Why the College Gender Gap Is Every Parent’s Problem (Even If Your Kid Is in Kindergarten)
The line outside the high school career center snaked past the water fountain. I was there for the annual financial aid workshop, but my son, a junior, was nowhere near the front. He stood at the back, arms crossed, eyes on his phone. The other parents were nodding along to a slide about FAFSA deadlines. I looked at my son. He looked up, shrugged, and muttered something about how college “wasn’t really his thing” anyway.
That was two years ago. He’s now in his first semester at a community college, taking two classes and working part-time at a hardware store. He’s fine, mostly. But I can’t shake the feeling that something bigger is happening around us, something that isn’t just about my kid or his grades.
The truth is, the college enrollment gap between men and women has been growing for decades. For every 100 women who enroll in college, roughly 88 men do. In some states, it’s even wider. And while this is often framed as a “men’s issue” or a talking point for commentary shows, the economic consequences are spreading far beyond any one group. It’s becoming a workforce problem, a family problem, and a local economy problem.
I didn’t see it when my son was in elementary school. He liked Legos, read at grade level, and had friends. But by middle school, something started shifting. His focus in class waned. Homework became a negotiation. His teachers said he was bright but “not applying himself.” I heard that phrase so many times I started to tune it out.
What I didn’t tune out were the numbers I started noticing at work. I’m not an economist, but I manage a small team in a logistics company. Over the last decade, we’ve had trouble hiring entry-level analysts. The job requires a bachelor’s degree, mostly because it involves data analysis and technical writing. We get tons of applications from qualified women. We get very few from men. When I mention this to other managers, they nod like they know exactly what I mean.
This isn’t a conspiracy. It’s a pipeline problem. Traditional male-dominated trades like welding and electrical work are in high demand, and plenty of men are doing just fine without college. That’s real. But the economy is also shedding middle-skilled jobs that don’t require a degree. Manufacturing has changed. Even good warehouse jobs now involve managing inventory software. The people who thrive in those roles tend to have some post-secondary education, whether it’s a degree or a certificate.
So when we say “college isn’t for everyone,” we’re right. But we’re also ignoring the fact that the version of college we’re talking about—the four-year residential degree with dorms and dining halls—is only one path. The community college route, the technical certificate, the online program: those are all on the table too. And yet, many boys I talk to don’t even see those as options. They just see “more school” and decide it’s not for them.
I remember a conversation I had with my son in his sophomore year. He was failing geometry. I sat on his bed, trying not to sound like a guidance counselor. “What’s going on?” I asked. He said, “I’m just not a school person.” That phrase stuck with me because I realized he had absorbed an identity, not a fact. He wasn’t bad at learning. He was bad at asking for help, bad at sitting still, bad at caring about a test score that felt abstract.
What helped him wasn’t a lecture about the future. It came from a small change at his high school. One of his teachers started a “men’s lit” elective. It wasn’t about gender wars. It was just a class that read stories about working-class guys, about fathers and sons, about the fear of being useless. My son came home one day and said, “We read this story about a guy who works on a fishing boat, and it was actually good.” That was the first time in years he’d voluntarily mentioned reading a book.
That teacher did something simpler than I thought. She gave boys a chance to talk about what matters to them, not what matters to the curriculum. She used discussion prompts that weren’t about “how does this make you feel?” but “what would you do differently?” She also changed the grading rubric to allow for oral presentations instead of only written essays. My son aced a presentation on a character’s confrontation with his boss. He talked for ten minutes without a single note.
This is the kind of thing that doesn’t require a grand policy change. It can happen in a regular classroom. But it requires noticing the gap, and most schools are still not noticing it. When I bring up the male enrollment numbers to my son’s school administrators, they say, “Oh, that’s a bigger societal issue.” And it is. But it’s also an issue that shows up in a ninth grader’s decision to stop trying in algebra.
So what can parents actually do, in real life, that isn’t just “talk to your kid”? From my experience, three things helped.
First, I stopped referring to college as “college” and started talking about “what comes after high school.” That sounds like a word game, but it matters. My son had built up an image of college as a place where you sit in lectures and write papers. He didn’t see himself in that image. But when we started talking about trade schools, certification programs, and even two-year degrees that lead to specific jobs, he perked up. The word “college” was the problem, not the education.
Second, I started asking different questions. Instead of “How was school?” I asked, “What was the most interesting thing you heard all day?” Often he didn’t know. So I asked, “What was the most boring thing?” That got him talking. Turns out, he found economics fascinating when it involved sports betting. So we found a class that discussed statistics through sports. That class was the reason he started to see math as useful rather than punitive.
Third, I made a rule in our house: no one uses the phrase “real job” to describe a career that doesn’t require a degree. My father-in-law used to say that to my son, meaning it as a compliment about trades. But my son heard it as a dismissal of anything he might actually enjoy. So now we say, “that pays well” or “that helps people” or “that uses your strengths.” It sounds superficial, but it changes how a kid estimates the future.
The larger economic picture is still scary. The earnings gap between men with degrees and men without degrees is growing. That means more men will struggle to find stable, well-paid work. That affects marriage rates, homeownership, and child-rearing. It affects our social fabric in ways that aren’t captured in a headline. And it affects our towns, because a workforce with a shredded middle is a workforce where too many doors are locked.
But I’m not writing this to doom you. I’m writing this because I’ve sat on the floor of my son’s room and watched him learn to like himself again, one small assignment at a time. He’s not on a four-year path. He might never be. But he’s in a classroom, learning a skill, and he’s not counting himself out anymore.
The gap isn’t going to close because some politician announces a new grant program. It’s going to close because a teacher lets a kid do a presentation instead of a paper, because a parent swaps “college” for “training,” because we stop assuming that a boy who doesn’t fit the mold of a classroom is a boy who doesn’t want to learn.
My son is still figuring things out. His job at the hardware store is okay, but he’s been talking about a certification in building inspection. That would require one more year of school, and he’s considering it. I didn’t push the idea. He came up with it himself, after a customer told him he had a good eye for detail.
I don’t know if he’ll follow through. But I know he’s no longer staring at his phone while other people plan his future. That’s a start. And for the economy, for our families, for the next generation of young men, it’s the only start that counts.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why the College Gender Gap Is Every Parent’s Problem (Even If Your Kid Is in Kindergarten)