Boarding School for Sixth Form: What Parents Should Ask Before Deciding
The first time we visited a boarding school for sixth form, the housemistress said something that stayed with me all through the tour. We were sitting in a small common room with mugs of tea, waiting while our son went upstairs to look at dormitories. “The ones who leave in the first term,” she said, “are often the ones whose parents wanted it more than they did. The ones who stay have usually chosen it themselves.” She said it kindly, but I felt caught. I was the one who had booked the visit.
My son is sixteen, in his GCSE year. At the local sixth-form college, he would be one of two thousand students, and I could imagine him drifting through the corridors, unseen. We live in a small town, and he’s ready for something different. But boarding school is not an easy thing to agree on. Some friends say it’s the best preparation for university life. Others say teenagers need ordinary life—lazy Sundays, trips into town, the chance to be bored at home—not a campus with a routine. My mother thinks sixteen is too young to be sent away. My sister, who boarded for sixth form herself, says it taught her to manage her time and made her friends she still sees. There is no family consensus.
The tour was ordinary, not dramatic. We saw a science block, a music room, a row of washing machines in the basement. The boarding house smelled of floor polish and toast. In the dormitory, the beds were made with the same pale duvet covers. Every room had a noticeboard. Dan pointed at a pinboard above the pillow—a single photo of a cat. “Somebody actually lives here,” he said. It was the only thing he said all morning.
Later we sat in the school hall while current sixth formers answered questions from parents. One mum asked what happened if you were ill. A girl in a green sweater said the matron would check on you, and you could call home after lights out if you needed to. Another dad asked about weekends. There was a pause. The same girl said, “It depends. A lot of us go home on Saturday trains, but the school runs trips for those who stay.” I wrote down “Saturday trains” in the margins of the prospectus. We live about two hours away. I didn’t know if that meant he’d come home often or never.
Over lunch, I found myself next to a mother whose older son had boarded for sixth form elsewhere. She said the first term was awful. He rang every night, didn’t make friends, and wanted to leave. They made him stick it out. By February he had a group of friends and never looked back. She said this as if it should reassure me, and for a moment it did. Then she added, “His younger brother is completely different. We’re not even going to consider it for him.” I liked her for saying that. It reminded me that the question isn’t whether boarding school is good or bad. It’s whether it fits a particular child at a particular moment.
That has become the most useful way to think about it. The schools all have good results and impressive facilities. What I can’t find in the prospectus is how Dan will cope at 10pm on a Tuesday night in November, in a room he shares with someone he barely knows. So we have started asking different questions. What happens if he feels homesick on an ordinary Tuesday? Who does he talk to? How many boarders actually stay in on a Sunday, and what do they do? Is there a real rule about phones after lights out, or does everyone just lie in the dark looking at them? What do staff do if a sixth former doesn’t come to breakfast? A quick, honest answer to those questions tells you more than a list of A-level results.
At lunch, one of the parents asked a current student, “What does the school do if you just want to be left alone?” The student considered it and said, “They leave you alone, mostly. But if you don’t come to breakfast, someone will notice eventually.” That seemed like the right balance. Boarding at sixth form is not constant supervision, but it’s not empty independence either. It sits somewhere between, and the child has to be able to live in that middle space.
We also learned that sixth form boarding is not the same as boarding at eleven or thirteen. Many of the pupils are day students. The boarders disappear after lessons, and you don’t see them much until Monday. Dan noticed it before I did. He said, “The only people in the boarding house at night will be the ones who don’t live nearby. Everyone else goes home.” That means a smaller group, closer, but also a lot of evenings with the same faces. It could be good. It could feel isolated. We need to see it, not guess.
The school offers an overnight taster in March, and Dan has agreed to go. I’m relieved. I think if we had just filled in the application form, the decision would have been made by us, not by him. Instead, he’ll sleep in a real dormitory, eat the real food, and set his own alarm. He’ll see what it’s like to get through a day without one of us in the house. After that, we can talk.
In the car on the way home, I asked what he thought. He shrugged and said, “It’s okay. The food is better than I expected.” I laughed. “That’s not a reason to go.” “I know,” he said. “Can I think about it?” It wasn’t the enthusiastic yes I had quietly hoped for, and it wasn’t a no. It was a sixteen-year-old being cautious, which may be what the housemistress meant.
We haven’t decided. The application form is still on the kitchen table, half filled in. Some evenings I think the whole idea is a mistake, and other evenings I think he needs it. My partner says we can’t decide by imagining the worst. We have to picture him on an ordinary Thursday in November, living his own life, making his own mistake, finding his own way back to breakfast. That thought is harder to sit with than I expected. But it’s the right question to ask, and the overnight visit will help us answer it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Boarding School for Sixth Form: What Parents Should Ask Before Deciding