My son asked me a question the other night that I wasn’t ready for. We were sitting at the kitchen table, him pushing peas around his plate, me half-scrolling through my phone, and out of nowhere he said, “Will I get banned for asking will I get bullied?”
I didn’t fully understand it at first. I thought he meant at school. I pictured a teacher overhearing him talk about a bully and sending him to the principal’s office, which didn’t make any sense. So I asked him to say it again, slower.
He explained that in one of his online games, there’s a chat feature. Kids can report each other for saying mean things. But he’d watched a video where some kid got banned for using the word “bully” in a complaint. The moderation system apparently didn’t care about context. It just saw the word and flagged it. My son’s actual question was: if he typed “will I get bullied?” into the game chat, would the system ban him before anyone even answered?
And the sad part was, I could hear in his voice that he already believed the answer was yes.
We ended up talking for about twenty minutes about it. The conversation bounced around a lot. He told me that a few kids in his class have been using a nickname for him that he doesn’t like. It’s not violent, it’s not slurs, it’s just annoying. He’d tried telling them to stop, but they didn’t. He told his teacher, and she said she’d “keep an eye on it,” which is teacher-speak for nothing will change because nothing visible is happening.
He wasn’t telling me any of this because he wanted me to fix it. He was telling me because he was trying to figure out the rules. The school has an anti-bullying policy. The game has a chat code of conduct. His teacher has a classroom behavior chart. But in his actual lived experience, none of those systems seemed to protect him. What they seemed to do was create a new worry: if I speak up, will I get in trouble for speaking up?
That’s the part that hit me. He wasn’t afraid of the kids who were teasing him. He was afraid of the adults and the automated systems that were supposed to be on his side.
I told him he wouldn’t get banned at school for using the word “bully.” I told him that telling a teacher is always okay, even if the teacher doesn’t do much about it. But I could see that my reassurances didn’t land completely. Why would they? He’s heard plenty of stories about kids getting punished for being “disruptive” when what they were actually doing was pointing out that another kid was being cruel.
We sat with that for a bit. Then I went into the room where our old iPad lives and pulled up the game’s reporting page. I didn’t know anything about it, but I figured it was worth looking at together. The language in the “community standards” was exactly what you’d expect: respectful, inclusive, positive environment. Nothing about what to do if you’re the one being targeted. The word “bully” didn’t appear anywhere, except in a clause that said “harassment or bullying of other players is prohibited.”
So there it was, right in front of us. The rule was: don’t bully others. But there was no visible rule about what to do if you’re getting bullied. The system was built for the accused, not the accuser. For a ten-year-old, that reads as: if I say I’m being bullied, I might get flagged as someone who’s talking about bullying, which the system could misunderstand. He wasn’t being paranoid. He was being logical.
We talked about what actually happens in those systems. I explained that there are usually real people reviewing reports, but that the first filter is automated. Sometimes the software makes mistakes. He already knew that. Every kid who’s ever typed “why are you bullying me” into a game chat and gotten a warning knows that.
I asked him what he wished the game would do instead. He said he just wanted to be able to type “this kid is being mean to me” and have a real person look at it. Not a bot. Not a mute button. Just someone who reads the conversation and says, “Yeah, that’s not okay.”
That’s not a crazy ask. But it’s also not how most platforms work, especially free games that rely on automated moderation. So I told him the truth: he’s probably not going to get a real person to look at it. The best he can do is use the block and mute functions, and tell a parent, and we’ll screenshot everything and file a complaint on our end.
He visibly relaxed when I said we’d do it together. It wasn’t because he cared about the complaint process. It was because I took it seriously. I didn’t say “just ignore them” or “kids will be kids.” I didn’t lecture him about screen time. I pulled up the actual thing, sat next to him, and read the fine print with him.
There’s a lesson in this for me, and I think it’s useful for other parents. Not the lesson about online games or school policies. The lesson is about how kids talk about safety.
When my son asked “will I get banned for asking will I get bullied,” he was really asking: “Is it safe to tell someone I’m unsafe?” And the answer, in his experience so far, was genuinely confusing. At school, talking about a bully might get the bully in trouble, or it might get him labeled as tattletale. Online, it might get him banned. In both cases, the person who did the hurting isn’t necessarily the one who ends up penalized.
I’ve started being more specific with him now. Instead of saying “you can always tell me anything,” which is too vague and sounds like a slogan, I say things like: “If you think you’ll get in trouble for telling me something, tell me anyway and I’ll take the trouble with you.” That might not fix the school or the game, but it changes the math. He doesn’t have to be alone in deciding whether to speak up.
We didn’t resolve the bullying thing. The kids at school still use the nickname, and the teacher still hasn’t done anything. But the other conversation, the one about whether it’s safe to talk, feels more settled. He knows the word “bully” won’t get him banned at home. He knows I’ll read the terms of service with him. He knows that some rules are dumb, and some rules are broken, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise.
The game still might flag him if he types certain words. I can’t change that. But I can keep sitting next to him while he figures out the difference between a system that punishes words and an adult who actually wants to know what happened. That’s not a neat ending, but it’s the honest one.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My son asked me a question the other night that I wasn’t ready for