Why the Best Educational Toys for 19-20 Month Olds Don’t Need Batteries (A Parent’s Perspective)
The kitchen floor is cold, but my son doesn’t seem to mind. He is sitting cross-legged with a plastic measuring cup in each hand, banging them together like cymbals. A moment later, he flips one over and starts stacking the others inside it, one by one, until the tower gets too tall and topples. He lets out a small grunt, then starts again.
This is the same child who, about a month ago, ignored the talking bus we bought him. You know the one: it sings the alphabet, asks questions, blinks lights. He watched it drive across the rug once, then walked away. The toy now lives in a basket with a few other gifts that seemed like good ideas at the time.
I am not against educational toys. But I have learned that at nineteen or twenty months, the most valuable resources are almost always the ones that let a child lead. And often, those aren’t from the toy aisle at all.
The morning after the measuring cup discovery, I gave him a clean, empty egg carton and a handful of pom-poms. He spent twenty minutes putting each pom-pom into a cup and taking it out again. Then he put the pom-poms in the lid and shook them. Then he put the carton on his head like a hat. Then he bit the corner. It’s not a toy, but he is learning: hand-eye coordination, one-to-one matching, spatial reasoning, cause and effect. None of these are things I need to teach him directly. They are things he works out by doing.
That is the shift I had to make. Instead of asking, “What does this toy teach?” I started asking, “What can he do with this?” If the answer is only, “watch it,” we don’t need it. If the answer involves opening, closing, filling, dumping, stacking, knocking down, lining up, or carrying around, we keep it.
I also started paying attention to what he naturally gravitates toward. Some toddlers love shape sorters, but mine is more of a pincher and a pourer. He will stand at the bookshelf for ten minutes taking every board book off and putting it back in a very specific order that only he understands. That sorting behavior is his way of exploring differences in size and thickness. A shape sorter would give him the same kind of satisfaction, but so does a basket of wooden spoons.
There are a few store-bought toys that do earn their place. A set of chunky wooden puzzles with pegs is one. He still can’t fit the pieces into the right slots, but he loves to take them out, stack them, and try to bite them. Over the next few months, he will slowly learn to rotate the pieces and match them. That toy stays in our rotation because it will grow with him. Same with a simple stacking ring tower. He knocks it over more than he builds it, but he is learning what happens when he swats it compared to when he gently places a ring on the peg.
What I avoid now are toys with one fixed action. A toy phone that only beeps when you press the same button again and again gets boring fast. He is at an age where he wants to be the one generating the action. He doesn’t want to be a spectator. So I have learned to look for toys that are like tools for pretend play and experimentation. Blocks, cars, animal figures, nesting cups, play scarves, paper boxes, old socks. The list is longer than you might think.
There is also a practical side. At nineteen months, everything goes in the mouth, even when you think that stage is over. I have to check any resource for small parts, sharp edges, and loose pieces. A paper towel tube is great until he flattens it and tries to eat the shredded cardboard. So I supervise, and I switch things out when they fall apart.
Another thing that surprised me: the environment matters as much as the toy. He has a low shelf in the living room where I rotate four or five options each week. When I put everything out at once, he gets overwhelmed and ends up wandering from one thing to another without settling. When I keep it limited, he stays with one activity much longer. I don’t know if he is learning more, but he is definitely practicing focusing, which is a kind of learning that will serve him later.
Most of the time, though, the best resources are ordinary life objects. Yesterday, I gave him a small pillowcase and a set of plastic cups. He spent forever stuffing the cups inside, taking them out, and putting the pillowcase on his head. He was working on object permanence, volume, and the concept of “inside” versus “outside.” I don’t need to explain that to him. I just need to let him do it.
I used to feel like I had to be teaching him something every second. If we were not singing the alphabet or pointing at flashcards, I felt like I was wasting a critical window. But watching him work with an egg carton and a handful of pom-poms, I realize he is learning exactly what he needs when he needs it. My job is not to lead him. My job is to notice what he is curious about and put more of that in his path.
There are still days when he ignores everything I put out and goes straight for the dog’s water bowl. That is fine. Some of the best learning happens in places I did not plan.
We are still figuring this all out. Some toys we bought have become permanent, and some have already been donated. The talking bus is still in the basket, and I am not sure if it will ever come back out. But I am less worried now about whether we have the “right” toys. I am more interested in watching him. He is the real resource. The rest is just stuff he can reach for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why the Best Educational Toys for 19-20 Month Olds Don’t Need Batteries (A Parent’s Perspective)