled. Now, when he writes, he says each word out loud before he writes it. It slows him down, but it works.
None of this is a cure-all. My daughter still gets frustrated with math. My son still avoids writing when he can. But the conversations have changed something. They’ve made the invisible visible. And that, I think, is the point.
We spend a lot of time teaching children what to think. We spend almost no time asking them how they think. When we start asking, we don’t just get better answers. We get a better relationship with the person doing the thinking. And that’s worth the extra few minutes, even when the dishwasher is running and dinner is getting cold.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why You Should Ask Your Child What They See and Hear in Their Head When Solving Problems