What to Do When Your Child Doesn’t Get Into Theater Club: A Parent’s Reflection
I was parked at the curb a little early, watching the school doors. When she opened the car door and climbed in, she didn’t say hello. She dropped her backpack on the floor, clicked her seatbelt, and stared at the dashboard.
“How was your day?” I asked. Not really a question.
“I didn’t get into Theater club.”
She said it flatly. Not crying, not angry. Like she’d been sitting with it for five hours and had used up all the reaction already.
I knew how much she’d wanted it. She’d been singing the spring musical songs around the house since January. She practiced her monologue in front of the bathroom mirror, adjusting her hand gestures because I told her they looked stiff. She wore her lucky sweater to the audition. And now, apparently, none of that mattered.
My first instinct was to say something like “Their loss” or “They don’t know what they’re missing.” I bit it back. I’ve been a teacher long enough to know those phrases never actually land. They just shut down the conversation.
So I sat with it for a second. “That’s disappointing. How did you find out?”
She shrugged. “The list is posted outside the drama room after school. My name wasn’t on it.”
We sat in the car in that weird silence where you can hear the engine idle in a way you never usually notice.
“Do you want to talk about the audition?” I asked.
She didn’t answer right away, but she also didn’t turn away. Then, slowly, it came out. She felt good about the first part of her monologue, but then she lost concentration and forgot a line. The drama teacher had to prompt her. She said that threw her off for the rest of the piece. Then the singing—she described it as “a little thin,” and I heard her voice crack a little when she said the word “thin.”
I could have jumped in right there and said, “That happens to everyone,” or “You probably did better than you think.” But that’s the other thing I’ve learned: when a kid tells you how they messed up, they’re not asking for reassurance yet. They’re just telling you the story. If I interrupt with comfort, they stop talking and start listening to me instead of processing the experience.
So I just said, “It sounds like your nerves got the better of you on the monologue.”
“Yeah,” she said. “I practiced it so many times. I just couldn’t get the words out.”
Here’s what I know from the other side, too. I’ve run plenty of auditions and selections in my own classroom—not for theater, but for school teams and events. I’ve had to take six kids when forty apply, and I’ve sat there looking at perfectly fine kids who just didn’t fit that particular group for reasons that had nothing to do with their value or even their talent. Maybe we needed two who could play defense. Maybe one role got cast early because of seniority. Maybe the group needed someone who could sing bass for this specific piece.
Selection isn’t an assessment of worth, but it sure feels like one when you’re on the receiving end. Especially at that age, a list on a door might as well be an answer to the question: “Am I good enough?”
When she told me that the club had only taken eight of maybe thirty kids, and that the show this year had a small ensemble, I felt like I could give her something real to hold onto. Not a promise of future success, but a fact. The odds weren’t good. It was like trying out for a band that only had one spot for a backup singer against people who’d been taking vocal lessons for years.
What actually seemed to work that evening was also really unglamorous. We ordered tacos, we didn’t talk about it for a bit, and then I asked her if she wanted to talk about what she liked about the audition itself. At first she thought I was being weird. “I didn’t like it, Mom. I froze.”
“No,” I said. “I mean, what part of the process—the practicing, the trying out, the being in that room with other kids doing something they were nervous about—even if the ending was bad, what part did you enjoy?”
She thought about it. “The practicing, maybe. And when I finally got through the whole monologue at home, the first time without forgetting, that was good. There was actually a girl I rehearsed with before we went in. We both were shaking. We kept messing up our lines on purpose to make each other laugh.” She smiled for the first time since getting in the car.
I think that moment was more useful than anything I said to her directly over the next few days.
For parents who are going through this kind of thing, here’s what I’d actually recommend, because I’ve tried it and learned it the hard way. First, don’t ask “Why didn’t you get in?” even though it’s the first thing that comes to mind. Most kids don’t actually know why, and the question makes them feel like you think they should have done something differently. Instead, I asked how she found out, and then eventually what the audition room was like. Those questions let her tell the story without feeling examined.
Second, wait before you comfort. The urge to say “It’s their loss” is strong, but if you jump in too fast, you block the rest of the story. I waited, and the real feelings came out a few minutes later—the embarrassment of forgetting a line, the awkwardness of walking back to class knowing other kids had seen the list. If I’d interrupted with reassurance, she probably would have just shut down and held it in.
The other thing that helped most was separating “this specific group” from “everything in the future.” Twenty-two kids didn’t make that club. I reminded her that she rehearsed for weeks, that she went into that room and performed even though she was terrified, and that those things aren’t canceled by the outcome. I didn’t use the word “resilience” with her, and I didn’t promise next year would be different. I just pointed to what I saw her do that took courage, whether or not it ended in a yes.
A few days later, we found a community theater program that runs a big open ensemble—they take everyone, no auditions. She’s not sure about it yet. She said it’s “different” and went back to her phone to scroll something I couldn’t see. I didn’t push it. That’s still there, waiting.
What’s different now is that the list on the door isn’t running her life. The spring musical came and went. She didn’t go see it for a long time, and then one Saturday two months later, she went with a friend from math class who also hadn’t gotten in. When she came home, I asked how it was. “It was good,” she said. “I could tell who the actors were. I know some of them.” She said that last part a little quietly, and I could see she was thinking about whether she might try out again next year.
The conversation isn’t finished. It might not be finished for a long time. She still gets quiet sometimes when someone mentions the club. I don’t have a neat ending to write here. She hasn’t decided if she wants to get back on that stage, and it’s not my call to push her. What seems to be working is that we keep talking about it in small pieces, whenever she brings it up, without me delivering a speech about bouncing back. For now, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do When Your Child Doesn’t Get Into Theater Club: A Parent’s Reflection