Funny Things Kids Say and What They Reveal About How Children Think
My daughter was five and eating toast when she asked, “Mommy, did you know your brain is full of soup?”
I stopped mid-pour of milk. “Full of soup?”
“Soup. It makes the dreams. It’s like a pot, and it moves at night so you dream.”
She said this with total conviction, as though telling me the weather. I almost laughed—the image was so silly and so precise. Instead I asked, “What gave you that idea?”
She explained that she’d come out of her bedroom once while my husband was watching a nature documentary about brains. “The scientist said the soup keeps the brain safe.”
It took me a second. She’d heard “cerebrospinal fluid” talked about loosely on-screen and had built a complete theory from it: the brain sits in a warm, watery liquid, and when you sleep, that liquid sloshes around, and that’s how dreams happen. Not just that—her whole statement was eerily reasonable from her point of view. She wasn’t being silly. She was putting a small piece of information into the biggest framework she had.
I told her it wasn’t soup, exactly, but a clear fluid that cushions the brain. “Like a soft blanket,” I said.
“Like soup,” she said.
I let it go.
Kids say funny things. That’s not news. But the more I think about the funny things my own daughter says, the less they feel like jokes and the more they feel like reports from a construction site. The project is in full swing. Some parts of the scaffold are exactly right. Others are wrong in interesting ways.
Take her vocabulary. Around that time, she called the sun “the outside light” and the moon “the outside light that sleeps.” It isn’t a random silly phrase. It’s a system. She had sorted the world’s lights into two categories—inside ones and outside ones—and the moon happened to be the one that was asleep during business hours. When I watered the garden, she asked me whether the plants “drank the outside light yet,” because in her view light and water were both just things that came from outside and helped things grow. There was logic inside every piece of it.
She also heard song lyrics in surprising places. For weeks, she sang along to a song about a girl who “makes no mustard.” She was so confident that I didn’t question it. Then one day she asked why a girl would make mustard, and we had to work backward until we both realized she’d been hearing a song that actually said “makes no mistake.” She’d taken the misheard words, made sense of them, and built a whole backstory where a girl’s main activity was mustard production. It didn’t make sense to me, but it made perfect sense to her. The song had said so.
In my nine years of teaching elementary school, I’ve started to see the same construction happening at desks all over my classroom. One of my third-graders was working on a geometry sheet last spring. The worksheet showed a drawing of a cube, and the question asked, “How many faces does a cube have?”
She answered, “3.”
It was a predictable wrong answer—any adult who’s ever held a box knows there are six. I had a red pen in hand, ready to mark it. But I stopped. These days, I ask before I mark. “How did you get three?”
She pointed at the cube drawing. “I counted the ones I can see. I think there are hidden ones, but they might not be the same.”
She hadn’t misunderstood the question. She’d solved it from a single point of view, picturing the cube the way it was drawn on the page. It wasn’t a silly mistake. It was a smart move with incomplete information. A five-second conversation changed a wrong answer into a real glimpse of her thinking. That’s the part I would have missed if I’d just laughed and moved on.
Around the same time, my daughter started correcting us on certain words. She said “yesterday” for any time that wasn’t right now, even if it was last month. These weren’t mistakes that needed fixing. They were young vocabulary doing extra work while the exact words were still on their way.
When you have a child, your first response to a strange sentence is usually to smile, maybe laugh warmly, and move on. There’s nothing wrong with that. Laughing tells a child that talking to you is safe. But I’ve learned that the moment right after a joke is where useful information lives. If I can spare thirty seconds, I ask a question instead of letting the moment dissolve.
The phrase I use most is “What makes you think that?” It works at home. It works in my classroom. When my daughter announces something outlandish, I don’t correct her first. I ask where the idea came from. That one prompt has produced some of the most beautiful mini-essays I’ve ever heard from a small human.
Another small move: use her logic to offer the correct version. When she said the brain had soup, I could have said, “No, that’s not true.” Instead, I said, “It’s a clear liquid, and it doesn’t exactly make dreams—something else does.” I let her adjust her theory with the new information. She didn’t mind being wrong. She minded being brushed off.
At school, where schedules are tight, it’s tempting to just correct confidently wrong answers quickly. I’ve learned to look for the answers that are oddly specific. Those are the ones worth staying with. A shrug and a guess is just a shrug. But specific wrong ideas mean a child was really building something in their head, and that something is worth examining. When I write a comment on a paper like that, I try to write a question instead of a checkmark: “Tell me how you got here.” That’s a half-sentence of feedback, and it opens a door.
This past weekend, my daughter asked if her baby cousin would have “brain soup” or “blanket water.” She’d taken my correction and folded it into her own private version of medicine. I could have reminded her that the real term is cerebrospinal fluid. I didn’t. She’ll get there in time.
Or maybe she won’t worry about the exact term for a while, and that’s fine. The way she holds onto “brain soup” makes me think she isn’t chasing scientific accuracy yet. She’s chasing the feeling of knowing something. That feeling is worth keeping. The correct words can always come later.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Funny Things Kids Say and What They Reveal About How Children Think