My 1-Year-Old Is the Worst Middle Manager — Here’s What I Learned About Toddler Development
This morning, my son pointed at the bananas on the kitchen counter. I picked one up, handed it to him, and he shook his head. So I put it back. He pointed again. I picked it up again. He pushed my hand away. Then he looked at me like I had just failed a very simple assignment.
He is 14 months old. He cannot walk steadily. He can say about three words, one of which is “no.” And yet, somehow, he is the worst middle manager I have ever reported to.
It is not just the bananas. Yesterday, he pointed at the drawer in the living room. I opened it. He stared at it, pointed at it again, and I closed it. He pointed at it a third time. I opened it. He looked inside, found nothing interesting, and crawled away. Later, he handed me a block and then burst into tears when I placed it on the shelf instead of holding it over my head and announcing “airplane.” There is no clear chain of command. There is no written policy. There is only him, standing in a playpen, delegating impossible tasks with one small finger.
Being a middle manager is a strange job. You have enough authority to make demands, but not enough power to do things yourself. You depend on the people below you for every actual result. You spend your day sending messages, following up, and hoping nobody asks too many questions. My son is exactly that. He cannot reach the bananas. He cannot open the drawer. He cannot stack the blocks himself. So he hires me, unpaid, to do the physical labor. Then he reviews my work and sends it back for revisions.
I used to think this was just him messing with me. But watching him manage me has actually taught me a lot about what’s going on in his head.
Around this age, children start to understand that they can influence the world. They don’t have the words to tell us what they want, and they don’t have the motor skills to get it themselves. But they do know one thing: if I point at something, the big person in my life will do something. That’s not mischief. That’s an early form of communication. It’s the beginning of cause and effect. He points, I respond. He gets a reaction. That’s powerful.
It also means he is learning that people are separate from him. A one-year-old is just starting to realize that his desires are not the same as his caregiver’s. That’s a big step. When he points at the banana and I bring the wrong thing, he is not being picky. He is trying to tell me, “No, you do not understand my internal state yet.” The frustration is real. I just wish he had better performance review skills.
The truth is, he is a terrible communicator. But that’s not his fault. The part of his brain that handles language and impulse control is still growing. He knows what he wants, but he can’t hold the whole thought in his mind long enough to explain it. So he gets stuck. I can see it happen. We’ll be walking to the kitchen, and he’ll stop, point at the pantry, then at the fridge, then start crying. It’s not random chaos. It’s a failed boardroom pitch.
So what do we do about it?
I’ve learned to stop responding to every point as if it’s an urgent email. That was a big change for me. When he points at something, I try to give him a word for it before I act. If he points at the banana, I say, “Banana. You want the banana.” Then I hold it up and wait for a reaction. Sometimes he nods. Sometimes he points at the counter again. But the naming helps him start connecting the sound to the object. It’s a tiny vocabulary lesson hidden inside a power struggle.
I’ve also started offering him more choices, but only two at a time. “Do you want the red cup or the blue cup?” I ask, holding them side by side. He looks at both, reaches for the blue one, and for a second we are both on the same team. This doesn’t always work, but it helps. It gives him a sense of control without giving him the whole boardroom. If I asked an open-ended question like “What do you want to drink?” at this age, we would both be standing in the kitchen for hours.
One of the most useful things we’ve done is build what I call a “yes space.” His play area is set up so that almost everything in it is safe and okay to touch. Books are on a low shelf. Toys are in bins he can reach. There may be only one drawer left that I actually care about, and I put a childproof latch on it. Now when he points and demands, I don’t have to say “no” all the time. I can let him make little decisions for himself. That’s better for his development, and it’s better for my patience.
Still, some days are harder. Diaper changes have become a full-scale audit. This morning, the second I pulled out a clean diaper, he tried to escape. He ran—or, well, toddled—under the table, looked back at me, and laughed. I chased him, caught him, and he twisted and screamed like I was asking him to lay off half the department. But that’s not really about the diaper. That’s about his growing desire to be in charge of his own body. He knows what’s coming, and he doesn’t want it. It’s not a scheduling conflict. It’s a values clash.
When he fights the diaper, I don’t try to reason with him. I give him a toy or sing a silly song. I talk about what we’re going to do after. I keep my voice low. I don’t want to make every interaction into a negotiation. Sometimes, the adult just has to be the adult. That is not bad parenting. That is what a middle manager needs: someone at the top who is willing to make the final call.
In a way, he’s practicing for real life. These little exchanges, the pointing, the rejecting, the pointing again, are how he learns to ask for what he needs and to live with disappointment when he doesn’t get it. He is learning that sometimes you have to wait. Sometimes the answer is no. And sometimes you get the banana, but only after you push the hand away, pick it up yourself, and realize you don’t actually want it.
I am not sure there’s a neat ending to this story. He is still a one-year-old. He still points at things he cannot name. I still have to guess what he wants, and I get it wrong a lot. But I’ve stopped expecting him to be reasonable. That was my mistake at the beginning. I was treating him like a small adult with a bad attitude. He’s not that. He’s a person with a lot of big thoughts and no way to get them out.
So we keep doing our little dance. He delegates. I follow orders. He rejects my work. I try again. He gives me that look, like he’s one bad report from replacing me. But I know that look is also an invitation. He is not just bossing me around. He is bringing me into his world. And for a worst middle manager, that’s not a bad outcome.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 1-Year-Old Is the Worst Middle Manager — Here’s What I Learned About Toddler Development