Only Child and Extended Family Worries: What Parents Can Actually Do
My son Eli was seven when my mother-in-law said it. We were at her kitchen table, plates of half-eaten cake, Eli on the floor building a garage out of Lego. “He plays so well by himself,” she said. “But what happens when you and Dan are gone? He’ll have no one.” The room went quiet. My husband asked about the weather. I cut a strawberry into smaller pieces for no reason.
It wasn’t the first time. At Eli’s birthday, an aunt asked if he was lonely. At Thanksgiving, a cousin wanted to know why he didn’t have a sibling. Eli didn’t seem to hear, but I did. Each comment landed like a small stone in my pocket. I carried them around for days.
The worries come from love, mostly. Extended family sees an only child and imagines a future without siblings: no one to call at midnight, no shared memories, no one to help with aging parents. They also see the present: a kid who is comfortable with adults, who can talk about dinosaurs with a 60-year-old, but who sometimes stands at the edge of a playground not sure how to enter a game. That gap worries them. It worried me too.
At parent-teacher conference that fall, Eli’s teacher, Ms. Alvarez, pulled out a sheet of paper. “Academically, he’s fine,” she said. “Socially, he’s fine too. But I notice he waits to be invited. In group work, he’ll stand near the table until someone says, ‘Sit here.’ He’s not upset. He just doesn’t push in.” She suggested we practice. Not with lectures. With games. At home, we started playing Uno and checkers with a rule: before the game, we practiced phrases. “Can I play?” “Can I have a turn?” “I don’t like that.” It felt awkward. Eli rolled his eyes. But after a few weeks, he used one at the park. A boy was building a sand ramp. Eli stood nearby, then said, “Can I help?” The boy shrugged. They built for twenty minutes. Eli came back with sand in his shoes and a calm face.
That was one small thing. The bigger thing was the extended family.
My parents are in their late seventies. I’m an only child, so when my father had a knee replacement last spring, the default was me. I took him to appointments, picked up prescriptions, called insurance. Eli came along sometimes because there was no one else to watch him. He sat in waiting rooms with a book, listening to me talk about blood thinners and physical therapy. One afternoon he asked, “Are you going to take care of me like that when you’re old?” I didn’t know what to say. I said, “I hope so. But you don’t have to worry about that now.” It sounded thin.
What I’ve learned is that only-child worries and extended-family worries often get tangled together. The family worries about the child being alone. The parent worries about being the only one caring for aging relatives. The child, if they’re perceptive, picks up both. They start to think their job is to fill every silence, to be social enough, to be grateful enough, to not be a burden.
So we made some changes. None of them were dramatic.
First, we stopped treating family gatherings as a performance. Eli used to be passed around like a conversation piece. “Tell Grandma what you learned about volcanoes. Show Uncle Mike your math test.” Now, before we walk in, we agree on a role. He can be the napkin passer, the dog walker, the cousin’s Lego helper. Having a job gives him a way to be part of things without being on display. If someone starts asking too many questions, I step in with, “He’s going to go play now. He can answer one more.” It’s not rude. It’s a boundary that keeps him from feeling like a small adult.
Second, we built horizontal relationships,
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Only Child and Extended Family Worries: What Parents Can Actually Do