Anti-Racism for a 5-Year-Old: Books, Conversations, and What Actually Worked
The question came on a Tuesday night during bath time. My daughter pointed at a picture book propped against the soap dish and said, “Why is his skin brown?” It was a book about a boy who loses his tooth, and the illustration had a Black grandfather in the background. I felt my shoulders tighten. I knew she wasn’t being hurtful. She had just noticed something out loud, the way five-year-olds do. But I wasn’t sure what to say. So I said something close to, “Because that’s his skin color. People have different skin colors,” and then I changed the subject.
Later, after she was asleep, I looked up “anti-racism resources for a 5 year old” and immediately felt worse. Many of the lists were for older kids or adults. Some recommended books that talked about police violence and slavery—important, but way too heavy for a child who still thought bedtime was a negotiation. Others were so abstract that even I struggled to understand the message. I ordered a pile of books anyway, hoping something would stick. Some did. Some went straight into the donation box.
I tell people this not because I have perfect answers. I don’t. But I have a pretty good sense now of what helps, what doesn’t, and why a conversation about race with a young child is usually quieter and slower than you expect.
First, it helps to know what a five-year-old is actually ready to understand. Five-year-olds notice physical differences. They notice that their friend has dark skin and they have light skin. They notice that another kid wears a headscarf. They notice that a character in a book has different eyes. They also have a strong sense of fairness—“It’s not fair” is basically their favorite phrase. That means anti-racism at this age is not about explaining systemic racism with all its history and nuance. It is about helping them see that people come in many different shades and shapes, that all of those are normal, and that treating someone badly because of how they look is wrong.
The books that worked were the ones that made those ideas visible without being scary. The Colors of Us by Karen Katz is a good place to start. It’s about a girl who walks through her neighborhood and notices all the different brown skin tones around her—cinnamon, chocolate, peach, butterscotch. My daughter was fascinated by the idea that you could talk about skin color the way you talk about colors in a crayon box. It gave us a way to name things out loud: this person has deep brown skin, this person has tan skin, you have fair skin. It might sound awkward at first, but naming skin color in a neutral or admiring way helps get past the idea that it’s a rude thing to mention.
Another book that stayed on our shelf is All Are Welcome by Alexandra Penfold. It shows a school day with families from different backgrounds, including kids wearing hijab, kids using wheelchairs, and families with two moms. There isn’t a heavy lecture. It’s just a picture of a daily routine where everyone belongs. It gave me an opening to say things like, “Look, that girl has a different skin color, and she’s playing with blocks just like you.”
Hair books also helped. Hair Love by Matthew A. Cherry is about a dad learning to style his daughter’s hair. My daughter loved it because there’s a silly cat in it, and I loved it because it shows a Black girl and her dad doing something completely ordinary. That seemed to matter: at five, kids don’t need books about struggle as much as books about everyday moments with kids who look different from them.
That said, I did try Antiracist Baby by Ibram X. Kendi. The message is thoughtful, but the rhyming text is clunky and my daughter asked to read something else halfway through. We put it away. That’s okay. Not every good book is good for every bedtime.
The biggest change happened outside of books, though. I bought a few puzzles with children of different skin tones. I swapped one of her baby dolls for a doll with brown skin, just as another option in the basket. I started putting on children’s shows that had diverse casts without making a big deal out of it. It felt too easy to be meaningful, but it may have been more useful than any book. At this age, children learn from what is in their everyday environment. If all their books and toys and shows repeat the same narrow images, they absorb that as normal. If they see a mix, they absorb that too.
There is also the matter of answering their questions in the moment. When your child asks loudly in a grocery store why the woman in front of you has darker skin, the natural instinct is to hush or deflect. I’ve done it. The better phrase is something like: “That’s just her skin color. People look different.” If the child follows up with “Why?” you can say, “Because of melanin, the stuff that gives our skin color. Some people have more, some people have less.” That sounds simple, but it answers the question honestly and avoids the weirdness of pretending race doesn’t exist.
Another thing that helped me was to stop trying to deliver a single “talk” like it was a school lesson. Anti-racism at this age is more about repetition and small moments. It’s saying, “I like how that friend shared a snack with you” and then later, “Wasn’t it mean when that character called someone a bad name?” It’s reading a book with a family who has brown skin and not always adding a moral at the end. It’s letting the images sit in your child’s mind without explaining everything.
I also learned to accept when a resource does not work. There is a lot of pressure to do this well, and sometimes a perfectly lovely book just doesn’t land. That’s not a failure. It means your child is five and has opinions. If a story about a march or protest makes them anxious, it’s okay to skip it and choose something about a child making a new friend. You can build up to more later.
The other practical thing I keep coming back to is to be honest about my own discomfort. If I am tense when a question about race comes up, my daughter senses that and learns that race is a taboo subject. The more I practice saying “people have different skin colors” without a dramatic pause, the more calmly she takes it. I still stumble sometimes. But I have a list of short, plain phrases now that feel like my own: People can look different. That’s one of the nice things about people. Does that look different from your skin? Yes. Isn’t that interesting? It isn’t poetic, but it works.
We are still figuring this out. I keep a few books on the living room shelf and rotate them. I try to mention skin color the same way I mention hair color or height, just as one detail among many. And I often remind myself that a five-year-old’s understanding of race is not the same as an adult’s—and it shouldn’t be. At this stage, the goal is not to teach my daughter everything. The goal is to make sure she learns the beginning: people are different, that is normal, and everyone deserves kind treatment. We read a little. We talk a little. We make mistakes and correct them. That counts for a lot, even when it doesn’t feel like enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Anti-Racism for a 5-Year-Old: Books, Conversations, and What Actually Worked