How to Divide Holiday Family Time When You Have Young Children
I’m standing in my kitchen on December 23rd, one hand on the phone, the other trying to open a bag of goldfish crackers with my teeth. My three-year-old is on the floor, sobbing because I cut his toast into triangles instead of squares. On the phone, my mother-in-law is saying, “So we’ll see you at noon on Christmas, then you’ll have dinner with your mom, and then you’ll come back here for dessert?” She says it like it’s a simple geometry problem. I look at the calendar. It’s a mess of red ink and arrows pointing in all directions.
This is the first year we’re attempting to see both sides of the family in one day. My son is old enough to understand that presents appear, but not old enough to understand why he’s being strapped into a car seat every three hours. My daughter is eleven months old and still naps twice a day, which means we have to plan everything around a window of time that shifts with her mood.
We used to split holidays differently. Before kids, my husband and I would just alternate years—Thanksgiving with his parents, Christmas with mine, then flip. It felt fair and simple. But after our son was born, we got guilt-tripped from both sides. My mom said she wanted to see him open his gifts. His mom said she only had the whole family together every other year. Somehow, fairness went out the window, and we became a logistics operation.
That first December with a baby, we tried to do the four-stop tour. We woke up at six, opened gifts at our house, drove forty minutes to my mom’s for brunch, drove another forty minutes to his mom’s for a late lunch, and then stopped at his aunt’s house for an hour because she was “just right nearby.” Our son slept twenty minutes in each car ride and was completely overstimulated by noon. He bit someone. I don’t remember who. By six in the evening, my husband and I were standing in his aunt’s kitchen, silently arguing over who forgot the diaper bag. We didn’t speak again until New Year’s.
So we had to change something. Not because we’re good at boundaries, but because we were exhausted. Here’s what we landed on, and it’s not a perfect system. It’s just what works right now.
We decided that Christmas morning belongs to us. No exceptions. We wake up at our own house, have pancakes, open gifts, and stay in our pajamas until at least ten. This sounds simple, but it took us two years to actually enforce it. The first time we told our parents, my mom said, “But Santa doesn’t need to travel.” My husband’s dad said, “We’ll just have breakfast ready for you by nine.” We had to say, no, we’re staying home. That’s it. We didn’t offer an alternative or a compromise. We just repeated it until they heard us. It felt rude at the time, but it’s the only reason Christmas is tolerable now. With young kids, the morning sets the tone. If they’re rushed out the door before they’ve had time to play with a single toy, everyone’s miserable.
After that, we split the rest of the day into two blocks. My side gets the late morning, his side gets the afternoon. We visit one side for a couple of hours, leave for the kids’ nap, and then go to the other side for an early dinner. We don’t stay late. We bring our own pack-and-play and a blackout curtain. We’ve learned to make a place feel nap-friendly even if the grandparents’ house is chaotic.
But here’s the piece I didn’t expect: even with a schedule, the emotional stress doesn’t disappear. It just shifts. We’re not doing four stops anymore, but I still feel like a referee. My son loves both grandmothers, but he doesn’t understand why we have to leave one house to go to another. When we pack up to leave my mom’s, he’ll say, “But I’m playing with Grandpa.” And I have to tell him we’ll see Grandpa again soon. He doesn’t get time the way adults do. An hour for us is a whole era for him.
What helps is giving him a warning before we leave. I’ll say, “We’re leaving for Grandma’s house in ten minutes. You can play for ten more minutes.” Then I set a timer on my phone. He watches the numbers count down. It doesn’t always work. But it works more often than just yanking him away.
The other thing that helps is not trying to make it perfect. I used to stress about matching the vibe of each house. I’d spend the whole ride to his mom’s prepping my son to say hello nicely and not beg for dessert before dinner. Then we’d walk in, and he’d hide behind my legs and refuse to look at anyone. My husband would say, “He’s just shy,” and his sister would say, “Did you not practice this with him?” I stopped practicing. Now I just let him hide. He warms up eventually.
I’ve also stopped trying to visit every grandparent individually. Last year, my husband’s parents were divorced and each had their own holiday thing. We tried to hit both in the same afternoon, and it was this frantic shuffle from one living room to another. By the end, our daughter was screaming, and I was sitting on the floor of a stranger’s bathroom, crying a little. We started a new rule: if a grandparent wants to see the kids, they can come to our house. Or we’ll do a separate weekend visit, not on the actual holiday. That’s been our big adjustment. We protect the actual day and spread the family time across the weeks before and after.
This year, we’re doing Christmas brunch with my mom on the 23rd, then seeing my husband’s parents for a mid-morning visit on the 24th, and on Christmas Day we’re staying home until noon. Then we’ll drive to my dad’s house, which is only twenty minutes away, for a couple hours. We’re skipping his cousin’s party entirely. I feel a small pang of guilt when I say that, but then I remember the year we went to four houses and I didn’t speak to my husband for a day.
More than any specific schedule, the biggest shift has been explaining things to the grandparents themselves. I had to have an awkward conversation with my mom where I said, “We can’t do everything. The kids are too young. We’re going to pick two visits per holiday, and the rest we’ll see another time.” She wasn’t thrilled. But once she saw that the kids were calmer, she got it. She stopped asking for more.
There’s also something to say about the kids’ own energy. A person under four doesn’t have the stamina for hours of social interaction. My son needs time to run around. He needs to eat at his usual intervals, or he’ll turn into a small monster. I’ve started carrying a bag of plain crackers and some sliced apples everywhere. It’s not glamorous, but it prevents about half of the meltdowns.
We haven’t figured out how to handle Hanukkah yet, since my husband’s family celebrates both traditions. That’s next year’s problem. We’re just going to try to keep the week before Christmas low-key so there’s some room for spontaneity.
I don’t have a neat answer for how to split time evenly or make everyone happy. My kids don’t care about fairness between households. They care about whether they feel safe and not rushed. So that’s what we prioritize now. We celebrate with people when we can, but the day itself belongs to our small family. When I think about it, that’s probably the real lesson: the holidays with young children are about survival, not about pleasing everyone. You do what you can, you say no without apologizing, and you leave a little room for the kids to be themselves.
Right now, my son is sitting next to me, eating a candy cane he smuggled out of my mother’s purse. My daughter is asleep in her pack-and-play. In an hour, we’ll pack up and drive to my husband’s aunt’s house, because we promised we’d stop by. I’m not looking forward to it, but I know it’ll be fine. We’ll have snacks, we’ll leave early, and the kids will probably sleep in the car on the way back. That’s as good as it gets this year.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How to Divide Holiday Family Time When You Have Young Children