Why the College Gender Gap Is a Problem for Everyone (and What Parents Can Actually Do)
At the end of last school year, I sat in a folding chair in the high school gym and watched the annual awards ceremony. The principal read through scholarship recipients, department awards, and honors society names. Fourteen students walked up. Twelve were girls. The two boys both got athletic recognition.
I didn’t think much of it at first. Then my neighbor leaned over and laughed. “The girls are taking over,” she said. But her joke didn’t land. We both knew it wasn’t one school’s fluke. It’s a national trend, and it’s been building for decades.
In 1980, the college split was almost even. Now women make up about 60 percent of undergraduates, and men around 40 percent. The lead has grown steadily since then. On a typical campus, you’ll see about three women for every two men. This isn’t a story about one bad school year. It’s the direction we’ve been heading for a generation.
And yet we don’t treat it like a crisis. We joke about it at award ceremonies. We say boys are immature, or that they’ll find their way later. Sometimes they do. But the numbers say otherwise: millions of men are simply disappearing from higher education. That should worry every parent, not just the ones with sons.
I didn’t want to admit it until I saw it happening in front of me.
My son got through middle school by the skin of his teeth. He’s bright, curious, and misbehaves exactly enough to be disrespectful. His best friend Jordan was similar. Jordan loved building things. He could take apart a lawn mower engine and put it back together by the time he was thirteen. But ask him to write a report on the Industrial Revolution and he’d shut down. Not out of laziness. He just couldn’t see the point.
By sophomore year, Jordan was getting low C’s in English and math. He was placed in “college prep” classes, but nobody actually talked to him about what college could look like. He told my son one afternoon, “I’m probably going to be an electrician. That’s a real job, dude.” And it is. But he wasn’t choosing it from a plan. He was falling back on it because the path to anything else felt unfamiliar.
I thought about that a lot. We have a system that tells girls “go to college, you belong here” and tells boys “figure it out.” We don’t do it on purpose. It’s the subtle stuff: teachers who praise girls for turning in neat work and boys for being funny. Parents who accept “boys hate reading” as biological fact. Guidance counselors who push male students toward trades when a girl with the same transcript gets pointed toward a university.
None of this means college is right for every boy. But when a seventeen-year-old who loves engines never hears about mechanical engineering, we’ve failed him. The trades matter. But not every kid who says “maybe I’ll work with my hands” has actually considered how much of that work now requires a two-year or four-year degree. Building automation, medical equipment, environmental technology—these are fields that look like “shop class” but need post-secondary training.
The economic piece is what makes this not just a boy problem. Most jobs today require some kind of education after high school. Our enrollment rates are slipping for half the population. When fewer men graduate, we end up with two overlapping problems: critical jobs go unfilled, and workers without degrees pile into a shrinking pool of lower-skill positions, which pushes wages down. That’s not a “men’s issue.” That’s how you get a sluggish economy and frustrated families.
Still, as a parent, I needed something practical. Lecturing my son about enrollment statistics wasn’t going to do anything. So we tried small changes at home.
The first thing was we stopped saying “boys are late bloomers” in front of him. I knew I’d used that phrase as a comfort. But it also lets a child coast. It says “your teacher shouldn’t expect much.” Once we started treating homework like it mattered equally, something shifted. We didn’t change our expectations, just our language.
We also made reading less noble and more social. Instead of handing my son a novel, I bought biographies of athletes, graphic histories, and a collection of essays by astronauts. He rolled his eyes, but he read them. The rule wasn’t “you must read 30 minutes.” It was “you can’t use your phone until you’ve read 10 pages.” Ten pages is nothing, but it built momentum.
The bigger change came from checking in with his teachers before anything went wrong. Twice each semester, I sent a short email: “How is he doing in class? Does he seem engaged or lost?” Usually the answer was somewhere in between. But in ninth grade, his math teacher wrote back, “He hands in homework but doesn’t ask questions. I think he’s bored, not confused.” That led to a conversation about moving him to a different level, which changed his whole attitude. If I had waited for a report card, he would have coasted for another year.
The most awkward but important step was normalizing help. My son thought asking a teacher for extra time or a counselor for organization tips meant he was dumb. We had to say it directly: “Using support is what successful people do. Nobody gets through college by lying about needing help.” He rolled his eyes, but he started going to a study hall run by a biology teacher after school. It wasn’t a big deal, and that was the point.
Jordan’s story took a different turn. He almost didn’t graduate with a GPA high enough for the local community college. But his dad finally sat down with a guidance counselor and learned that the electrical program at the community college trains into a two-year degree in applied technology. That was the first time Jordan heard there was a path between electrician and engineer. He’s now a freshman, and he’s doing okay. Not great, but okay. He’s still not the kind of student who turns everything in on time. But he knows college can include him.
I’m not writing this to say we’ve solved it in our house. Far from it. The gender gap is massive, and no single family, classroom, or school district can reverse it. Our schools are still designed around the way girls’ brains are encouraged to organize themselves. Our economy still sends mixed messages about what it means to be a man. And our culture still treats “college boy” as a suspicious identity in a way “college girl” is not.
But I’ve learned that the problem won’t fix itself with speeches about falling enrollment. It gets fixed in the ordinary spaces—the car ride home, the quick email to a teacher, the phrase we use when a boy says “I don’t need college.” We don’t have to force every son into a degree. We do have to expand what he thinks is possible.
The economy will force us to deal with the rest. I just hope we don’t wait until the college enrollment numbers get even worse. By then, the boys who fell between the cracks will be adults, and we’ll all be paying for it. Not in statistics, but in the service that doesn’t get staffed, the design that doesn’t get built, the family that can’t get ahead. The girls at that awards ceremony will be fine. They’ll go to college, get their degrees, and lead. The question is whether the boys sitting next to them will still be waiting for someone to tell them what’s possible.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why the College Gender Gap Is a Problem for Everyone (and What Parents Can Actually Do)