What Extracurriculars Should a 9th Grader Do? A Realistic Parent’s Guide to Getting Started
My 9th grader brought it up on a Wednesday afternoon, somewhere between the drive-thru and our garage. She was telling me about a friend who had started a math club, and then, mid-sentence, she just asked: “What are some ECs I could do?”
Not in a panicked way. More like she’d heard the term thrown around at school and figured it was something she should probably have an opinion on. Still, that question made me pause. Because I knew exactly what was underneath it: the quiet suspicion that everyone else is building their résumé already, and she’s somehow behind. That pressure creeps into 9th grade earlier than you’d think.
Here’s what I didn’t say, because I was still holding a bag of groceries. I didn’t say “do what you love” or “colleges want well-rounded kids” or any of those polished phrases that mean nothing to a tired 14-year-old. Instead, after a couple of weeks of watching her circle the question, I have a more realistic answer than the standard ones.
Start with what’s already in the building.
The easiest extracurriculars are the ones your school already runs. It doesn’t sound glamorous, but the math club, the student council, the environmental club, the school newspaper—they all want members. And here’s the secret about 9th grade clubs: they’re completely fine with beginners.
My daughter ended up joining the school newspaper’s photography section even though she had never used a real camera. She almost didn’t. She was convinced everyone would know way more than her. Then she sat through one meeting and realized it was a group of teenagers arguing about which photos of the school play were usable. It was not intimidating. It just required her to be in a room after school once a week.
The two most practical things you can say to a 9th grader are “just go to one meeting” and “you don’t have to commit to anything.” Attendance is not a marriage proposal. Find out when the club meets, show up, see how it feels. If it doesn’t fit, walk away. No teacher is going to hold it against them. Nobody keeps a list.
The conversation about quitting is more important than the starting.
My son tried robotics at the beginning of his freshman year. He had a great time for the first two weeks. Then the build season got more technical, the after-school hours stretched later, and he realized the whole thing wasn’t for him. He quit after about three weeks and felt genuinely guilty. He thought he’d wasted everyone’s time, that he was a quitter, all the usual stuff.
What I told him—and what I’ll tell any parent reading this—is that 9th grade is the only time in your life where quitting is the whole point. You sample things to figure out what you don’t like. That’s data. The kid who quits robotics in September and tries photography in November is doing it right. The kid who stays on the JV soccer team just because he feels bad about leaving is the one getting stuck.
Stress that, if they end up in an EC that feels wrong, they don’t have to stick it out “for the résumé.” Two months of something that doesn’t fit, framed honestly—”I learned I’m not a robotics person”—is a perfectly normal part of figuring things out. Nobody expects a 15-year-old to know what they’ll enjoy at 30.
Try the low-friction options first.
It’s easy to overcomplicate extracurriculars. We see Instagram posts of other people’s kids doing competitive sailing or competitive debate or competitive everything, and we think it needs to be expensive and intensive. It really doesn’t.
Some of the best ECs are the ones that don’t need a parent chauffeur and some of them don’t even require the school. Let me give you a few realistic options.
The public library near our house runs a teen advisory board once a month. They sit around, plan events, eat snacks, and technically it’s volunteering. It costs nothing, it’s low commitment, and it gives kids a way to say they did something that wasn’t schoolwork. That counts. It counts as an EC too.
The YMCA has a leadership program that meets on Saturdays. It’s not competitive to join, and it’s full of other kids who don’t exactly know what they’re doing. That’s the point.
And here’s a big one nobody tells you: getting a job counts as an extracurricular. Lifeguarding, working at the movie theater, doing a paid internship at a local small business. My daughter’s friend busses tables at a diner on weekends. That’s an EC. It’s real-world experience, time management, customer service, all the stuff that looks good on paper but more importantly, it’s just useful.
One or two things is enough.
The other misconception is that you need a laundry list. You don’t. Especially in 9th grade. What actually works is one thing you’re trying because you’re curious (maybe a sport or a creative thing) and one thing that’s structured (like a club or volunteering). That’s it. That’s the whole year.
When my daughter complained she had “nothing” to write in her planner because she only had photography and the toxicology club (which mostly watches documentaries), I pointed out that she had two regular commitments. That’s not nothing. That’s a full schedule for a freshman. The kids who are doing seven ECs are usually miserable. There’s plenty of time in 10th, 11th, and 12th grade to go deeper into the things that actually stick.
What I’d say to your kid
If your 9th grader comes home with the same question, try to give them a way to move forward without the weight of a big decision. Something like: “Look at the list of clubs at school, pick two that sound interesting, and just go to one meeting each. No commitment. Just to see.”
Or: “Is there anything you’d do even if it didn’t count for anything? Start there.”
That last one is the real test. The extracurricular that ends up mattering the most isn’t the one that looks good on the college application. It’s the one they keep showing up to because they genuinely like the people, or the activity, or the way it feels when they leave the room. And you can’t plan that in advance. You can only create the conditions for it.
We’re still figuring the whole thing out. My daughter is deep in photography now, and she’s signed up to help with the school play’s social media because she wants photos of the rehearsals. She’s still not sure what she’ll do next semester. Last week she was talking about a film club that meets on Fridays.
I didn’t push her toward any of it. I just told her the truth: nobody has this figured out in 9th grade, and the kids who look like they do are mostly just trying things until something finally feels like theirs. It takes about a year to get there. Sometimes longer. And that’s completely fine.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Extracurriculars Should a 9th Grader Do