We’re standing in my kitchen, and Maya has her arms crossed. She’s seven, and she’s just informed me that my idea—making our own pizza dough from scratch—is “boring.” I’m not sure if she’s actually bored or just feeling a little unsure. Her mom mentioned that Maya has been quiet lately, quick to say “I can’t” when something looks tricky, especially at school. I want her to feel like she can do stuff, not just hear that she should believe in herself.
So I put the flour away. “Okay, you’re the boss,” I say. “What should we make?”
She looks at me like I’ve said something suspicious. Then she shrugs. “Cookies. With sprinkles.”
I get out a mixing bowl, a whisk, and a bag of chocolate chips. I also find the sugar cookies half-baked in the freezer and pull them out. “Alright, let’s do it. You take the lead.”
She looks at the frozen dough. “I don’t know how.”
“That’s fine,” I say. “I’ll teach you. But you get to decide the order, the timing, and what goes in. We’ll check the recipe together.”
That’s the shift. Instead of me telling her each step, I ask her questions. “What do we need first?” She reads the back of the box. Says, “Mix butter and sugar.” We get the butter out. She tries to spoon it, but it’s too hard. She looks at me, frustrated.
“What could make it easier?” I ask, genuinely not sure if she knows.
She thinks. “Maybe put it in the microwave for a little bit?” she says, and I nod. She does it herself—I just tell her where the button is and to use a low setting. She watches it soften, then she stirs. It’s messy. A little lands on the counter. She laughs. I don’t fix it. She adds the sugar, then the egg. She cracks it too hard and gets shell on her hand, and she says, “Oops, I broke it.”
We pick out the pieces. She doesn’t say “I can’t this time.” She just says, “I did it again.”
That’s the part that matters. Not that the cookies were perfect. They weren’t—the first batch came out a little flat, and one edge was burnt. But when her mom called to say she was on her way to pick her up, Maya said, “Wait, I have to show you what I made.” She ran to the kitchen and held up the plate like she’d won a trophy.
Her mom turned to me later, smiling. “She seems so proud of herself.”
What I didn’t tell her is that the pride didn’t come from the praise I gave her. It came from the fact that she did it. She made the decisions. She saw the result. She could point to something and say, “I made that.” That’s the kind of confidence that actually sticks—it’s built from evidence, not compliments.
I’ve been thinking about this because it’s easy to confuse cheerleading with confidence building. I can tell Maya a hundred times that she’s capable, but until she has a moment where she actually feels capable, the words don’t do much. For a seven-year-old, that moment often looks small: reading a recipe aloud, cutting a banana, choosing which stickers go on a chart, deciding which way to hang a picture.
So last weekend, when she came over again, I tried something else. I gave her a little notebook and said, “We’re going on a hunt. I have a list of things for you to find, but you can choose your own too.” I made it up on the spot: a leaf that’s bigger than your hand, something blue, something soft, anything that makes you laugh, a bug (maybe—if it’s not too fast). Not hard, not tests, just noticing.
She got really quiet, walking around the backyard with the notebook, stopping to look under a porch bench. She found a feather. She wrote “fEther” in her notebook with a pencil, and I didn’t correct her spelling. She drew a picture next to it. Then she spotted a ladybug on the fence and said, “I’m putting this in my book, but I’m not touching it.” She wrote “ladybug” and drew a circle with spots.
When we came inside, she read the whole list back to me, even the guesses at words. “I’m proud of my book,” she said. She didn’t ask me if I liked it. She just knew.
A lot of what works with kids her age, I’ve found, is creating little moments where they are the one in charge. It doesn’t need to be a big production or a complicated lesson. It can be something as simple as letting them set the table and deciding where everyone sits. Or asking “how many spoons do we need?” and letting them count. Or giving them a choice between two ways to fold laundry—and then actually letting it be okay if they do it their way.
The tricky part is that as an adult, I naturally want to fix, suggest, and redirect. I want her to succeed, and it’s hard to watch her struggle with measuring or meeting resistance from a stubborn zipper. But every time I step back and let her work through it, she does. She might take longer. She might get frustrated. But she’s learning to trust that she can figure something out, even if it feels hard at first.
One phrase I use a lot is, “What do you think we should do next?” It sounds small, but it’s powerful. It tells her that her opinion matters. It gives her practice making a plan and adjusting when things go wrong. If she says, “I don’t know,” I don’t swoop in with the answer right away. I say, “Okay, let’s look at what we have and see if that gives us a hint.” That keeps the problem-solving in her hands, not mine.
There’s a common misunderstanding that confidence means feeling good all the time. But watching Maya last week, I realized it’s actually more about being okay with not feeling good, and trying anyway. She burnt her thumb a little on a pan—not seriously, but she was startled. She said, “I don’t want to do the cookies anymore.” I said, “That’s okay, let’s take a break. We can finish later if you want, or not. It’s okay to stop.” And she sat on the couch for a minute, and then she came back and said, “Let’s use the oven mitt this time.”
That was a more important moment than the baking. She chose to go back in. She found a way to manage her own fear. I didn’t tell her what to do. I just made space for her to figure it out.
I’m not always this calm or thoughtful. Sometimes I’m tired, and I just want to make the cookies myself because it’s faster. But I’m trying to remember that the mess and the slowness are the actual material of confidence. She’s learning that she can do things, that she can make mistakes and recover, that an answer she doesn’t know yet isn’t a reason to quit.
We still have her little notebook from the scavenger hunt. It’s on my kitchen counter now, next to a jar of sprinkles. Next weekend, she wants to make “real” pizza from scratch. I told her she’s in charge. She said, “Okay, but I need to learn how to cut the cheese.” I said, “We’ll figure it out together.” That’s probably how it’ll go—a mix of me knowing and her testing, with a few torn cheese packages and one or two proud moments. I don’t need her to become a confident kitchen guru. I just want her to keep noticing that she can handle things she hasn’t tried yet. That’s about all any of us can really hope for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » We’re standing in my kitchen, and Maya has her arms crossed